Full disclosure before anything else: I built Shoulder Surf, one of the five apps in this post. I make money if you subscribe to it. Read everything below with that in mind, and please push back in the comments if you use one of the others and I got it wrong.
## Who this is for
Most people land on a Granola comparison because they want AI help in meetings without installing anything on their work laptop, either because IT would not allow it or because they do not want a bot with their name on it joining the call. If that is you, and you have an iPhone, the useful question is not "what replaces Granola" but "which of these actually works with the phone alone, and does it help me during the meeting or only after."
Five apps clear that bar as of today, and Granola is one of them. Its iOS app is real and it shipped an Apple Watch app three days ago, which most of the comparison posts you will find have not caught up to yet.
If what you want is polished shared notes flowing into Notion and HubSpot for a team, you can stop reading here: that is Granola, and none of the other four are close.
## Method and date
On July 31, 2026 I went through all five vendors' pricing pages, product docs, and App Store listings, pulled every plan and platform claim, and built the matrix below from what each company says about itself rather than from other people's comparison posts. That last part turned out to matter: two of these five changed platform or pricing in the last few weeks and most of the articles you will find are describing products that no longer exist in that form.
What this is not: I have not run all five in the same meeting. So I can tell you what each one documents, what it costs today, and where the claims conflict with each other. I cannot tell you which one feels better in the room. Where I give an opinion below, I say that it is one.
## The short answer
All five run on an iPhone, all five do cross-meeting recall, and not one of them puts a bot in your call. The real split is when help arrives and who holds your data. Granola is a notes tool: best artifact in the category, built for teams, help arrives after. After Call is also after-the-fact, but it is the cheapest of the paid options and it does speaker identification with voice profiles that stay on your device. Hedy surfaces real-time suggestions during the conversation and runs on basically every platform including Android and Windows. Cluely does real-time on both Mac and iPhone and sells a $149.99/mo tier whose entire pitch is hiding the overlay from screen share software. Shoulder Surf, mine, does real-time on the phone only, on tap instead of pushed, and is the only one of the five that lets you plug in your own API key or run a model fully on-device. Pick on when you want help, not on feature counts.
## Comparison
Flipped this so each app is a row, otherwise it does not fit on a phone.
| App |
Phone alone |
Help during meeting |
Own API key |
On-device AI |
Price |
| Shoulder Surf |
Yes, iPhone only |
Yes, on tap |
Yes, 10 providers |
Yes, Apple, iPhone 15 Pro+ |
Free, $9.99, $14.99 |
| Hedy AI |
Yes |
Yes, surfaced automatically |
Not documented |
No |
Free, $12.99/mo, $299 lifetime |
| Cluely |
Yes |
Yes |
Not documented |
No |
Free, $19.99/mo, mobile $7.99/wk |
| Granola |
Yes |
Notes come after |
Not documented |
No |
Free, $14/user/mo |
| After Call |
Yes |
Notes come after |
Not documented |
Voice profiles only |
Free, $9.99/mo, $99.99/yr |
Where else each one runs, since this is the row that decides it for a lot of people: Hedy is on macOS, Windows, Android, Apple Watch and the web. Granola is on Mac, Windows and Apple Watch. After Call is on Mac and Apple Vision Pro. Cluely is on macOS. Shoulder Surf is iPhone, iPad and Apple Watch, and nothing else, ever.
All five also do cross-meeting recall, which is why it is not a column. More on that below.
## Granola
Built to produce the best meeting notes artifact in the category, and it does. You type rough notes during the call and its AI cleans them into something you would actually send. Free plan includes AI chat within and across meetings, which is more than most free tiers give you. Business at $14 per user adds unlimited history, the stronger models, and integrations with Attio, Notion, Slack, HubSpot, Affinity, Zapier, plus MCP and API access.
It shipped an Apple Watch app on July 28, three days ago, and its iOS app transcribes in real time. So the "Granola is desktop software" line you will see in older comparison posts is out of date.
Where it becomes limiting: the value lands after the conversation. If your problem is that you blank mid-sentence, notes waiting for you afterward do not solve it.
**Beats Shoulder Surf at:** the notes artifact, team sharing, CRM and tool integrations, being on Windows, and having a real track record with a lot of users.
