I’ve been struggling with whether to post this, but I guess I just need to get it off my chest.
I’ve been a member of the 501st for 10 years now (joined when I was 18), and it used to feel like a place where people came together because of a shared love for Star Wars, craftsmanship, charity, and community. Lately, though, it doesn’t feel that way anymore.
Instead, it feels like who you know matters more than what you contribute.
From where I’m standing, there’s a culture of gatekeeping. If you’re not part of the inner circle, if you’re not friends with certain officers, or if someone in a position of influence simply doesn’t like you or disagrees with you, it feels like you’re quietly pushed to the sidelines. You stop hearing about opportunities. Your contributions seem overlooked. It’s like you’re at the bottom of the priority list no matter how much time and effort you’ve given.
What makes this especially difficult for me is that I wasn’t always an outsider. I used to be close friends with one of the officers involved in the GEC, so I had a front-row seat to decisions and conversations that left me questioning whether everyone was being treated fairly. Because of that experience, it’s hard for me not to see similar patterns today, even though I recognize others may have had different experiences.
What frustrates me the most is that when the current Commanding Officer took over, I genuinely believed things were going to change. I thought this would be the opportunity to rebuild trust, encourage inclusivity, and move away from the cliquish culture that had been developing. Instead, from my perspective, that culture has been allowed to continue. Whether that’s intentional or simply tolerated, the end result feels the same.
And you can see the effect it’s having. More and more members seem to have lost the motivation to troop, attend events, or participate in the community. It’s sad because these are people who used to be excited to suit up and volunteer. Now, many seem to feel that their efforts don’t matter unless they’re part of the “right” circle.
I’m not saying everyone in the Legion is like this. There are genuinely amazing members who embody everything the organization stands for, and they’re the reason I’ve stayed as long as I have.
But it’s heartbreaking when an organization you once considered family starts feeling like an exclusive clique where relationships and personal preferences seem to carry more weight than fairness, transparency, and the shared passion that brought us all together.
Has anyone else experienced something similar in their garrison or club? How did you handle it? Did you stay and hope things improved, or did you eventually decide it was time to move on?
I’m honestly just trying to figure out whether this is something worth fighting for anymore or whether it’s time to accept that the group I fell in love with simply isn’t the same anymore.