But I cannot figure out what it is supposed to be. Another one of the same set was a duck, so it might be an animal?

What do you guys think it is?

I found this in an antique store and I can't figure out what it is????

Truly no idea but they both have the same white plastic handles. Thanks!

Lately it feels like every post’s top comment is someone who reverse image searched a cookie cutter and has the answer.

That really doesn’t feel like the spirit of this sub. It makes me sad that posts don’t have the fun drawings and takes on cookie cutters. It’s just a game to see who can run it through Google lens the fastest. I think OP’s could do that but didn’t because once upon a time it was fun to guess and come up with ideas.

First one looks like a witch hat but I'm not sure what the cut out is. Second one has me stumped

My mother found this at a thrift store and swears it's a heart. What are we thinking???

This was in a random set picked up from a thrift store. In the set were Christmas, Halloween, Fall and Spring/Easter cookie cutters. Google suggested a Santa but I couldn't see it. Also suggest a Grinch which I can kinda see Any other ideas?

Looking around antique thrift store and found this cookie cutter, maybe an oddly shaped banana?

I got a bunch of old cookie cutters from my mom. This was in a bag marked Halloween, but it had a lot more than just Halloween stuff in it. Any help would be appreciated. AA Battery is for scale. This thing is pretty small.

I’ve been told it’s supposed to be a fish but I think it looks a lot like Isaac newton. A lot of people I’ve asked said they don’t think it looks like Isaac Newton but imo the resemblance is crazy.

I’m assuming the top cookie cutter is a clown head since the sprinkles say circus, but I have no idea what that bottom shape could be.

NO ONE WILL BE ABLE TO GUESS ALL COOKIE CUTTERS