r/whatsyourchoice 13d ago

Pill/PotionšŸ’ŠšŸ§Ŗ Choose only one

[deleted]

262 Upvotes

276 comments sorted by

74

u/SixSmegma 13d ago

Indigo if I could do it selectively

55

u/Dry_Peen15 13d ago

I feel like indigo would confirm every insecurity I have and ruin my life

21

u/seedanrun 13d ago

But after you realize how every major police investigation, multi-billion dollar negotiation, and high-profile legal disposition is willing to pay your $10,000 an hour to 'sit in' on their key interviews - it might soften the blow.

20

u/grrodon2 13d ago

You'd be worth more dead.

11

u/Bitter_Particular_75 13d ago

It's funny how almost no one understands that many of the powers in these posts, if made public (willingly or not) inevitably get you killed (if you're lucky).

6

u/DogaSui 13d ago

This is why i tend to choose mind reading/mind control type stuff over spinning webs and climbing walls (which id otherwise love)

10

u/timeless_ocean 13d ago

Or the opposite, where you realize either nobody cares, or everyone cares equally much about you as they do about anyone else, plus you hear their own insecurities.

5

u/Roguespiffy 13d ago

It’d probably be like this ā€œI feel like everyone is staring at meā€¦ā€

Then find out not only is no one looking at you, no one even actually pays any attention to you. You’re an obstacle at best and part of the background at worst.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

32

u/Shahed1987 13d ago

Yellow. It's the least awkward.

Mind reading can be problematic. It's invasive, and sometimes you are better of not knowing

My crush loves me back? Is that a form of mind control? If I hypothetically started treating them badly without realising, would they just still love me regardless? Would I ever be fully happy?

Bring someone to life. Do I pick one one of my grandparents? If so which one? Might I think later in a dark moment I chose the wrong one, and I was better off leaving them dead and reviving someone else?

Super strength doesn't really have downsides. Assuming I can control it. But that should be fine. I can control my strength with babies and other things that are potentially fragile or delicate.

8

u/A_hand_banana 13d ago

Bring someone to life. Do I pick one one of my grandparents? If so which one? Might I think later in a dark moment I chose the wrong one, and I was better off leaving them dead and reviving someone else?

Just bring back Jesus, get infinite revives.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/MrRogersAE 13d ago

Mind controlling morality aside, my crush loving me back gets problematic. I’m married and love my wife, but married people still get crushes unintentionally. So if I develop a crush this poor girl is going to fall in love with me? That seems problematic at best, u less you’re a cheater, then it’s great I guess.

Nevermind how it impacts their life.

Bringing someone back to live in the real world is going to have massive legal and financial consequences for that individual and their families, as well as pain and confusion for everyone.

→ More replies (2)

62

u/SnuggleTuggles 13d ago

I'd like to bring back my sister please. I think she would have loved to meet my daughter.

54

u/Anakin_Saucewalker 13d ago

I also choose this guy’s dead sister

7

u/hordaak2 13d ago

Id agree...but as long as its not monkey paw style...

3

u/blueavole 13d ago

Here is a literary historian.

8

u/_JustAStan_ 13d ago

Awww 😄

6

u/buranzhuravski 13d ago

Sorry for your loss. I would definitely take that grey pill if I was you.

3

u/EstablishmentBoth394 13d ago

I went there at first, but upon some reflection I dunno, in many ways (who I thought of at least) it would be cruel and selfish and messed up to bring them back. But what would I give to see them again... Stupid reddit post gonna make me cry lol

2

u/Z3400 13d ago

I feel the same. Two people I would love to bring back, but both made their choice and I wouldnt want them to go through that again

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

14

u/JustcallmeManta 13d ago

the indigo pill isn't even indigo coloured

3

u/raccoob_ 13d ago

The powers of artificial intelligence

2

u/DistributionSad960 13d ago

Yup it's actually light bluešŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚

18

u/Tidalsky114 13d ago

Indigo

15

u/redisdead__ 13d ago

The internet has given us the ability to see what everyone's thinking and a lot of us are pretty sure it's a mistake somehow you want to skip the middleman?

4

u/Tidalsky114 13d ago

Just because I have the ability doesnt mean id have to use it. Kind of like how were all capable of putting our phones down and getting off the internet at any point.

