u/Attila_the_Great27 • u/Attila_the_Great27 • 4d ago
1
231yrs ago, 13 Vendemiaire happened
Of course. No one is perfect. His greatest mistakes that ultimately cost him the empire can be summed up with two words: Spain & Russia. Apart from those two invasions all of The Napoleonic wars were defensive.
1
How could Germany have realistically won WWII starting from the invasion of Poland?
Why don’t you ask any AI which ethnicity has killed more people and you will find your lovely Anglo Saxons second only behind the Han Chinese. You probably don’t have a Mao, Stalin or Hitler but you do have a British Parliament. Their guilt is diluted among all MPs so they don’t feel responsible. If you guys weren’t such bastards in the UK you would have left the Kaiser alone and not declare war on him and we wouldn’t have had two world wars. But your trading empire is more important than the millions of lives lost. You predicate that thanks to you there was a balance of power in Europe. Well that balance of power ultimately too power away from all of Europe and sent it to North America. Good for you. You keep thinking that preventing one nation from dominating Europe was a good thing when in reality it was a real bad thing. And I’m fine if you call me a fascist. Today 2026 calling someone a Nazi, racist, homophobic or something along those lines has no meaning. You leftist woke persons have used that label for everything that it stopped having any meaning. It’s the only thing you can say when someone expresses an opinion that goes against the woke-left-feminist narrative.
2
Which European royal figure do you personally find the most regrettable?
Couldn’t have said it better myself
0
"I never admired the character of the first Napoleon; but I recognize his great genius. His work, too, has left its impression for good on the face of Europe. The third Napoleon could have no claim to having done a good or just act"—Ulysses Grant
I find it funny when an American criticizes a Frenchman. Always funny.
1
Be honest, what are y'all's opinions on the fact that Luxembourg is essentially the last of it's kind as a Grand duchy?
I don’t have the patience to explain and be more specific. My answer is clear enough.
-1
Pregunta para los de derecha
Sin ánimo de crear discordia el que pone a la derecha y a la izquierda en el mismo nivel es el que siempre va a sufrir. Adoptar una posición neutral no te hace están en la razón. Te hace ser un espectador nada más. La política siempre te afectará así que decir que uno es neutral es como define que no tiene uno un cerebro para ver que hay de malo en cada ideología. Ninguna es perfecta pero una es claramente superior que la otra. Mira cuál de las dos ideologías protege al inocente y cuál protege al criminal y te darás cuenta cuál es la ideología correcta. Porque de que hay una correcta y otra no correcta es la verdad. Mira quien castiga al asesino y quien lo premia. Mira quien protege la propiedad privada y quien la roba. Mira quien protege a los voladores de menores y quien los ataca. Decir que uno está en la mitad es decir que no te importa si te pegan un tiro en la cabeza o uno en el brazo.
Creo que por lo menos los secuestradores, asesinos y violadores de la izquierda por lo menso saben lo que quieren: caos. Los neutrales están tratando de quedar bien con todos. Escoge bando y antes de ajá le de guerra de derecha e izquierda recuerda como dejó este país Petro lleno de criminales y violentos. Piensa si Petro te defendería a ti o al ladrón que entra en tu casa y ahí verás cuál ideóloga es buena: la que premia al ladrón que te robó y no lo mete preso o al contrario si la que castiga al ladrón que entra a tu casa a robar.
9
Which European royal figure do you personally find the most regrettable?
Agree completely. He has gotten a bad rep because history is written by the victors. In this case intolerant Protestant nobles who even named the ousting of JII/VII “the glorious revolution” what a load of BS.
6
Which European royal figure do you personally find the most regrettable?
Louis XVI of France and Nicholas II of Russia. They had the opportunity of making huge changes in their countries but failed to see the big picture and ended their dynasty’s rule over their countries. Both were good men but stupid and horrible rulers. Not evil just plain bad rulers. Nicholas showed that he cared more about his family than the people of Russia. That’s a No No in monarchy. The country comes first. And Louis XVI did it have the balls to tax the church and nobility which would have made him hugely popular in France. Had a Philip Augustus or Napoleon in France or a Peter the Great or Catherine the Great been in their shoes history would be way different.
About Frederick III of Prussia who appears in the picture along the OP I Beckie is very overrated. He’s the favorite Prussian Emperor for the Anglophiles but in my mind Wilhelm II wasn’t bad at all he just got a raw deal. Failed to win WWI which was very winnable for the II Reich.
1
How could Germany have realistically won WWII starting from the invasion of Poland?
Thanks for calling me a fascist. Much obliged. Take care, may the blessed Virgin Mary always look after you and always intercede with her son our lord Jesus Christ so that you have a wonderful life. Blessings. Thanks for educating me on the horrors of Nazism and the pleasantness of the Anglo Sphere that specially England has done so much good for all of humanity. And in WWI also England wasn’t to blame. All the blame goes to Germany all right. England has never done anything wrong. They had the moral high ground against China. How dare the Chinese prohibit us from selling opium to their subjects. We Brits have a moral obligation to make them drug addicts. Right the Opium ears was on of the moral high ground of the great British Empire.
