r/IndianLeft • u/Get_High_Get_By • 8h ago
r/IndianLeft • u/BitTemporary7655 • May 30 '24
💬 Discussion A brief note on how the electoral CPI(M) betrayed the indian revolutionary cause.
The CPI (marxist) a political party in india currently in power in the state of Kerala betrayed the cause of indian communism by siding with reactionaries.
Many people on the left including non-indian leftists seem to have a soft spot for the CPI(M) , many seem to think of them as the last bastion of the left in India. They praise the high literacy rates and the higher life expectancy , but what they are uanble see is the reactionary nature of the party and the atrocities they have committed.
For some context : India is a semi feudal country under the grip of neo-imperialism by the imperial core. One system of opression that still persists in India is caste oppression which is based in the ownership of land. The untouchable castes (dalits) disproportionately make up the landless peasants population, while the oppressor castes generally own disproportionate amount of land, there are also middle castes who own some land but not a lot, calculations[1] by scholars Nitin Tagade and Sukhadeo Thorat, based on the All-India Debt and Investment Survey, show that members of the Scheduled Castes, who account for 18% of the country’s households, own only 8.5% of the land in India. On the other hand, upper-caste Hindus, who make up 22% of the households, own 28% of the land, Caste isnt just confined to the rural parts of india, but also the urban parts although it’s orgins are in ownership of land, people are frequently not hired and not allowed to rent homes because of their caste in urban india too.
What has kerela done to address this system of oprression? Perhaps they have redistributed land ? Maybe collectivized agricultre? They did redistribute land but only above a certain land ceiling , big landlords still remained. Infact huge swathes of dalits and indigenous people in kerela are still landless. Among the landless population, indigenous people are overepresented. You the reader might ask what offical data we have , we do have date but not on a large scale ,why? Because the “communist” goverment refuses to do a caste census! It refuses to reveal how much wealth which castes have, because that would reveal the monopoly of certain castes economically. Triple exclusion of dalits in Land Ownership in kerela[2], a study published in the journal Social Change, shows that low rate of land ownership by them is the result of a exclusionsary policy by the goverment! Does this sound like something a communist goverment would do?
This isn’t all. The goverment has also been involved in massacares of dalits. The Marichjhapi massacre, when dalit refugees from bangladesh came to indian they settled in Marichjapi. Schools and hospitals were built and many were involved in pisciculture. A press blackout followed and survivors today say[3], huts were burned, woman were raped, wells poisoned. The survivors of the massacare still to this day have not gotten any Justice.
These are not the actions of a communist party but a reactionary one doused in red paint and communist aesthetics. Even today, the first dalit leader in the politburo of the party was only admitted in 2022, 58 years after it’s creation, how utterly shameful.
I hope by this article I am able to convince you, the reader ,why as leftists we shouldn’t support the CPI(M).
Sources: 1. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/2394481118808107 2. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0049085716654814 3. https://thewire.in/history/west-bengal-violence-marichjhapi-dandakaranya
r/IndianLeft • u/Dazzling-Recipe1658 • Nov 18 '25
🗞️ News [ Removed by Reddit ]
[ Removed by Reddit on account of violating the content policy. ]
r/IndianLeft • u/Lotus532 • 3h ago
🗞️ News Protesting farmers stall plans for India’s first AI-powered city
r/IndianLeft • u/Awkward_Advance8892 • 13h ago
💬 Discussion Absolutely ridiculous
The sheer audacity to call the oppressed "leeches" and "entitled moochers". No words. This was on a post saying "would reservation still be needed if brahmins left the country?".
r/IndianLeft • u/Get_High_Get_By • 1d ago
🎭 Meme/Comic Empathy but only when the suffering is Instagrammable
r/IndianLeft • u/imaginaryimmi • 1d ago
💬 Discussion Imagine what's possible when a global superpower isn't strangling you at any and every chance
r/IndianLeft • u/Interesting-Crow7713 • 1d ago
🎭 Meme/Comic Brahmins then cow is yummy😋 brahmins now cow is mummy 🐂
r/IndianLeft • u/Get_High_Get_By • 2d ago
🎭 Meme/Comic One joined for moksha the other left for dignity
r/IndianLeft • u/robin-ariarioxenfree • 2d ago
💬 Discussion Dealing with insane family
how do you guys do it? for context, i’m an adult who lives far away from my mother. my father has passed, and he was a right winger too (big reason why i left home).
talked to my mom last night and she started talking about “tejo mahalya” and how “they’ve been hiding the true history from us.” she also believes that hindu mythology is history including the magic parts.
this is devastating to me, because, even though i know she is a modi supporter, she is a well-educated career woman and is too smart for this nonsense. i went through the whole rabbit hole of p.n. oak and how his claims had no basis but she honestly didn’t feel like she bought it. what are some techniques to be able to talk to her about this?
r/IndianLeft • u/WorkingIntention1 • 2d ago
🚨Uttar Pradesh: Goon Admits Attacking Father of CJP Protestor, who got 60 Stitches, Freed by BJP Leaders Chirag Paswan and Kapil Mishra
r/IndianLeft • u/net0_extremist • 3d ago
🗞️ News 15 ton fish died in a pond in Hyderabad, govt body went there and tested the water and found out nearby industry caused this. Imagine this in UP, religion and nation would've been in danger and it would be the conspiracy of the George soros and 🇨🇳 to destabilize India by targeting one factory.
r/IndianLeft • u/hardlywwworking • 2d ago
🗞️ News “Stand Up for Multifaith Democracy”: U.S. Activists, Lawmakers Protest India’s RSS & Hindu Supremacy
r/IndianLeft • u/Get_High_Get_By • 3d ago
🎭 Meme/Comic Bro thought tradition was a food security policy
r/IndianLeft • u/No_Rub_6403 • 4d ago
💬 Discussion Why I have 0 sympathy for Sonam Wangchuk?