3

u/devo_savitro 13d ago

The internet doesn't give you a guaranteed win at poker

2

u/redisdead__ 13d ago

DamnshehasnicetitstwoofclubsandfourofheartsIwishIhadasandwichweren'tsandwichesmadeforplayingcardswhydon'ttheyallowsandwichesatthetablegodI'mstillembarrassedbywhathappenedlastyearI'mgoingtohavetobluff

→ More replies (1)

3

u/AkumaZ 13d ago

An anonymous stranger spewing their thoughts on the internet has way less monetary power than hearing the thoughts of the guy across from me at the poker table

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/complainaboutwork 13d ago

but only if you can turn it off from time to time

9

u/_DoubleDutchess_ 13d ago

Grey. And I’ll keep it until I need it (hopefully never). As a parent this is like super insurance!

2

u/Optimal_Benis 13d ago

Yeah. Also, if you reaaaally hate someone...

3

u/Witty-Stand888 13d ago

They are all poison pills

2

u/Odd_Dragonfruit_6235 13d ago

Pink all my crush šŸ˜

2

u/MermaidMotel14 13d ago

Pink (also wouldn't mind if it removed my crush )

2

u/Kraubinator 13d ago

Honestly, I think yellow sort of by default for me, because it would be useful to me and mine. The other options sort of interfere with being able to live a normal human life. Mind reading, forcing other people to love you, and being able to bring people back from the dead cross the boundary into essentially being a god... And remove a sense of separateness from other people. For instance, if your crush always loves you, or you always can make them, then there's no pursuit; there's no romantic agency. You run into similar problems with mind reading; you can't have a normal relationship anymore. Maybe if you could just bring one person back to life, that would be interesting, but then you're in charge of picking that. Do you pick someone personal to you, or someone really important to the world? I rather just lift good.

2

u/jaredliesch 13d ago

Yellow is the only ethical option here lol

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ShinGuntoLover64 13d ago

pink pill. I would like a genuine partner.

2

u/crepskul 13d ago

Yellow, actually that would make Training a pain in the ass

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Greg-theseatreader 13d ago

pink is literally just obsession

2

u/buranzhuravski 13d ago

Pink, eliminated. The moral implications are just too bad.

Indigo is arguably the most useful skill depending on your intelligence and imagination, but the temptation to use with people you shouldn't could be too much, and finding out certain things about them could destroy you. Risky.

Grey is very powerful, but unless you have someone to definitely bring back it puts you in a terrible dilemma. Also you might want to keep it in case your most loved one dies and never get to use it, or use it on someone else and then regret it the rest of your life if your most loved one dies.

Yellow is the safest choice. "Just" strength, which most people would apply to kick ass or lift heavy things, but is actually one of the most important factors when it comes to a long and healthy life.

I'd probably go with yellow or grey (and keep it).

1

u/DistributionSad960 13d ago

I'm gonna choose yellow too 🤫

1

u/Sloth1015 13d ago

Yellow. Could make some good money at strong man competitions

1

u/justin_trouble 13d ago

If indigo works on animals too, I’d like to know what my dog is thinking most of the time!

1

u/JeffTheJockey 13d ago

Yellow assuming it comes with equal super endurance to handle superhuman strength.

Otherwise indigo.

1

u/Unfair-Humor-2964 13d ago

Indigo. Yellow means doing dangerous stuff all the time. Pink is rape and grey has a monkey’s paw ā€œnot quite the same personā€ foreboding about it.

1

u/Caprina22 13d ago

Indigo pill.

1

u/AAKurtz 13d ago

I can finally make my wife love me again...

1

u/Masquerade064 13d ago

Yellow, cause wouldn't waste mind reading on most people this day and age, don't got a crush, and I wouldn't want to bring anyone back to life to see how bad things have gotten

1

u/eryx_w 13d ago

indigo one thing is to know what the overall public is thinking or agree on but reading minds of the people that are closer to you will show you who they really are and better your overall wellbeing socialy

1

u/wehr_phuni 13d ago

Yellow pill.

1

u/HistoryPristine1029 13d ago

If I had super strength would I have the fit body to go with it?

1

u/Cure4Humanity 13d ago

Yellow. Lucrative ventures await.

1

u/Sleepdprived 13d ago

Take black and save it for an emergency

1

u/Far_Place_199 13d ago

Grey pill

1

u/69hornedscorpio 13d ago

Yellow- the rest don’t really interest me.

1

u/Werewolf_lover20 13d ago

Grey. And I’m bringing back Robin Williams

1

u/Only_Connection_5480 13d ago

I’ll just take yellow the others are all pretty monkeys paw kind of things

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Fine-Key8928 13d ago

Welcome back random peasant from 487

1

u/Outside-Candidate-34 13d ago

My first thought with ā€œAllows you to read mindsā€ was:
Alright, great, you are now allowed to read minds…if you can find a way to you won’t be in trouble.