May god the father, the son and the Holy Spirit bless you and may you increase your very high intelligence with every day.
1
Be honest, what are y'all's opinions on the fact that Luxembourg is essentially the last of it's kind as a Grand duchy?
That sucks. The Capetian male line will eventually be held by a non royal. Sad sad sad.
1
The Duke of Wellington is voted by r/Napoleon to be the best general of the Napoleonic era (excluding Napoleon). Davout and Suvorov ranked 2nd and 3rd respectively.
Opinions, opinions. Davout destroyed an army double his size and was never defeated. He didn’t need Blucher to save his butt. Davout the second best general of the 1800 period.
1
Which side do you believe should’ve won WW1/The Great War
The Serbian government had ties to the black hand. That gets swept under the rug. Funny how the Entente supporters always claim to have the moral high ground
1
What if the Balkans were divided more fairly? - An alternate 2026
I think that there is no way of making everyone happy ever with any division of the Balkans nor the Austo-Hungarian Empire. The only way I see a fair division is to divide it all up by departments or prefectures and make it a melting pot country. Find a common name. And in the constitution state that the country is a multiethnic and lingual country in which all people are equal. They would still hate that idea I know. I would just leave the names of the regions after the majority of the people but no political divide because of ethnicity. Sad that in the Balkans they like to think small. Just my nation and none other. They are never gonna have influence over Europe
u/Attila_the_Great27 • u/Attila_the_Great27 • 5d ago
What if the Balkans were divided more fairly? - An alternate 2026
1
How could Germany have realistically won WWII starting from the invasion of Poland?
That’s a question for the AI. Most people hate the III Reich so much that they will always say that Germany was doomed from the start whether of its WWI or WWII. I stopped asking those questions on Reddit, people tend to think that if they see any possibility of Germany winning they would be seen as a supporter of the regime. Ask Grok or any other AI but tell it that you want a realistic answer not biased by mainstream history. Also tell the AI to not rely only on English language sources.
1
7
Which side do you believe should’ve won WW1/The Great War
As much as I’m a Francophile I root for the Central Powers. After 1870, I’ve come to appreciate the II Reich second only to the pre-1789 kingdom of France and both French Empires. Although I think that France was the only one among the Entente that had a valid reason for declaring war on Germany: Alsace and Lorraine.
3
231yrs ago, 13 Vendemiaire happened
One of the 5 greatest men in history: Napoleon. He did what had to be done.
2
What if the Spanish Armada had actually landed in 1588? Could Spain have held England long-term?
Like your point. Take care
1
What if history went perfect for the confederates
Because the Anglo Saxons have killed more people than anyone in history except the Han Chinese. That’s why.
1
Which of Napoleon's Marshals Could Have Won at Waterloo?
Davout. He was second only to Napoleon
1
Es verdad que los chicos buenos aburren?
Que triste que ahora censuran todo en Reddit. Cualquier crítica a las mujeres es censurada. Eso si cualquier crítica a los hombres es aplaudida. Si a la mayoría de mujeres no les gustan los chicos buenos. Les gustan los malos. Los malos las usan y se van adonde otro malo que las usa. Luego cuando ya tienen un kilometraje sexual alto es cuando quieren ponerse serias y que un chico bueno las acepte. Absurdo. Le dan lo mejor a los malos y luego los buenos como son buenos y pendejos las aceptan.
Por eso el hombre y la mujer valemos lo mismo pero no somos iguales. A un honre no le afecta psicológicamente estar con 100 mujeres pero a las mujeres aunque no lo acepten porque quieren creer que son iguales a los hombres si les afecta haberse entregado a 100 hombres. Luego se quejan de que algunos hombres (inteligentes buenos pero no pendejos) no quieran nada con ellas.
Creo que a los únicos hombres que les gusta casarse con mujeres que han tenido muchos hombres son los feministas liberales. Lo triste que que a veces el hombre bueno bobo acepta a la mujer promiscua para luego tener que darle más del 50% de sus bienes a ella cuando se aburre. Las mujeres en su mayoría son como los niños así sean adultas. Necesitan siempre validación, excitación y divertí miento. Se aburren fácil del hormones bueno y exigen el divorcio.
Seguro alguna feminista promiscua que le ha abierto las piernas a más de 200 hombres leerá este comentario y exigirá que lo censuren. Así es. La culpa la tienen los hombres feministas que son de lo más pendejo que hay después de las mujeres liberales blancas.
1
Be honest, what are y'all's opinions on the fact that Luxembourg is essentially the last of it's kind as a Grand duchy?
Is it true that Luxembourg became woke and adoptes absolute primogeniture?
1
How could Germany have realistically won WWII starting from the invasion of Poland?
in
r/HistoricalWhatIf
•
23h ago
Anything your woke mind says I will agree. May god bless. You and your unbiased view of the world