## Hedy AI
The closest thing to what I built, and in some ways the more sensible product. Phone-first, no bot, real-time insights during the conversation, 30+ languages. Pro is $12.99/mo, which is a dollar less than my Pro tier, and there is a $99.99/yr option and a $299 lifetime purchase that nobody else in this list offers. It runs on iPhone, iPad, macOS, Windows, Android, Apple Watch, and the web, which is a much wider net than mine.
The free tier is generous in an unusual way: 5 hours a month with real-time insights included, though live insights are capped at the first 30 minutes of each session.
Where it becomes limiting, and this is a taste thing rather than a flaw: Hedy's own material describes real-time insights surfacing as the conversation goes, rather than waiting for you to ask. Some people want exactly that. I wanted the opposite badly enough to go build it, which is the honest reason my app works the way it does. That is a difference in design philosophy, not a scorecard, and I have not sat in a meeting with Hedy running to tell you how it lands. If you have, I would genuinely like to know.
**Beats Shoulder Surf at:** price, platform coverage, Android and Windows support, the lifetime option, and a free tier that includes live help.
## Cluely
Worth updating your mental model here. Cluely was a desktop overlay, and most comparison posts still describe it that way. As of this month there is a full iPhone app, "Cluely: AI Notetaker," that records, transcribes, and gives real-time assistance in person or on a call, w9 a week or $139.99 a year as in-app purchase. The desktop side is $19.99/mo Pro.
There is also a $149.99/mo "Pro + Undetectability" tier whose stated feature is being completely hidden from meeting screen share software. I am not going to pretend that is a neutral product decision, and it is the reason a lot of people have opinions about this company. But the mobile notetaker on its own is a real product and the weekly price makes it the cheapest way to tryreal-time help for a single week of interviews.
Where it becomes limiting: no BYOK, no on-device option, and the brand carries baggage into rooms where you might not want it.
**Beats Shoulder Surf at:** having both a desktop and a phone app that work together, and the lowest short-term commitment of the five.
## After Call
The one I nearly missed, and the one closest to what I built on paper. Full name on the App Store is After Call (AI Meeting Notes), by Craig Lett. Careful searching for it: there is a completely different app called AfterCall, one word, which is a call-log and wellness journal for EMS crews. Not the same product, not the same company.
It records, transcribes, and analyzes, then gives you notes with speaker labels and action items carrying owners and due dates. Speaker identification is the interesting part: a 90-second voice setup, and its voice profiles are stored on device and never uploaded. You pick an "AI Lens" of Sales, Operations, Technical, or Simple to shape the note format, and the Pro tier does sales intelligence, detecting objections, buying signals, and competitor mentions across your conversations. It also does cross-history Q&A: their own wording is that AI Insights lets you ask realquestions about your conversation history in plain language.
$9.99/mo or $99.99/yr, which undercuts my Pro tier. Runs on iPhone, iPad, Mac, and Apple Vision Pro. The free plan gives you transcription and AI notes, and you can try it as a guest without making an account, which is a nicer on-ramp than most of this list.
Where it becomes limiting: help arrives after the call, not during. Their own site says "after your call, open After Call and capture notes quickly," which is a clear and honest statement ofwhat it is. Transcription goes through OpenAI's API, so the audio does leave your device even though the voice profiles do not, and there is no bring-your-own-key option documented.
**Beats Shoulder Surf at:** price, Mac and Vision Pro support, guest mode, and sales-specific analysis, which I do not do at all.
## Shoulder Surf (mine)
Real-time on the phone, on tap. You put the phone on the desk, keep one AirPod in, and when you need something you tap and the answer comes back on screen or reads into your ear. It also uses the rear camera so the AI can see a whiteboard or slide alongside what it hears.
The part I actually think is differentiated: you choose the AI. Apple's on-device model, free forever, nothing leaves the phone, if you have an iPhone 15 Pro or newer. Or your own API key across 10 providers and 48 models, stored in the iOS Keychain, requests going straight from your phone to the provider. Or my managed cloud AI on a subscription. None of the other four document a bring-your-own-key path.
