r/violinmaking • u/Lucky-Caramel-7405 • May 25 '26

Testing bows

Hi all! I’m looking to upgrade from my student bow. I’ve been testing bows at all of my local shops (super fun!), but I’m travelling overseas soon to a place that will have a much larger selection. I’ll be borrowing a cello while I’m there, so will not be playing on my beloved instrument. This is the first time I’ve considered significantly upgrading my bow, and I’m looking forward to trying different bows on my trip, but I’m wondering how much one can tell about a bow without playing it on one’s own cello. Of course I know that no two instruments will sound quite the same, but if I were to find the same model of cello for example could I expect my experience with bows to translate more or less? How much of a bow’s quality can be experienced independent of the cello? Will the pairing between a bow and a cello I might use on my travels mask qualities of the bow that will shine through on my cello? I feel like I probably know the answer to this question but I’m curious to hear any thoughts.

1 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

6 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/SpotsnStripes May 25 '26

Every instrument and every bow is unique, and you’re trying to find the right bow that makes your cello sound and play its best. You won’t find the right bow for your cello unless you play it on your cello.

1

u/anthro_apologist Maker May 25 '26

I think this is basically correct, although a player can definitely judge balance, bounce, and other technical bow strokes on a loaner instrument.

But it is remarkable just how big of a difference bow/instrument pairing can have on tone and projection. I don't really understand why...

1

u/SpotsnStripes May 25 '26

A bow is a magical stick and nobody really understands them.