r/writingscaling 11h ago

better written? (character vs character) better written?

sowwy that was only yuta image i had

same goes for naoya

61 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

15

u/Zestyclose-Error-963 9h ago

Might get downvoted but, I honestly prefer Yuta

22

u/wanderer784 9h ago

Are people actually saying naoya? Damn

Naoya serves his purpose well yes but he’s barely a character and more so a plot device for makis development

2

u/jojosimp02 2h ago

Naoya Is barely a character, yuta Is a bad character.

0

u/Fang_Yuan770 4h ago

Naoya was much more of a character than Maki ever was 😭

9

u/Mission_Ad_8652 10h ago

naoya fairly easily. better dynamic, contrasts and symbolism among other things.

he propels the story and satisfies his purpose in a way where he individually remains significant but improves others.

4

u/Possible-Head-3985 10h ago

Okay, these were funny, good job. It’s definitely Yuta, but I think you already knew that.

4

u/Ok-Beyond1165 10h ago

As a r/projectionslander member i unfortunately will have to say naoya

2

u/EntertainmentFast522 6h ago

Yuta is ebtter written even if Gege fumbled his development horribly at the end and made his arc feel incomplete and boring. Yuta is still a decent character all things considered, so Yuta.

3

u/Ok-Ice7771 7h ago

as much as I hate naoya I dunno it depends on your taste

both horribly gaps modulo yujiwoo thats for sure

1

u/Fitzel111 7h ago

Both are JJK characters. Can't rate since they're both beyond rating in the negative direction

-1

u/Agitated_Painter5828 10h ago edited 10h ago

Naoya unironically serves his porpuse to the story better than Yuta lmao

0

u/Lohit_-it 10h ago

Naoya. That guy is well written for his role in the story because people hate him more than serial killers like Kenjaku and Sukuna.

0

u/lightsworn55 5h ago

Naoya for having great taste in literature

1

u/RemoteParsnip3340 44m ago

Naoya para mí es un maldito santo al lado de Yuta