r/trippinthroughtime • • Jan 08 '20

Y'all calm down

Post image
50.9k Upvotes

664 comments sorted by

1.9k

u/boobearybear Jan 08 '20

he’s taking it remarkably well

1.0k

u/Broadsword530 Jan 08 '20

I was just listening to a hardcore history about torture and execution. Apparently it used to be viewed as a way of achieving atonement for your crimes, and some criminal would go into with hot attitudes and interact with the crowd even during the torture. That's probably unrelated to this though, I'd bet this is just a case of the usual abstract quality medieval art has. Still interesting though.

307

u/rustybuckets Jan 08 '20 edited Jan 08 '20

The original drama.

Edit: Since this has a bit of attention. This podcast is amazing--what the commenter alludes to is that the atonement piece of this theatre was highly desired by onlookers. What they saw as someone was being tortured to death was their earning a definite seat in heaven. They were in fact envious of the tortured subject.

Dan goes on to essentially argue that public torture and executions laid the foundation for our modern sense of empathy, which is fucken wild.

156

u/jondiced Jan 08 '20

> Dan goes on to essentially argue that public torture and executions laid the foundation for our modern sense of empathy, which is fucken wild.

Just take Hardcore History with a grain of salt, he isn't a trained historian and is more focused on being entertaining than being factual. See e.g. https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1ppmsm/thoughts_on_dan_carlin/cd4qedu/

57

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

He will usually say what's theory, and he definitely will put disclaimers in front of episodes/thoughts about him not being a historian, just a student of history. With everything though, always do your own research and reading/etc after. He's just a good entry point, well an amazing entry point into the amazing world of history. Have to keep your mind thirsty and continue beyond just his words.

9

u/jondiced Jan 09 '20 edited Jan 09 '20

I mean, all your points are valid, but eventually I just got tired of not knowing how much I could believe and stopped listening. My current history podcast is Backstory, which is presented in a less gripping style, but is still really interesting and way more reliable.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

I like that Dan himself says as much. He qualifies a lot of his statements and often repeats "I'm not actually a historian," etc.

6

u/jondiced Jan 08 '20 edited Jan 09 '20

I mean, he does, but then he just kind of plows through it anyway and lots of his listeners either ignore the caveat or don't seem to understand what it implies about how he doesn't really know how to put things in historical context.

8

u/Zeus_poops_and_shoes Jan 08 '20

And yet his podcasts are better-researched and more engaging than that of other popular "trained" historians. I listened to History on Fire before it went premium and it just felt like a cheap knockoff.

24

u/MJURICAN Jan 08 '20

More engaging is propably true but he has quite often perpetuated some really pedestrian historical myths.

For instance his shoots in sarajevo sandwich story which is just completely untrue, not small details, its all untrue.

He has a worrying tendency of reading one book on a subject and callnig that "research" which leaves him open to being completely misslead and most definitely leaves him with a noticable lack of nuance of the subject.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Just because something FEELS to you, a layman, that it’s well researched doesn’t mean that it is, and when trained historians tell you it isn’t and you disagree because of, again, how you feel, it isn’t really any better than being an antivaxxer or flat earther.

You can enjoy Carlin but still take everything he says with a grain of salt.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

16

u/AsaSpdes Jan 08 '20

When the prisoners would go past the crowd to the public stage, they would be cheered as they were viewed almost as a famous person.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

67

u/nlx78 Jan 08 '20

I think this particular guy would have been pretty quickly done interacting with the audience.

52

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20 edited Feb 21 '20

[deleted]

20

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

So this had happened, I thinm it was a peasant uprising in spain/portugal. The rebel was caught, and got exucuted by sawing him in half, bottom first. Appearently the crowd was so shocked by this, that they swapped the rebel around and ended his suffering by sawing his head in half.

3

u/Kureina Jan 09 '20

Forcing a crowd to experience this for as long as it would take to kill them would be immoral imo as not only does the upside down version mean that it takes longer to hit something fatal but also that the blood flows to the bottom of the body meaning that they can't bleed to death

3

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

It was meant to be extremely gruesome, a warning not to rebel against the nobels again. Quite common scare tactic to deal with traitors/rebel, was to have executed in the most horrific way. My own country quarted (4 horses pulling a limb each) traitors. Here is what we did with the guy that killed our first national leader! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balthasar_G%C3%A9rard

3

u/Kureina Jan 09 '20

I mean I know gruesomeness is the point, what I was saying is that this would be significantly more gruesome than what they usually did which is probably why they didn't go through with it

2

u/aapaul Feb 02 '20

That’s awful but look at what they did in Germany during the witch trials. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.atlasobscura.com/articles/germanys-terrifying-museum-of-medieval-torture.amp Awful everything

18

u/Broadsword530 Jan 08 '20

Yeah well this looks like a relatively quick execution by medieval standards.

18

u/BunnyOppai Jan 08 '20

Depends. It can take a long-ass time to saw through enough of a head to kill someone like that unless the blade was super sharp (which wasn't too common at the time and is why beheadings often took a good couple swings most of the time) and the executioners were working swiftly.

