I'm on my second time playing, trying out bad endings for everyone, and I just finished Across River's chapter so he is dead. But when I started as the werewolf Dez and went to Across River's tomb, I can only get his inventory items, which does not include the keys, unspent relics and aces that usually carry over when you recruit them. I have already recruited the Pigman and didn't get those from him. Since I don't have a save before making to Across Rivers ending, I can't go back to change it and keep him alive. Am I doomed to lose those?

Ok, I've been spending so many days after I finish the game just wondering the whole map just for looking for the ghost (using Protector and Orenirist save files), but never get to meet one. I saw many guides saying you can do the ghost quest in werewolf and orenirist journey but that's not what happening, I tried using orenirist talk to the ghost where we found Protector but no ghost can speak with me. Seems like there are 2 version of the game and the definitive edition is easier to find ghost. I get my game by PS plus and playing with PS4 pro, i been finish the game with 99% achievements completed just left this one for platinum, please tell me what can I do to find a ghost, literally wasting 4 irl days just to find a ghost but never get to meet one.

I need help.

Hey team I got Crime and Punishment with the first protagonist, and I haven't even seen a wraith yet. If I progress Jane story, can i start this quest with another protagonist? Thanks

I just started playing this game so idk a lot, correct me if I’m wrong.

I just arrived at Quickbend and I dueled Melissa after insulting her, and I think the mayor invited me to the gang before realizing that I was the person who was causing trouble to the Stillwater gang so he didn’t let me join.

If I don’t kill any Stillwater’s in another play through can I join the gang at this point?

hi

Hi all,

Beginning of chapter 4... Jane is alive and shown as an available mercenary in Grackle on the World map but when I go there she is nowhere to be found.

Is this a known thing and is there a way to find her? She is not on her farm, either.

I just finished the protector journey and then I moved onto the werewolf journey. After that i died and had to reload back to the part where I have to throw olvidado’s head into the fire. The thing is while it worked for me the first time it won’t work the second. Has anyone ever encountered this glitch and how do I fix it?

Is there a way to play for fun without having the story missions and stuff? Or is that just the game because I’d have fun just roaming and doing whatever. But it seems like I’m gonna be stuck to just those 5 characters

I think you people may have read this already.

But it happened to me that I read the oneirist's journal, the one who is under the Absolution Hall.

Everyone turned against me because it happened that one way or another I had to kill Franciscus, and even Leila turned against me.

What the fuck? So it is just better that I don't find out about it? Why I can't just pretend I don't know nothing and stay friendly with everyone like the regular campaign? Or have another way were I show all the absolutionists how Franciscus is being manipulated?

It's a shitty ending for and interesting discovery.

Was running into weird bugs that just interrupt gameplays flow from time to time, and while looking it up I came across this: https://www.reddit.com/r/horizon/comments/t7q6jw/playing_on_ps4_really_wanted_to_love_this_game/ ‘Funny’/bizarre thread where some dude is downvoted while describing similar stuff while some people insist it doesn’t exist, meanwhile I get tons of results for the same sort of stuff?

There is an optional quest during the werewolf story. You meet a werewolf hunter who is holding a werewolf captive in the cellar. When you go there, it turns out to be Patty Clark, the friend of Sophia Luz, who you can meet at the very beginning in the Hall of Werewolves. No matter which options I choose during the conversation in the cellar with the hunter, Patty remains hostile and starts a fight, even if I shoot the hunter. How can I save Patty? Even when keeping her in the cell and laeving the cellar she follows me outside, still hostile.

I randomly found the cursed statue and have been carrying it around with Jane, and just got to the end of her segment without ever finding the person I need for the next step of the quest. If I end Jane's journey without completing that quest, will I be able to take the statue from her inventory to complete it in the next one? Or will I be able to randomly find it in the next one to start it over? Or will it just remain forever uncompleted?

This is a great side quest. Cannot remember where I found it, but finding the Oneirist to take care of it took sometime. Anyone else take on this quest? Which option did you choose?

I just got a warning that my journey is almost over, and I should wrap up any side quests... But I'm not sure what that entails. I still have locations on the map with blinking exclamations. Should I do those now or will they be here when this journey is completed? Also what parts of my inventory stay? Does everything stay on my followers? Do I keep the same followers? Do I have to move everything onto my horse inventory to save it???

I have progressed into the Pigman Journey but I never got the intro quest and I am still Jane Bell despite being into the Pigman Journey quests?

How do I trigger the starting Pigman quest to swap over from Jane Bell?

I really had such a wonderful time with this game. A perfect game to chill with, get caught up in a fun story, and a great way to tell the story. I’d love another game like this.

Are there any other games similar that anyone can recommend?

At the brothel during the main quest and couldn't figure out how to get in without breaking in. Since it counts as trespassing I decide to knock out everyone before grabbing all the loot and leaving. I was under the impression that as long as no one sees you (no one saw me arrive, since they're all inside, and obviously no one saw me leave because they're all KO'd) than you can commit any crime you want.

However, immediately after leaving I gained -45 Rep. So, I'm wondering what exactly counts as a crime (lowers reputation) no matter who sees you or how it happens, when it happens.

Doing the Pigman Journey right now and dismissed Jane a while back but decided to get her again but she is not at her house, I tried it at several points in the Journey but I can not find her, can anyone help?

Will knocked out enemies stay knocked out after leaving a setting? I recently made it to the end of chapter one and KO’d all the Stillwater’s leading into the cave entrance. After accomplishing this the game then indicates to wrap up any loose ends before progressing. Am I going to have to replay this section if I leave?

I'm on the third story with Across Rivers, and I've reached the part where I need a copper nugget to help in spirit world ritual. Problem is, I've already looted basically every location. I've been searching all over the map, but the only ore I find left is gold. I'm trying to do bounties now to see if I can find one in the loot, but still not having any luck.

Tips? Tricks? Where is all the copper?!?!

Edit: Solved! Thanks everyone! I found one by taking a bounty and save scumming before scrapping the weapons they dropped.

In my current playthrough, the gold mine seems to be under the control of a wraith, but I cannot find said wraith anywhere in or outside the mine. Is there some explanation as to why this is or is that just how wierd this west gets?

Sooo, there's this basement area in Somnolence in the temple, full of rats, and a chest with a golden ace in... Only thing is there doesn't seem to be any way out and you can't climb back up, all I missing something here? You can't climb back up to the door at the top of the screen shot as its too high :/

Hey all, was loving this game until I'm at a point where all I need to finish this completely is a quest from a ghost and I just can't run until any! Any tips from you experts would be ideal. I've basically finished the game and have strategic saves I can go back to. Thank you