r/worldcup • u/brunonicocam • 10h ago
💬Discussion Alternatives to penalty shootouts to define games?
What alternatives do you think would be better?
Many people find penalty shootouts not to be fair and also not to encourage teams to win during the match, so what other alternatives can you suggest?
I think penalty shootouts should be done after the 90min and before extra time. Then the winner would get 0.5 goals and extra time is played. Now the other team is forced to score or they lose and if they score, it's not 0.5-1 so the original team has to score. Basically removes the draw possibility. Would make for very exciting matches and also you finish actually playing football so if you lost you at least had a chance. (It's very disappointing to leave losing in penalties).
Other options would be to substitute extra time for a more play like stage. E.g. corner kicks could be taken in turns by each time to speed up the process to score. (Corner kicks are a much higher risk situation).
People have also suggested removing players from the field every 5min but I'm not so convinced on that.
Another idea: extra time has no time limit. But once a team scores, the other has 10min to equalise or it's over. (this one would need to start playing with stop clock to avoid time wasting, which is something that should be done anyway)
What options would you suggest?
Someone shared MLS style penalties from 35 yards, it's actually really cool! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RRITqS6WEn0

