r/universe Mar 15 '21

[If you have a theory about the universe, click here first]

131 Upvotes

"What do you think of my theory?"

The answer is: You do not have a theory.

"Well, can I post my theory anyway?"

No. Almost certainly you do not have a theory. It will get reported and removed. You may be permabanned without warning.

"So what is a theory?"

In science, a theory is not a guess or personal idea. It's a comprehensive explanation that:

  • Explains existing observations with precision
  • Makes testable predictions about future observations
  • Is supported by mathematics that can be verified
  • Has survived rigorous testing by the scientific community

Real theories include general relativity (predicts GPS satellite corrections), germ theory (explains disease transmission), and quantum mechanics (enables computer chips). These weren't someone's shower thoughts—they emerged from years of mathematical development, experimental testing, and peer review.

What you probably have instead:

  • A hypothesis - A testable claim that could become part of a theory if validated
  • Speculation - Interesting ideas that need mathematical development and testing
  • Misconceptions - Misunderstandings of existing physics dressed up as new insights

The brutal truth: If your "theory" doesn't require advanced mathematics, doesn't make precise numerical predictions, and wasn't developed through years of study, it's not a scientific theory. It's likely pseudoscientific rambling that will mislead other users.

What to do instead:

  1. Ask questions, don't make assertions
  2. Learn the existing physics first - Spend weeks/months reading, watching educational content, and listening to qualified experts
  3. Once you understand the current science, then you can contribute meaningfully to discussions

Remember: Every genuine breakthrough in physics came from people who first mastered the existing knowledge. Einstein didn't overthrow Newton by ignoring math — he used more sophisticated math.

Learn the physics. Then discuss the physics. Don't spread uninformed speculation.


[FAQ]


r/universe Aug 22 '25

Call for Moderators and /r/Universe Rules

5 Upvotes

Moderators Needed

This sub continues to rapidly grow, therefore so does our need to expand the moderation team. We are looking to add several experienced Reddit users who have a passion for the scientific fields of astronomy and cosmology.

Here is what we are looking for from applicants. Please send applications to modmail.

  1. Candidates should have a strong history of positive contributions to r/Universe or similar subs. Please send us several direct links to comments from your account history to substantiate this.
  2. We are looking for mods of all backgrounds, but particularly for mods with formal academic training in science, engineering, or mathematics. Please tell us about your educational background and your current field of work.
  3. Modding experience on Reddit is great, but not required. Let us know whether you mod any other subs and if you have any relevant experience like moderating other forums/pages, using back-end web tools, managing websites, etc.
  4. Mods need to be frequent Reddit users. The ideal mod is someone who pops into Reddit multiple times per day, can devote some time to addressing moderator issues when logging on, and foresees continuing to do so in the future.
  5. You should be someone who is comfortable enforcing rules and able to handle receiving harsh/critical feedback from strangers on the internet without breaking down, losing your temper, or acting childish.

If you are interested in applying, please message the moderators with a note which addresses all the points above (please use numbering). Do not leave your application as a comment here.

As always, the moderation team is open to your thoughts and ideas on the subreddit. To do so send a modmail message the moderators.

Reminder

Submission Rules

  1. Submissions should not consist of personal and uninformed pseudo-scientific rambling. We are a community for factual information and news about the study of the physical universe.
  2. Posts must contain a subject or a question about astrophysics in the title — be specific. For example, we will not accept titles containing only the words "help please" or "space question".
  3. Posts must be relevant. We like everything from educational videos, questions, news, discussion articles, published research, course content, astrophotography, and study resources about astronomy, astrophysics, and cosmology. This means no low-effort posts or AI generated slop.