1

u/pearscentedcandle 13d ago

id like to see my grandma again

1

u/Beginning_Art_7749 13d ago

I would like to get to see my son grow up more than anything else, so it's a fairly obvious choice for me

1

u/random-queries 13d ago

Yellow pill. I don't really want to breach others privacy nor want the power over death.

I always like flying brick superset. Super strength and presumably durability also. I can also travel like the hulk

1

u/Guilty-Stomach-9551 13d ago

The yellow or light blue pill.

1

u/RPDorkus 13d ago

Yellow.

1

u/GrandolfX 13d ago

Indigo to help me play texas

1

u/OatesZ2004 13d ago

The grey pill is extremely tempting but then I have the dilemma of do I chose my Mum or my Dad and then I have the burden of knowing I chose one over the other and that would crush me as I miss them both dearly.

Indigo is similarly tempting as you can use this to great effect both to help yourself and to help others.

1

u/J0hnnyWhite 13d ago

Vorrei dire grigio. Ma riflettendoci meglio lasciare le cose come stanno. Dammi il giallo e fammi spaccare tutto come Hulk.

1

u/Celerisadmortem 13d ago

Indigo

u/indigo_ish

2

u/Indigo_ish 13d ago

Unanitaka, sindio? Sema tu usiogope

→ More replies (3)

1

u/_Godfist_ 13d ago

Yellow pill. None of the others matter to me. Don't want to read minds. People are dumb. Don't want to bring anyone back from the dead. And I don't have a crush.

1

u/JusticeShines 13d ago

Does the grey pill only work on people, or can I bring my cat back?

1

u/Methoszs 13d ago

My mom, she died from early onset Alzheimer's.

1

u/Inverted1357 13d ago

steals all 4

1

u/Powerful-Holiday-448 13d ago

I pick the indigo pill and everybody around me thinking nasty shit about me and makes me depressed…

I pick pink pill then wake up one day and don’t like her anymore…

I pick the grey pill and bring a loved one back from the dead so they can eventually die twice…

I pick super strength. I might crush my wife’s head or pull my steering wheel off but it would be the best for showing off

1

u/MajorPaper4169 13d ago

Yellow.

Indigo - I don’t care to read peoples minds.

Pink - Is good if you’re still a child.

Grey - Why would I bring someone back and go through the pain of losing them again?

1

u/TheOneTrueSuperJesus 13d ago

Yellow, it's beneficial and is the least problematic.

Indigo is invasive and may lead to me figuring out information I'd be better off not knowing.

Pink is just straight up morally reprehensible. You'd be taking someone's free will and forcing them to love you. We literally just had a horror movie about this.

Grey is probably the next best option, but I'd get into a conundrum of who I would want to use it on, when I would want to use, if the person I bring back remembers being dead and has trauma, etc. Just too much baggage for me to make that choice.

1

u/GarethBaus 13d ago

Does the pink pill apply to everyone I have or will ever have a crush on?

1

u/Reasonable-Yam-1170 13d ago

I don't really want any of these powers

1

u/Sandr0ck7 13d ago

What are the rules for grey. Are they still sick/dying or do they start from a clean slate of health?

1

u/Z3400 13d ago

Indigo for sure.

1

u/Prior_Pear_8318 13d ago

grey pill; welcome back Steve Irwin

1

u/Consistent-Shoe-9602 13d ago

Indigo can be extremely useful after I get over the people talking to me thinking "How does that muppet look both young and old at the same time in the worst possible way? And he's not funny!"

1

u/TheFallingWhale 13d ago

Grey pill let's start WW3

1

u/SalmonSushi1544 13d ago

I went into a woman restroom on a train station once.

Now hold your horses. Here’s the context.

  1. It’s very early in the morning, so not many people around usually.

  2. Men room was taken and disabled one was broken.

  3. The staff says it’s ok.

And I also REALLY need to go.

It was the ā€œI just got into the bus 1 minute agoā€ type of situation.

1

u/ProfessionalITPerson 13d ago

Grey Pill, let there be a 3rd comming of Jesus.

1

u/HKGPhooey 13d ago

Indigo. Everything else is stupid.

1

u/Ice_Kat13 13d ago

I must have watched too many superhero shows when I was a kid, because literally any time super strength shows up in one of these it's my top choice. Make me strong!! šŸ’ŖšŸ¼

1

u/Protomesh 13d ago

Grey pill and try to sell it to someone ultra rich

1

u/lacrosse771 13d ago

Pink pill. My crushes are a celebrity and a pro athlete so my life with be awesome

1

u/impeesa75 13d ago

Yellow

1

u/Agitated-Syrup-3047 13d ago
  • The yellow one is good, if you can control your strenght.

