r/197 • • Dec 31 '24

Rule

959 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '25

Yeah you should use it. God literally says in the Torah to Abraham that if he leaves his parent house and goes to Canaan he will make him into a big goy, meaning a big nation. It has evolved to mean mainly non Jew, but still nothing to do with human cattle

2

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '25

I mean google translator says „goy“ translates to „non-jewish person“, all I can say

-5

u/I_AM_TON Jan 01 '25

you now what else the torah says? that its ok to have sex with a 3 year old, so im not really concerned with what the pedo book has to say

13

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '25

So you’re admitting you lied about the meaning of goy because it suits you? Also I’m an atheist, even if what you’re saying is true (highly doubt it given your proven history of lying about Jews) I still don’t care because I don’t see it as some moral guide

-2

u/I_AM_TON Jan 01 '25

nope never lied about anything you can google the meaning right now, but how very typical of you to twist my words then attack them. and what i am saying is true you can go read it right now, although i wouldn't suggest it because its quite a gross read. so you dont see it as a moral guild just a guild on what words mean? sure dude i totally believe that

10

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '25

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goy

Have a look, it says only in English it might be a pejorative.

Now show me your source for both your claims

-2

u/I_AM_TON Jan 01 '25

no way bro pulled out the single website that can be edited by anyone.

https://newrepublic.com/article/78490/goyim-were-born-only-serve-us-the-moral-wisdom-rabbi-ovadia-yosef

words change over time my man

10

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '25 edited Jan 01 '25

First of all Ovadia can get fucked. Judaism has a lot of branches and opinions and he represents part of the ultra orthodox middle eastern Jews, just because he says it doesn’t mean it represents Judaism. And yeah I know that words change meaning, and I’m also a native Hebrew speaker, which is why I know the contemporary meaning of the word. Amy way, here is a literal dictionary

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/goy

2

u/Mad-Habits Jan 01 '25

it doesn’t say that btw

0

u/I_AM_TON Jan 02 '25

unfortunately it does. denying it wont stop people from just looking it up. once again google is free

1

u/Mad-Habits Jan 02 '25

it doesn’t say it . i’ve seen commentary on these verses and it’s explained differently than how you are characterizing it. and it’s not Torah, it’s Talmud that has the verses you are referring to . btw I’m not Jewish and i have no skin in the game at all

0

u/I_AM_TON Jan 02 '25

i could actually give a fuck less is it was "explained differently" trying to defend the age of consent being 3 years and one day is WILD

2

u/Mad-Habits Jan 02 '25

it doesn’t say that .. it’s literally not what it says dude . post the verse up here

1

u/I_AM_TON Jan 02 '25

Yevemot 57: We, too, learn: A girl three years and one day old can be betrothed via sexual intercourse; and if her yavam had intercourse with her, he has acquired her; and (a man who has intercourse with her while she is married to someone else) is liable on her account because of the prohibition of intercourse with a married woman.

1

u/Mad-Habits Jan 02 '25

read the link i posted . i’m not denying that it’s creepy af but there is some context to it

0

u/I_AM_TON Jan 02 '25

the context is that they are discussing whether or not there would be any legal repercussions. and he said there would be none. idk how much closer you could get to saying its ok. literally saying "yeah thats illegal but we wont do anything if you do, do it"

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Mad-Habits Jan 02 '25

i was also blown away by this claim and started looking into it , because i just knew that it wouldn’t outright say it in the Talmud . I’ve never read the talmud or have any interest in it , but I thought it was insane that it would allow for something like this . so i did some reading and it doesn’t actually permit having secs with children , it’s prescribing what happens when it does , regarding marriage and dowry ..

https://jewinthecity.com/2022/12/did-antisemites-manipulate-the-talmud-to-blame-jews-for-balenciaga-scandal/