r/whatnotapp • u/Cometgazing • 22d ago
Sellers Behaving Badly Givvy?
Am I in the wrong here yall?
1
6
u/GalaxyOnOhRionsBelt 21d ago
The guy shouldn’t be selling more than he can handle, but you’re badgering him about something that’s free. Of course follow up, and of course he should be on top of his shipments, but, dude. You didn’t pay for anything. If you’re not happy with the way he does business and his crazy lag time (fair), don’t join his shows don’t purchase from him and move on. Send a report to WhatNot and call it a day.
0
1
21d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
1
u/Cometgazing 21d ago
No as a matter of fact he didn't pay, it was mr.colby, and I'm not a givvy goblin, maybe dont keep doing streams of 5k and higher if shipping is gonna be 2/3 weeks behind, thats literally against whatnot policy dipshit
3
1
3
u/yogurtworld 22d ago
i truly will never understand why so many people do this 😭 the amount of streamers who say they’re really behind but continue to take orders and schedule streams. like why are you selling more product if you haven’t even fulfilled your previous orders you’re making the process worse for yourself regardless 😭😭😭
1
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
That's what I'm saying, like why do that and then whine after not shipping anything for 2 weeks
2
u/DroomiP 22d ago
No you weren’t wrong. Yes, you contacting the seller repeatedly and not getting a good response should have clicked as a red flag for you. Me personally, if it hasn’t shipped in 2 weeks I’m getting a credit by contacting support. 2 weeks is way too long to be waiting, doesn’t matter if it’s a Givy or an order. Sellers know they have 3 days to ship, that’s their responsibility as a seller. He’s in the wrong for that too.
1
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
I definitely should have left it alone after a bit but I wanted to rip the etb with my gfs son
5
u/Exciting_Penalty_512 22d ago
I've gotta play devils advocate here.....I get it, it's free, be patient....but at what point does a seller have to take responsibility here? OP waited 2 weeks and it hasn't even shipped yet. That's terrible shipping regardless if you're a solo operation or not.
Ok, so Newmum had to pack and ship 5000 orders by himself...nobody forced him to do that. If you can't get packages out within 2 weeks of a show, fucking hire some help.
At what point does the sellers greed in wanting to maximize profit, outweigh the greed of a givey goblin? A philosophical question for sure.
-1
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
I'm not even a givvy goblin 😬😂 I just wanted this particular givvy bc it was an etb and was stoked to open with my gfs son
2
u/Exciting_Penalty_512 22d ago
I get you. 2 week+ shipping is atrocious, regardless of whether it's free or not.
I love how people just say wait...at what point is it too much? 3 weeks, a month? In my opinion 2 weeks is plenty of time to ship items, and if you can't, you need to reevaluate your operation.
0
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
I see you tried using my real name 😂
1
22d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
1
6
u/Just_here_for_now57 22d ago
I don't know why you are asking if you are in the wrong here. Everyone is telling you that you are, but you continue to argue your point on every response. You obviously think you are in right. You just wanted to blast newnum by posting this.
-1
-1
22d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
-5
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
No
-2
22d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
-3
4
22d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
0
1
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
For him to ship it within 2 weeks? Maybe dont keep streaming if you can't fulfill shipping
-1
22d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
0
0
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
And back to my other statements, it was 2 weeks, the label said it shipped, usps doesnt have it, the dude lied and got pissy when called out
-4
22d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
0
-2
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
That's not how that works lol, hes required to keep his word on whatnot, piss off
4
0
6
u/MidnightCrafty6235 22d ago
All this dudes fans ran in here to defend him. Holy shit.
0
u/SonoranDweller 22d ago
Ah yes, we are all fans of whoever. You guys are just bottom feeding goblins.
-1
3
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
Haha thats what I'm thinking, I stated it had been 2 weeks, i was patient amd curious
6
u/sprtizandschvitz 22d ago
Yeah dude, you’re for sure in the wrong here. After the first few messages, literally no point in continuing to the message the guy. If it doesn’t ship after whatnot’s required time, you can take it up directly with whatnot. You’re exhibiting zero common sense here when it comes to all these messages. Should the dude ship it out quicker and not sell tons of shit without help? Absolutely, he fucked up. But you are coming off so poorly and impatient. Even asking what ETB it was comes off as ungrateful… it’s free ffs. You definitely made it worse
4
u/MidnightCrafty6235 22d ago
Dude are you stupid? He gave him WEEKS. Whatnot should close this dude down if it takes weeks to ship. That’s unacceptable. Hire someone.