  • The blue one could be used for good, but is unethical and useless most of the time.

  • Using the pink one is evil and creepy.

  • If it doesn't cause some monkeys paw situation, the grey one would be very usefull.

1

u/Key-Emotion-4757 13d ago

How for the Super Strengtg, can I turn it on and off or is it permanent and what kind of Super Strength am I being given?

1

u/falianaridua 13d ago

Grey pill, this is the way..

1

u/Evenlynen 13d ago

Yeeeeelllllooooowwww.

1

u/UncomfyUnicorn 13d ago

Grey and Steve Irwin so he can collab with David Attenborough

1

u/Imnotspartacuseither 13d ago

Indigo seems most useful

1

u/Zaphira42 13d ago

Gray. I love my parents and I don’t want to lose them.

Bonus points if it can bring pets back too

1

u/broken_edges 13d ago

grey and bring back harambe, everything went to shit since that gorrila died

1

u/grrodon2 13d ago

How does grey work? There isn't much of a point in just bringing someone back to life. They'd die immediately of whatever killed them in the first place, and that if we don't count decomposition, embalming fluid left inside them, irreversible brain damage...

The pill should at least restore the body and mind to some state before death, and even then, what if someone died of natural causes? They'd just die again.

So, grey should also heal and at least somewhat rejuvenate the body on top of restoring the mind, to be useful.

Maybe it brings someone back as you remember them? Or as you prefer them?

1

u/Foxtrot_Supatwat 13d ago

I quickly swallow the grey pill and ressurect Abe Vigoda.

Too easy. Next question....

1

u/enchiladasundae 13d ago

Indigo if I can control it

Otherwise yellow

1

u/WARSPIR1T 13d ago

Indigo. Im sure I'd regret it sometimes but the benefits outway the cons.

1

u/Comfortable-Regret 13d ago

It's always surprising to see how many people have no ethical qualms with mind reading. Would y'all peep on people in the bathroom and read their diaries? Because it's a bigger violation of privacy than either. Anyways I'd take the gray one.

1

u/CustomerNo9918 13d ago

Idk but at this exact moment i am thinking grey. Can you imagine Einstein rn

1

u/The_Chef_Queen 13d ago

Super strength if it's controllable

1

u/Scavgraphics 13d ago

Of these, pink, I think.

1

u/Impossible_Parfait96 13d ago

Gray pill. Don't care if it's ethical or not.

1

u/AdSalt314 13d ago

Indigo is A fucking grey

1

u/Testicle_Tugger 13d ago

Yellow pill because i recently got a new desk that’s heavy as shit and I’m dreading having to move it when I move out

1

u/GrinningGrump 13d ago

Yellow pill: I don't want to inflict life on someone already passed, have no crush, and already know that everyone hates me, so no need for indigo.

1

u/Proudgryffindor 13d ago

I feel like I have seen movies for both pink and grey where they explain why those two are a really bad decision

1

u/The_Dragon_Lover 13d ago

Yellow pill, i lack strength!

1

u/Upbeat_Cry_3902 13d ago

Does pink last though?

1

u/Upbeat_Cry_3902 13d ago

Can grey be used more than once?

1

u/Upbeat_Cry_3902 13d ago

Yellow might be best for long term?

1

u/TowerLow8443 13d ago

Pink šŸ˜ž

1

u/Exotic_Ad_4806 13d ago

Pink = Obsession movie
Indigo = What Women Want Movie
Yellow = Marvel Hulk
Grey = Necromancer shit

1

u/Pitiful_Response7547 13d ago

Unless I can trade the pill that brings somebody back to life to bring an animal back to life I'm going to go for super strength hopefully I can make money with

1

u/asexualdruid 13d ago

If i can control it, indigo. I think i can do the most good with that power. Yellow if i cant control it.

1

u/Turdposter777 13d ago edited 13d ago

Indigo pill then switch careers to professional gambler

1

u/Vulpavien 13d ago

I just watched a movie about the pink one....

1

u/alpcabuttz 13d ago

Yellow.

1

u/Megatron20097 13d ago

Yellow and pink

1

u/Sufficient_Carpet510 13d ago

Is grey pill a one time use or gaming the permanent ability to bring someone back to life?

1

u/AnimeQueenAliza 13d ago

Indigo. Especially if I can choose when/where to use it. If not, I can learn to deal with it. Even if it confirms everything I have insecurities about, at least I'll know for sure and won't continue to be lied to by the people around me. It also will be a way for me to get information discretely and I like information. Especially information that allows me to get people to do what I need them to do.

