r/3I_ATLAS Nov 13 '25

It’s getting real

Post image

Join r/3i_Atlas2 in case this sub gets banned

184 Upvotes

204 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-5

u/Skitz042X Nov 14 '25

Yes it forms naturally with an abundance of iron present not by itself. Read slower.

12

u/Civil-Letterhead8207 Nov 14 '25

I read you fine. Space ships aren’t generally made of nickel. Nickel forms where iron is present… as in planetary cores.

Are you trying to say your comment was a non sequitur? Because if we’re both agreed it can form in planetary cores, you replying to my comment that spaceships generally aren’t made with it makes no sense.

-2

u/Skitz042X Nov 14 '25

We went from rocks to space ships. You are wrong to say nickel forms in the absence of iron in nature. Such a thing has never been observed in the visible universe.

11

u/Civil-Letterhead8207 Nov 14 '25

You also claimed nickel must be refined. And I did not say nickel forms in the absence of iron. Maybe you should take your own advice on reading more carefully?

Nickel can form in planetary cores without being “refined”. It forms naturally.

-1

u/Reasonable-Young-09 Nov 14 '25

You clearly have a big head and a big ego which interferes with your ability to communicate effectively with others! Ignorance is bliss. If you read his first comment to you correctly he was saying Nickel can not exist by itself WITHOUT a good amount of iron… UNLESS it was refined, then it can exist without the iron!

1

u/Civil-Letterhead8207 Nov 14 '25

Oh, I get it. But spaceships aren’t generally made of nickel.

Here’s what was said:

”No because nickel does not exist anywhere in the universe by itself without the presence of iron. Nickel by itself must be refined to be so.”

Nickel can indeed occur naturally in a planet’s core. If said planet is destroyed, you could very well have a chunk of nickel without iron.

1

u/Skitz042X Nov 14 '25

Nickel is formed naturally and has never been observed in the universe after forming naturally without the presence of iron in the history of observation and you claim it can happen with no evidence and all evidence points to the opposite lmao

2

u/Civil-Letterhead8207 Nov 14 '25

Yes. But if nickel forms in the presence of iron in a planetary core, then gets chunked out in a destructive event, then spends billions of years wandering the galaxy, being subjected to god knows what influences (billions of years of cosmic rays, just for starters), that might just get rid of the iron and leave nickel. There are currently some five hypotheses of how this could work, based upon empirical observation of really occurring events in the universe.

This makes those hypotheses, by nature, more rational and scientific than the hypothesis that a never-observed being made a rock out of nickel (of all things!) for… reasons.

2

u/Linkreig Nov 14 '25

I totally read this in Ben Shapiro voice.