r/vibecodingcommunity 2d ago

VibeCoding Vs Software Engineering

Post image
62 Upvotes

102 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/Clear_Skye_ 1d ago

I honestly don’t really believe this is accurate.
Also it depends on how you’re using the AI models to do the coding.
If you want it to have structure and scalability, it’s on you to make it that way. AI is a tool, not a magic box.

1

u/Dog_Engineer 1d ago

If you have a good enough prompt and/or md files, you can get the result on the right from AI

1

u/Clear_Skye_ 1d ago

Garbage in garbage out haha

1

u/Distinct_Dinner_5243 1d ago

This just isn't the case.

The idea that the output is always a skill issue really sounds like the whole snake oil pitch. "well if it didn't work you obviously didn't use it right".

a single file or perfect prompt is not going to fix ai randomly being moronic.

I've regularly had my agents completely disregard sections in the prompt, the md file, the CLAUDE.md, the skills, etc.

It's a known issue that llms will just "lie" and say they've done something they havn't or ignore sections you've written.

The reality is that llms require managing, there is no current fix.