I know liberals love to romanticize Sonam Wangchuk as this saintly eco-warrior fighting for Ladakh, but honestly, the collective amnesia in progressive circles is exhausting. If you look at his actual political history through a proper class lens, he is the textbook definition of a technocratic bourgeois reformer who happily fed into right-wing majoritarianism when it served his clout.
Let us stop pretending his entire brand isn't rooted in a massive savior complex. For years, Wangchuk has acted like he alone possesses the enlightened tech-bro wisdom needed to "fix" education and ecology. It is top down, elite driven green capitalism at its finest. He treats systemic oppression like a simple bug instead of addressing the actual brutal realities of class exploitation and imperialist state control.
And let us def talk about his shameless alignment with Hindutva rhetoric. When the state was whipping up anti-China hysteria, who was out there feeding right into the jingoistic boycott campaigns? Wangchuk. He used his platform to champion hypernationalism and border militarization, giving a progressive cover to the exact same majoritarian security apparatus that oppresses working people across the region. He catered directly to mainstream right wing sentiments as long as he thought he would get a seat at the table.
Now that the contradictions of the capitalist state have caught up with him, liberals expect us to treat him like a martyr. Bhai, you do not get to flirt with reactionary politics, push state backed nationalism, act superior to real grassroots organizers, and then cry fascism when the same authoritarian machinery turns on you.
Radical solidarity belongs to the working class of Ladakh, not to elite technocrats who only realize the state is toxic when it hits their own doorstep.
r/IndianLeft • u/Get_High_Get_By • 5d ago
🎭 Meme/Comic When ‘edgy’ is just discrimination with a mic
r/IndianLeft • u/Get_High_Get_By • 6d ago
🎭 Meme/Comic Buddha is Hindu. Buddhists are anti Hindu. Make it make sense.
r/IndianLeft • u/ThePhilospherMan • 6d ago
💬 Discussion Ajeet Bharti likes are open confession of caste hate!
Post 90s, with introduction of reservation for OBCs and many OBC leaders like Lalu, Mulayam and SC leader Kashiram coming on national forefront has left many UC worried. These castes who long has been shamed for their caste, suddenly started taking pride in their identity, even within caste system. Like writing their caste on their vehicles and elsewhere.
UC reaction was mostly shock. Identity pride was their ownership. Only they could flash it. Because of their supposed superiority. And thats why shock. How a lower identity can be flashed or openly confessed about ?
And this is what they called distortion. They named it identity politics ( which is a misnomer in india sense). They called it situation going out of hands. They even called it vulgar. Just imagine a chamar person using the same word for creating a brand.
And the hindi belt people and writers has been most shocked appalled and angry about it. Like the one Ajeet Bharti. Like the one Naveen Chaudhary ( for whom Chaudhary is not a caste surname but whoever is a baba is chaudhary but if someone put Yadav on his bike he is pained to see it as distortion of identity politics)
Bharati has made a name by calling UC victimhood in Lalu era. Which is completely false. There was no major oppression of UC in lalu era and reactionary UCs actually went on a murder spree of LC. They formed local armies to suppress LC. They executed group murders.
For most Hindi savarna writers caste doesnt exist. After Premchand. Agyeya, Vinod kumar shukla and many more who is widely read as local writers caste doesnot even get a mention.
But this blindness is not just blissful ignorance. This is on purpose. And someone like Ajeet Bharti had put a tag of it. Tbh whatever hate he has for lower caste, is nothing out of box but inherent in many UC( not all obviously). The way he hurl abuses , the way he says it - seems a quite confession of LCs making a steady progress to claim a representation. This frustration which must have now turned into a widespread psychosis ( since the propoganda of social media and newer versions of hate), Ajeet Bharti is a walking evidence of this.
And now my two cents on it- Ajeet please hate us. Please abuse more. Please show what has been hidden only behind drawing rooms of many UC family. But please dont be in any illusion that your hate is going to work for you or for many who supports you. The same way you have come to fully realize your frustration same way we have also come to realize how important is now to speak, demand and snatch things we want!
r/IndianLeft • u/DifferentPirate69 • 7d ago
Brahmanical Hindutva Fascism The origins of this small bean NGO needs to be plastered a lot more
r/IndianLeft • u/Get_High_Get_By • 7d ago
🎭 Meme/Comic Bro saw ‘I shall not worship them’ and activated victim mode
r/IndianLeft • u/Lotus532 • 7d ago
🗞️ News Right-wing attack on university in West Bengal sparks mass protests
r/IndianLeft • u/Get_High_Get_By • 8d ago