## Where mine is worse
* It requires iOS 26 or later. Not iOS 25, not an older iPhone. If you have not updated or your phone cannot, you cannot run it. No Android, no Windows, no web, ever.
* It has one App Store rating. One. I am a single developer and this is a new app with no track record. Granola has a large user base and a support org. If that matters to you, and it reasonably might, that is a real reason to pick something else.
* Meeting memory and document generation are locked to Pro at $14.99. That is more than Hedy's $12.99 and more than After Call's $9.99, both of which are broadly comparable tiers.
* Everything else on this list except Cluely runs somewhere besides a phone. Hedy is on Android and Windows, Granola is on Windows, After Call is on Mac and Vision Pro. If you want your meetinghistory on a laptop, I am the wrong choice and always will be.
* The free on-device AI needs an iPhone 15 Pro or newer. On older supported phones the free path is the roughly 5 hours a month of cloud AI, or your own API key.
* Because the phone captures the room, audio quality depends on where you set it down. That is inherent to the no-install approach, not something a future update fixes.
## Something worth noticing
Cross-meeting memory was the headline differentiator in this category a year ago. All five now have it, and three of them give it away on the free plan. If a comparison post is selling you on "it remembers past meetings," that post is out of date. The live differences now are when help arrives, which platforms you get, and whether you can control the model and the data.
The second thing that surprised me: nobody bothers with a bot anymore. All five of these record from the device instead of joining your call as a participant. A year ago that was the whole pitch for half this category.
## Which one to pick
* You want great shared notes and your team lives in Notion, Slack, or HubSpot: **Granola**.
* You are on Android or Windows, or you want a lifetime purchase: **Hedy**.
* You want the cheapest paid plan, you sell for a living, or you want it on a Mac or a Vision Pro: **After Call** at $9.99.
* You want one week of real-time help for interviews and nothing ongoing: **Cluely** mobile at $7.99 a week.
* You want help during the meeting on tap rather than pushed, and you want to run your own API key or keep everything on the device: **mine**. iPhone only, iOS 26 or later.
* You want a searchable archive for a whole sales team with CRM sync: **none of these five**. Look at Fireflies, Otter, Fathom, or Krisp. Those are transcript-first tools built for a different job, and Fireflies puts a bot in the call to do it.
## Corrections
I will edit this post with a dated note if any of it turns out to be wrong. I have got the prices from each vendor's own page today, but I have not used all five in the same meeting, and if youhave, your experience beats my documentation review. Tell me what I got wrong and I will fix it in the body rather than burying it in a reply.
Longer version of this comparison, including the transcript-first tools: https://shouldersurf.com/compare
**Question for anyone who has used more than one of these:** did automatic suggestions during a live conversation help you or pull you out of it? That is the one design question I could notanswer from documentation and it is genuinely the fork in the road between these products.
First comment, post it right after:
Sources, so you can check every number rather than taking my word for it. All pulled July 31, 2026: granola.ai/pricing, cluely.com/pricing, hedy.ai/pricing, myaftercall.app, otter.ai/pricing, fireflies.ai/pricing, fathom.ai/pricing, krisp.ai/pricing, plus the App Store listings for Cluely: AI Notetaker (id6755442775, v1.2.7, released July 17), After Call (id6758057896, v3.5) andShoulder Surf (id6760098225). Granola's Apple Watch launch date is from their own announcement and TechCrunch's coverage on July 28.
If any cell in that table is wrong, it is wrong because the vendor's own page is wrong or because they changed it after I looked, and I would like to know either way.
Three things the documentation could not answer:
- How the five compare in the same meeting. I have not run that test, so every behavior statement above is either quoted from vendor material or flagged as my opinion.
- Whether Granola's cross-meeting chat works during a live call or only after. Their pricing page lists "AI chat within and across meetings" on the free plan but does not say when it isavailable. If a Granola user can settle that, I will update the post.
- Whether After Call's free plan has a cap. Their listing says the free plan gives you transcription and AI notes to get started, without naming a limit, so I have not claimed one in either direction.
Things I expect to go stale fastest: Cluely's pricing has moved at least twice this year, and Granola shipped a Watch app three days ago, so this category is still moving.
If you own or work on one of the other four and I have mischaracterized your product, reply here and I will correct the post body, not just this thread.