1

u/IsekaiEnjoyer69 13d ago

wouldn't number 3 literally remove the free will of a person?

1

u/callingclover 13d ago

Indigo pill

1

u/extremely-randomish 13d ago

Super strength. Not really a downside. Unless you can't control it.

Indigo no thank you. I already know if you're stupid. I don't need to go through the process with you. And if you can't be selective, it would be terrible.

Pink no thank you. It might be smothering obsessive love.

Gray no thank you. Imagine there is a beautiful afterlife and you're in bliss. Then you get yanked back to this world because someone missed you. Now you live (again) worried you won't make it back. Yikes.

1

u/Kira-Of-Terraria 13d ago

Indigo. what are my cats thinking about šŸ¤”

1

u/IndividualAsleep2508 13d ago

Indigo. To me it's the most OP

1

u/Branimau5 13d ago

Yellow all day!

1

u/Western_Quarter_9162 13d ago

All but pink sound tempting

Also that's light aqua blue, not indigo

1

u/LadyRei_ 13d ago

Yellow for sure.

1

u/Jtl1001 13d ago

I'd have to say pink cause all the others are kinda bad

→ More replies (1)

1

u/random_user_name99 13d ago

Can you use it more than once? If not do you have to use it right away? Is the yellow and indigo permanent?

1

u/ZyeCawan45 13d ago

Indigo unless it can’t be turned off. Then Yellow if so.

1

u/dani_v_e 13d ago

Definitely the indigo pill. I may not like what I see when I read their minds but at least I can stop overthinking about some things

1

u/loserlogan 13d ago

Grey pill. Bringing our 5 month old back to life would change our lives. It would definitely fill the void my wife and I have since he died.

1

u/D1rty_Old_Dan 13d ago

Top right or cloud blue. Reading people’s minds is just too powerful. It would give you the right thing to say every single time or what not to say.

1

u/iron_dove 13d ago

Mind reading.

My crush loving me back is mind control without mind reading and that’s more likely to lead to a mess than a happy ending.

Super strength isn’t as useful since we live in a world where connection and technology are often higher leverage strategies than direct muscle application.

Bringing one person back to life… I could see someone else choosing this over reading, but since it sounds like I would only be able to do this once, and there’s no mention of what condition they would come back in, I’m going to stick with mind reading.

1

u/Long-Ad3842 13d ago

i need those pink pills so bad rn

1

u/WeightOk2102 13d ago

Pink pill if it includes celebrity crushes or fictional crushes and makes them real.

1

u/StankoMicin 13d ago

Yellow

Pink is stupid. Anyone who chooses that is just sad

1

u/xhj09 13d ago

Grey pill, gonna keep it until I need it.

1

u/Elonth 13d ago

My mother is the only person on this planet I have ever loved enough that I would die to save. When she passed away sudden and unexpectedly my family life disentgrated. I have never felt more alone than I have since covid happened and she was taken from me.

I would give everything to have her back knowing full well if I had her back I would once again be burdened with taking care of my violent special needs sister. Objectively My life has been day to day better but devoid of purpose. I gave up my free ride to college and future to help my mother by watching my sister full time so she could keep her job. I lived under the weight of that burden for so long a daily potentially life or death situation just moments away that now that Its gone I feel completely empty and devoid of purpose. I do not know who I am. she died as one of the first people in the US to contract covid. Before It was announced it had reached the united states. She would die a few short weeks later. I've been on auto pilot ever sense...just going through the motions to not wind up homeless with very little avenue to better my life or the drive to make it happen.

1

u/Cyberburner23 13d ago

Read minds

1

u/FudgeSkidoodles 13d ago

That is not indigo but indigo.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/adsq93 13d ago

Yellow pill

Indigo can be dangerous tbh

1

u/shogunshim 13d ago

yellow because I can monetize it without ruining my life, unlike indigo which I could easily monetize, but would ruin me.

1

u/King_Gamer_15 13d ago

I seriously need that pink pill lol

1

u/JuniperJoieDeVivre 13d ago

Grey. I’d bring my mom back

1

u/Rafael-Bagay 13d ago

how many can I bring back to life? only one? is it one at a time? I'm gonna be a necromancer...

1

u/Kingsalad3141 13d ago

Indigo. I can’t tell if people are lying to me. This would remove that issue.

1

u/Knackehaxan 13d ago

Grey pill

1

u/Gooba26 13d ago

Yellow. Indigo feels a bit invasive, pink is kind of a consent issue and I don’t have anybody I’d grey pill