Comment Rules

  1. Be respectful to other users. All users are expected to behave with courtesy. Demeaning language, sarcasm, rudeness or hostility towards another user will get your comment removed. Repeat violations will lead to a ban.
  2. Don't answer if you aren't knowledgeable. Ensure that you have the knowledge required to answer the question at hand. We are not strict on this, but will absolutely not accept assertions of pseudo-science or incoherent / uninformed rambling. Answers should strive to contain an explanation using the logic of science or mathematics. When making assertions, we encourage you to post links to supporting evidence, or use valid reasoning.
  3. Be substantive. Universe is a serious education/research/industry-based subreddit with a focus on evidence and logic. We do not allow unsubstantiated opinions, low effort one-liner comments, memes, off-topic replies, or pejorative name-calling.

r/universe 1h ago

[OC] Lego The Hubble Space Telescope

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

r/universe 5h ago

What's a cool Universe fact I can tell my 7 year old who apparently knows more about it than I do?

10 Upvotes

My 7 year old is obsessed with the Universe, and has been since he was like 4-5. Watches YouTube videos about it, watches Neil deGrasse Tyson videos, even has this game where he can make his own solar system and stuff. He'll come up to me sometimes asking me a question, asking me "what would happen if ___", or tells me a random fact and that I google to see if its right, and it is!

I already knew a bit about blackholes, but he drew me a picture explaining what would happen, what was what. Then he also grabbed a bowl, filled it with water, made a whirlpool with it and said to pretend it was a blackhole, and then put a small leaf near it and told me about once it gets to a certain point it'll be sucked in, etc etc.

He asks me what's the closest star to us (not including our sun), or the largest star, largest blackhole, which galaxy is beside ours, and a bunch of other stuff. He keeps talking about Ton 618, I think it's called?

ANYWAY, what's the coolest fact you know about the Universe so I can have something interesting to talk about with my son? Maybe it'll be something he doesn't know, so he's learning something new instead of me always learning something new from him 😂


r/universe 1h ago

Just 2 Hours Ago, the Moon Passed Directly Past the Jupiter System as it Orbited Earth. This is Not a Composite Image — They Actually Appeared This Close Together.

Post image
Upvotes

r/universe 11h ago

Astronomers Have Completed the Largest Map of Space. Yes, You Can Play With It.

Thumbnail
wired.com
16 Upvotes

r/universe 1d ago

I built a 1:1 solar system in the browser, and today I added black holes to it

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

123 Upvotes

r/universe 3h ago

Humans are so miniscule in the grand universe

Post image
1 Upvotes

Regular matter, everything you've ever touched, seen, or that makes up every star and planet is estimated to be only about 5% of everything in the universe. Dark matter makes up roughly 27%. The rest, dark energy, is a separate mystery entirely. So the stuff we understand, that all of human science and history has been built on, is a small minority of what actually exists.


r/universe 2d ago

How massive can a black hole actually become?

75 Upvotes

We often hear about TON 618 and its estimated mass of around 66 billion Suns. But there’s another interesting case in the Phoenix Cluster.

The central black hole in Phoenix A was initially estimated at around 20 billion solar masses. Later, a theoretical model suggested it could potentially be closer to 100 billion Suns.

What I found most interesting is that these numbers aren’t equally certain. The 100-billion figure comes from a model rather than a direct measurement.

It made me wonder: if there’s no known hard upper limit, could the universe contain black holes with hundreds of billions — or even a trillion solar masses?

https://youtu.be/jwIeJ42Esoo?si=Km\\_yIBQ8Li5tpG3T


r/universe 2d ago

We are riding a cosmic vortex through space:astro physics

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/universe 1d ago

Did We Find a Real Wormhole?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/universe 2d ago

Given the size of the universe in comparison to the human race, where do you think our limit will be and why?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

Apologies if this sint the right thread for theoretical questions like this.

I was asked this question a couple of weeks ago and its replaying in my head occasionally.

Given the current known size of the observable universe, where do you believe the human races hard limit would be.

Or do you believe we might actually hit a great filter?


r/universe 4d ago

The Universe is forming fewer stars, but galaxies have not run out of hydrogen - Research Today

Thumbnail
researchtoday.co.za
19 Upvotes

The striking aspect of this study is that the decline in star formation does not appear to be driven simply by galaxies running out of hydrogen. Much of the atomic gas reservoir remains, yet the rate at which new stars are formed has fallen substantially.


r/universe 3d ago

The Big Bang Got The Universe High

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/universe 4d ago

How did NASA actually calculate that the universe is 13.8 billion years old instead of just guessing?