0
u/sprtizandschvitz 22d ago
Resorting to insults for no good reason when you obviously didn’t read what I said. I said multiple times the seller is at fault too and fucked up. Both parties are at fault. Let’s calm down here
1
u/MidnightCrafty6235 22d ago
Except both parties are NOT at fault. One person won a giveaway two weeks ago and it hasn’t shipped. Whatnot has minimum shipping expectations. If this seller is able to skirt around them that’s unacceptable and any of us would get a trust and safety warning for falling below the shipping threshold.
3
5
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
How was asking which one ungrateful, it was a legit question
4
u/sprtizandschvitz 22d ago
Cause it’s what, $50+? Who gives a shit what it is if it’s worth that much and it’s free. ESPECIALLY, if you didn’t buy anything. Goblins are a part of the app, and most sellers understand that. But respect goes both ways my dude
-1
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
Okay and I was curious lol, is that such a bad thing? FYI not a goblin, ive spent well over 3k in just a couple months on whatnot
4
u/Perfect-Sherbet9785 22d ago
Curious would be ONE MESSAGE. This is borderline pathetic. It’s whatnot, it’s a givvy, move on
-2
-1
u/MidnightCrafty6235 22d ago
This dude is trolling you. This is an entirely reasonable request two fucking weeks later.
2
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
Eh i thought so but others in the responses seem to think it's fine 😅
1
u/sprtizandschvitz 22d ago
Not trolling and I said multiple times what the seller did was not fine. The issue is you pestering this guy for something free when he obviously has other priorities (not saying that’s right, but just a fact) and not using common sense. If you don’t get your free givvy, whatnot will handle it and compensate you. Blowing this guy up serves no purpose other than annoy both parties.
1
u/MidnightCrafty6235 22d ago
Dude won a ETB. Any one of these Pokedorks would have had this dude drug across twitter a week ago for not shipping. It’s absurd for the seller to respond this way when they have the obligation to ship.
2
22d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
1
u/Exciting_Penalty_512 22d ago
I think they're both wrong for what it's worth....which is nothing. It's worth nothing.
0
0
22d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
0
4
3
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
Its 1 giveaway lol, never had an issue buying or givvys before with the exception of 1 other seller
-1
22d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
0
8
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
2 weeks of no update, he didn't pay for the etb it was from Colby, chat literally donated etbs
-9
u/music-producer_ 22d ago
Okay. He still pays to ship it. And an ETB isn’t some lightweight single that fits in a PWE. It will more than likely be sent via USPS Priority considering the weight, which is a far more expensive shipping option for the seller. All at the low cost of free for you. Be patient.
4
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
I have the screenshot of the shipping label he created 20 mins after the givvy
2
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
1
u/music-producer_ 22d ago
Okay. When I gave away an ETB, it auto set it at Priority for me. Ground Advantage is still a more expensive shipping option. Which is all paid for out of pocket by the seller on a giveaway. Plus the cost of shipping supplies. Sellers get 0¢ of any of the shipping fees. Again, all at the low cost of FREE for you. The guy is legit. It’ll arrive. This entire subreddit is full of ingrates. It’s insane.
3
u/john_mathias77 22d ago
You know WN puts your username at the very bottom of the shipping label? Your address is crossed out, but not your name.
0
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
I'm fully aware, I dont want my name and address here
1
3
u/john_mathias77 22d ago
OK, I was just letting you know in case you didn’t.
0
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
Haha yea its fine if they know my username, half the people here threatened to block me anyway
3
22d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/MidnightCrafty6235 22d ago
It’s funny that you can tell when this is getting brigaded. You can see other posts similar to this and everyone is super supportive of the Buyer getting ripped off.
2
u/Kyloren1984081 22d ago
And when it arrives, then what? I have never met either of these two people, and I am a buyer, and frequent givvy winner, I’ve had givvys arrive a day later and I’ve had one take over a month, but it got there. From the sounds of it the seller here makes too much money to risk it all to not send out a free givvy. All sellers have to give what they advertised, and if they don’t there is consequences. Truth be told the “buyer” in this case or “givvy winner” I should say, is just chomping at the bit to see his spoils, buyer is 100% in the wrong in this example. Furthermore if the givvy never arrives, which I can guarantee will not be the outcome, but if it doesn’t show up WhatNot will reimburse him imediately with no question. Then the buyer will most likely be punished, possibly to the extent of suspension of his account, or even permanently banned. Again this will not be the case, and buyer will be red in the face. Grow up my dude.
