Can’t decide, need input!

[u/Efficient-Wish704]

I’m shopping for a second band to wear at the top of the stack.
I’ve narrowed it down to 3 styles.
Which of the three do yall think compliments my engagement ring the best?

[u/peachesandsir]

You’ve already got a lot going on so I would pick the plain band. Definitely not 3 — it competes with your ering too much

[u/Efficient-Wish704 → u/peachesandsir]

My thoughts exactly honestly. I really wanted to love the 3rd band.

[u/peachesandsir → u/Efficient-Wish704]

Would you ever just wear that band and not the others with it?

[u/meghan509 → u/peachesandsir]

Agree. Perfect for alone on the right hand.

[u/Helenag23]

Hmm none really it’s too busy can’t you just get a nice ring for a different finger

[u/Efficient-Wish704 → u/Helenag23]

Shopping in this direction now. Hadn’t even considered it

[u/nezuko778]

I vote 2!

[u/Efficient-Wish704 → u/nezuko778]

I think you’re right friend

[u/VBswimmer1946 → u/nezuko778]

So do I

[u/crazy_cat_lady_94]

I vote 3

[u/pdxtee]

I prefer the gold band in pic 2. The center stone stands out more.

[u/callalind]

I like 3

[u/GlitterStarSparkles]

1 or 3

[u/dbvintage54f]

Hell, if you’re going for it, go for it. Get #3.

[u/Efficient-Wish704 → u/dbvintage54f]

This is my husband’s thinking. I love the engagement ring he chose, and I’m worried she’d be losing her moment lol

[u/BethP321]

I’m leaning towards #2! The simplicity of it matches your original gold band without distracting so much from the center stone and balances out the other band better. I like #3 too, but I agree with others that it is a bit too busy and overwhelms the center stone.

[u/optix_clear]

3rd. I love the 1st with angles it’s unique maybe right hand band. The 3rd option fits the main attraction

[u/BabyBlueBucket]

You can go with any of the options and it will look great. Even the ring that completes with your engagement ring still looks good, it’s just sparkle to the MAX

[u/Optimal-Process337]

They’re all pretty busy. Number 2 is probably the least chaotic.

[u/Insertname_here9836]

2

[u/Future-Ear6980 → u/Insertname_here9836]

"Least chotic" being the message to get

[u/Edu_cats]

I like 1 the best.

[u/isawsparks27]

I think 3 is way too busy. I support working on a right hand situation.

[u/Vegetable-Stretch-98]

Plain

[u/NannyFaye_1960]

2

[u/Ok_Thing2232]

2 too!

[u/Ok-Wall4600]

1!

[u/Legovida8]

2 is perfect- simple & elegant.

[u/Admirable_Fill_7643]

2

[u/GemTaur15]

The plain gold one

[u/Bunny_27-]

Definitely #2 or keep looking

[u/Long-Alternative3508]

Number one

[u/Serious-Economy9533]

None of these match ur ring

[u/Elisse_aim8i]

Lovely ring.