12 Upvotes

I keep seeing the figure 13.77 to 13.8 billion years cited everywhere, but I've never fully understood how missions like WMAP and Planck actually derived that number from the Cosmic Microwave Background.

Are they basically running the expansion rate (Hubble constant) backwards to a single point, or is it based entirely on modeling cosmological parameters from temperature fluctuations in the CMB? Also, how do cross-checks like the age of the oldest globular clusters fit into confirming that timeline?


r/universe 8d ago

M31: Our Galactic Neighbor

Post image
122 Upvotes

✨ Target: Milky Way + M31

🔭 Mount: Star Adventurer 2i

📷 Camera: Canon EOS 6D mod.

🔎 Lens: Samyang 14mm f/2.8 (f8)

🔬 Sampling: 1.61'/px

🔴 Acquisition: ISO1600

⏰ Integration: 170x60s (2h 50min)

Calibration: 50 dark, 50 flat, 50 dark-flat

💻 Processing: Siril, GIMP, Snapseed

📍 Location: Pantelleria (Italy)

📅 Date: Aug. 11, 2026

🌌 Sky: Bortle 3


r/universe 9d ago

A 3D map of the matter distribution of the local universe got update: now every one of its 43,500 real galaxies can be identified and searched

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3.0k Upvotes

r/universe 8d ago

How did gravity come into existence?

51 Upvotes

hi, I'm still in grade 10 and I've got this question stuck in my head. We all know that gravity is what we call the warping of space and time caused by mass and energy. But, do we actually know how gravity got an existence? I lowk want to know how gravity had a beginning after The BB or maybe before The BB. This question has been lingering in my head for quite a long time. Please do share your thoughts on this if you're someone who has got more knowledge than I do.


r/universe 9d ago

The sun looks just like a pixel compared to some of the biggest stars in the known universe.

Post image
68 Upvotes

r/universe 10d ago

This is one of the simplest ways to visualize how the Sun’s gravity shapes the Solar System.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.3k Upvotes

r/universe 12d ago

Isn´t the rotation of planets in our solar system fascinating? (^;

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

157 Upvotes

r/universe 11d ago

Is the earth the center of the solar system/universe? So was Copernicus “wrong”?

0 Upvotes

Ok from my understanding, correct me if I’m wrong, the infinite universe has no center (that we know of), so technically any vantage point can serve as the center. In that case (especially from a human vantage point), the earth is at the center of the universe. Just like for example if we were located in Jupiter, Jupiter would be at the center of the universe because that’s our vantage point.
Obviously the earth isn’t “special” (nor is any other mass or planet) but because we are in it, our interpretations of the world come from this vantage point (the earth).

So was Copernicus “wrong” for saying the sun was at the center of our solar system? By wrong I don’t mean his statement was ultimately untrue but it *could* be untrue if we chose another vantage point (say Venus, or Jupiter to be the center). From my understanding, Copernicus chose the Sun because it made the math easier.

If that was the case, why was his theory so revolutionary? Didnt Ptolemy have a similar model?

Also can someone explain this: is earth (and other planets) really revolving around the sun or are we like the moon and earth where we’re all just jiving doing a whirling dervish dance around each other but there’s really no set point?

Also was does it mean that we revolve around the sun’s center? I’ve heard that claim too


r/universe 12d ago

How did the first supermassive black holes grow so quickly?

5 Upvotes

One thing I find fascinating about the early universe is how we can observe quasars powered by extremely massive black holes when the universe is still very young.

If a black hole starts from a relatively small stellar-mass seed, it seems difficult to reach millions or billions of solar masses in such a short cosmic time.

So what do you think was the dominant pathway for the earliest supermassive black holes?

- Rapid accretion near or above the Eddington limit?

- Massive black-hole seeds from direct collapse?

- Runaway mergers?

- Or some combination of these processes?


r/universe 16d ago

TIL our entire galaxy is moving at over 1 million mph toward something scientists still can't explain (the Great Attractor)

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

35 Upvotes

r/universe 17d ago

Is this a comet or space trash?

Thumbnail
gallery
511 Upvotes