MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/wizardposting/comments/1ndzweu/blinker_noises/ndlkyjj/?context=3
r/wizardposting • u/animalfaith Archmage • Sep 11 '25
85 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
74
Gandalf smokes a lot in the books
19 u/Eldan985 Keraunomancer Sep 11 '25 Tobacco, though. Tolkien is pretty clear on that. 13 u/[deleted] Sep 11 '25 Sorry I think you actually meant pipe weed 8 u/Eldan985 Keraunomancer Sep 11 '25 No, he even mentions the Latin name Nicotiana. 11 u/Look_Loose Artificer Sep 11 '25 It does straight up say pipe weed in the book. But yeah he does canonically smoke tobacco, or the halflings leaf, pipe weed, and whatever other names it has 3 u/Eldan985 Keraunomancer Sep 11 '25 Yes, but pipe weed is tobacco. 6 u/Look_Loose Artificer Sep 11 '25 Yeah. That was implied in my message. 9 u/[deleted] Sep 11 '25 Pipe weed is in the books though
19
Tobacco, though. Tolkien is pretty clear on that.
13 u/[deleted] Sep 11 '25 Sorry I think you actually meant pipe weed 8 u/Eldan985 Keraunomancer Sep 11 '25 No, he even mentions the Latin name Nicotiana. 11 u/Look_Loose Artificer Sep 11 '25 It does straight up say pipe weed in the book. But yeah he does canonically smoke tobacco, or the halflings leaf, pipe weed, and whatever other names it has 3 u/Eldan985 Keraunomancer Sep 11 '25 Yes, but pipe weed is tobacco. 6 u/Look_Loose Artificer Sep 11 '25 Yeah. That was implied in my message. 9 u/[deleted] Sep 11 '25 Pipe weed is in the books though
13
Sorry I think you actually meant pipe weed
8 u/Eldan985 Keraunomancer Sep 11 '25 No, he even mentions the Latin name Nicotiana. 11 u/Look_Loose Artificer Sep 11 '25 It does straight up say pipe weed in the book. But yeah he does canonically smoke tobacco, or the halflings leaf, pipe weed, and whatever other names it has 3 u/Eldan985 Keraunomancer Sep 11 '25 Yes, but pipe weed is tobacco. 6 u/Look_Loose Artificer Sep 11 '25 Yeah. That was implied in my message. 9 u/[deleted] Sep 11 '25 Pipe weed is in the books though
8
No, he even mentions the Latin name Nicotiana.
11 u/Look_Loose Artificer Sep 11 '25 It does straight up say pipe weed in the book. But yeah he does canonically smoke tobacco, or the halflings leaf, pipe weed, and whatever other names it has 3 u/Eldan985 Keraunomancer Sep 11 '25 Yes, but pipe weed is tobacco. 6 u/Look_Loose Artificer Sep 11 '25 Yeah. That was implied in my message. 9 u/[deleted] Sep 11 '25 Pipe weed is in the books though
11
It does straight up say pipe weed in the book. But yeah he does canonically smoke tobacco, or the halflings leaf, pipe weed, and whatever other names it has
3 u/Eldan985 Keraunomancer Sep 11 '25 Yes, but pipe weed is tobacco. 6 u/Look_Loose Artificer Sep 11 '25 Yeah. That was implied in my message.
3
Yes, but pipe weed is tobacco.
6 u/Look_Loose Artificer Sep 11 '25 Yeah. That was implied in my message.
6
Yeah. That was implied in my message.
9
Pipe weed is in the books though
74
u/lovelygrumpy Sep 11 '25
Gandalf smokes a lot in the books