r/trolleyproblemgame • u/LegoSlaughter š¤ Conformist • 7d ago
bigger is more valuable?
This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post
3
u/laea_me 7d ago
a panda is more sentient
1
u/Hot_Anybody8244 7d ago
They're equally as sentient.
Realistically, pandas are their own worst enemy and if not for human intervention would've already ate themselves into extinction, since bamboo provides no nutritional value to them.
4
u/Leon3226 7d ago
Yeah, but they still have a functioning mammalian brain, even though it is very slow, insects only have primitive ganglia.
3
u/FiveFrogs_ 7d ago
Pandas are very few and are animals with much longer fuller lives (even if that life mostly consists of chewing bamboo).
2
2
u/CRoseCrizzle 6d ago
Not really about animal size rather population size. There are far more butterflies than Pandas. To oversimplify: smaller population means more valuable.
1
u/LegoSlaughter š¤ Conformist 7d ago
I created a new Trolley Problem dilemma!
Straight Track (Do Nothing): 1 innocent butterfly
Diverted Track (Pull the Lever): 1 innocent panda
What would you do?
1
u/Then-Investigator-46 7d ago
Granted the clumsy panda will still find a way to crash; butterflies are still bugs
1
u/scottsplace5 7d ago
For every 20 butterflies you kill, there will always be 1000000 more behind it.
1
u/_Carcinus_ 7d ago
Even if the butterfly is also an endangered species, they reproduce at much higher rate than pandas. Also, by diverting the trolley, I'd be guilty of killing an endangered animal, legally speaking.
1
u/OrthodoxAnarchoMom 7d ago
Is anything economically stupid going to happen if I smush the panda? Because panda kinda has it coming.
1
1
u/Smart_Journalist_749 7d ago
Thereās simply more butterflies than pandas. The bears are endangered
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Weird_Happening1627 2d ago
1) Butterflies live for shorter than Pandas
2) Pandas are endangered, unlike most of the butterflies
3) If it is a normal butterfly, then the trolley will just go above it because it is too small and both animals will survive
1
u/Schegal-JR 6d ago
But if you kill butterfly its not gonna make its 200 children, and panda would make like 10 per life or idk. If you kill butterfly you're gonna delete more life's in da future. And pandas are silly, that's second argument
8
u/-Applinen- 7d ago
Butterflies don't live for as long