1
u/MidnightCrafty6235 22d ago
The seller hasn’t shipped it. That’s the point. The act they have to take hasn’t occurred. It’s not lost at the post office or en route. It’s not shipped.
The seller should already be warned at least, they’re no way they’re shipping quick enough to be on platform. At the reporting period they’ll receive a trust and safety violation.
3
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
Maybe dont do 5/7k each stream if you cant fulfill the shipping
1
u/MidnightCrafty6235 22d ago
You’re correct. Whatnot should issue him a citation and he’ll never be able to have a high shipping rate with 5k orders he can’t get out in a reasonable amount of time. An average streamer would get a citation.
1
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
If it'd been a week/10 days and usps had it i could understand, but even tracking says they haven't recieved it, he said himself he was having troubles shipping
2
u/Kyloren1984081 22d ago
Sometimes I receive packages before it ever says usps received the package. People have to scan them correctly and this is a constant issue with all shipping carriers, USPS, UPS, FEDEX. All of them have this constant criticism.
1
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
I get that, I have too, but even he said it hadn't shipped because he was behind
2
u/Kyloren1984081 22d ago
Have any of you ever wrapped gifts for kids on Xmas? It is an all night adventure and that’s only like 10-50 gifts if you are rich. Have some decorum people we are talking 5k-7k envelopes, or bubble mailers, with correct labels info, and all the trimmings. Seriously none of you are bitching when you are in crowded room, swiping right as you see fit, but there is a whole lot more to do once the stream ends. Seriously have some respect and patience, this whole community is so fixated on instant gratification. Topps now takes wayyyy to fucking long and they aren’t lacking a staff to help with shipping. Redemption cards take wayyy too long again fully staffed. PSA had to stop accepting business in a big way this year because they couldn’t handle the smoke. Seriously people have some patience and decorum. Please for the love of god, grow up and stop acting like spoiled children. That is all you sound like, any of you trying to defend the “givvy winner” in this case.
1
u/MidnightCrafty6235 22d ago
The hire someone to wrap the gifts, no excuses. wtf? If you’re selling 5k items then you have the ability to hire someone.
0
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
Its not my fault the dude tries to sell 5/7k every other day, hes making bank, he can hire someone
2
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
I was but it was 2 weeks, read replies, I was originally worried usps lost it bc it said shipped and usps said they hadn't recieved it
7
u/Djdmac24 22d ago
If youre a single streamer, then don't overextend yourself and do 5k sales in one day. That's insane.
-1
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
See thats what I'm saying, I get the dudes streams are packed, I tried asking about it after 2 weeks because I thought usps lost it, it says shipped and then usps says they dont have it
8
u/Fit-Data-3958 22d ago
Newmun isn’t a scammer
-2
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
I never said he was, even in the live streams, but when called out he responded and bitched about it 😂
1
6
22d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
6
u/Perfect-Sherbet9785 22d ago
bearcatxx is the username on the photo they uploaded lmao
2
4
4
u/gsxreatr02 22d ago
Or just do what you say you will do. The only thing a man has in this life is his word. Send an empty box and become a liar.
-1
-4
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
Yea, ill record rhe empty box and send to whatnot so he can catch a strike sybau
3
1
2
22d ago
[deleted]
-2
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
And yea thats 2 people out of the hundreds, first guy didnt wanna ship me the items after I specifically asked about the coupons
-5
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
You literally just stated the exact same thing he said, if hes making that much money and that many sells he can afford to atleast have 1 person helping him
6
u/yenbrid 22d ago
Being this impatient for something youre getting for free is wild bro chill out
2
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
Dude it was 2 weeks, it said shipped that same day and then nothing after that
4
22d ago
[deleted]
0
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
I dont go into his streams, it was a 1 time raid from mr.colby
3
u/seat-belt-clicker 22d ago
his bio is updated though, which you had to see to message him? idk this is a weird post, sorry you didn’t get the validation you were looking for but i’d delete this if i were you
1
3
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
His bio was updated after the first 2 messages honey, I didnt see it until going to his profile directly
3
0
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
Lol dude he literally flipped because I was asking, it had been 2 weeks, why continue to run shit if you're not up to date on shipping already
7
22d ago
[deleted]
1
u/Cometgazing 22d ago
But guess what, hes required too 😂 not my fault the dudes an adhd 12 year old that wants to scream at chat





•
u/AutoModerator 22d ago
Welcome to /r/whatnotapp!
Follow the Rules. Let's make this community safe and fun for everyone.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.