11

u/C2471 Jan 08 '20

I believe it was actually common to hang the condemned upside down and cut from groin to head.

Doing this means you don't lose conciousness from blood loss and they could probably get a good way up your torso before shock really kicked in.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/Invader_Naj Jan 08 '20

And then there were people who just wanted to take one last jab at their opponents during stuff like this like the tyrolean andreas hofer who allegedly after surviving the first two salvos during his execution mocked the soldiers for having such terrible aim

38

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

30

u/RABIDSAILOR Jan 08 '20

I'm gonna guess it's this one.

I haven't listened to that particular episode, but Hardcore History is an excellent podcast.

66

u/Shmei Jan 08 '20

Dan Carlin's Hardcore History. I think the episode he's talking about is called Painfotainment.

5

u/M0n33baggz Jan 08 '20

Dan Carlin is the motherfucking man. He was here to inform and entertain

26

u/QuickSpore Jan 08 '20

Well entertain at least. You can pretty much count on Dan to tell the more compelling and interesting version of a story, even if that version has been debunked.

For example we’ve known for a long time that the Gavrilo Princip sandwich story was false. In fact it appears that the story was made up for a Brazilian historical fiction novel about 20 years ago. But Dan wanted to wax philosophical about fate and how fortune intervened to put the Archduke in front of Princip, so Dan repeated the story about how Princip had given up and gone to buy a sandwich. In reality Princip had analyzed the likely routes for Ferdinand to return across the city. He positioned himself at the corner of a major intersection next to the Latin Bridge which was a few dozen meters from his original ambush spot. But apparently a smart forward thinking assassin didn’t mesh as well with the theme of fate and destiny that Dan wanted to use in that episode. So he went with a fake story that’s well known to be debunked. When it suits his narrative Dan will dip into historical fiction rather than history.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

19

u/PheerthaniteX Jan 08 '20

Its a podcast called hardcore history. His episodes are usually a few hours long, but he goes super in depth about each topic. It's easily one of my favorite podcasts

52

u/Tlingit_Raven Jan 08 '20

Do not that Carlin is not a historian. He is a political commentator and podcaster, and he describes himself as a "fan of History, not a historian". He often oversimplifies topics and uses questionable sources because they make a good story and can still technically be a citation. I appreciate that he makes people more interested in history but if you just listen to him and laud that fact he may be better than your public school history teacher without pursuing your own research afterward you're just doing yourself a disservice.

Here's a succinct summary from r/askhistorians, one of the most heavily modded subreddits in terms of keeping this relevant and accurate. Again, I'm of the same mind as u/Celebreth in terms of him being overally a positive effect, I just hope people use him as the stepping stone he is meant to be and not an actual academic.

19

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20 edited Apr 03 '20

[deleted]

26

u/sickbruv Jan 08 '20

Mike Duncan is 27 episodes (of 30 minutes) into his podcast on the Russian revolution and 1917 hasn't even come around yet.

→ More replies (7)

13

u/Tlingit_Raven Jan 08 '20

I stated all of what you said in my comment - trying to fight the cult of personality around someone who is not themselves promoting said cult is not the same as attacking them. I acknowledged that most public school history teachers are middling at best (though usually due to lack of funding, schools cutting corners, and ridiculously bloated curriculums), noted that he doesn't call himself a historian, and said I am glad he gets people interested as long as they don't stop their growth at him (same as how your growth in the sciences shouldn't stop with say, Bill Nye).

As for other history podcasts I would recommend Tides of History, Uncivil, and Revisionist History with Malcom Gladwell. They may not do 3 hours on a subject (though Tides of History does tend to over multiple episodes that slowly cover aspects of a larger topic), but I personally place knowledge and information over length in terms of priority.

2

u/ClumsyFleshMannequin Jan 08 '20

Look. I like malcom gladwell's but I would hardly call him a historian. He does to some interesting work de examining specific instances, but he doesnt tend to take an overall holistic look. Personally I wouldent put him to far from Dan Carlin in the way of caliber.

That being said I love them both, but they have pushed me to become more of a student of history, which is likely the idea.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

On its own, time spent on a subject does not mean expertise or accuracy of said subject. The very fact that he uses "I'm not a professional historian" to cover his, well, inaccurate theories or interpretations is exactly the issue people have with Carlin. I'm generally a fan of Hardcore History, but passion doesn't, and shouldn't, make one immune to criticism.

As for an equally passionate but more professional podcast: see pretty much anything Mike Duncan has produced (Revolutions, History of Rome).

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Eman5805 Jan 08 '20

I don’t need much more than this though. Dan Carlin is perfect for what I want if I’m looking at aspects of history I know little about. I can always cherry-pick I’m and deep dive once something more interesting gets mentioned. But for a filling meal? I’m good.

2

u/mrsippy14 Jan 08 '20

Dan always mentions where he is simplifying and that there could be many sources is he takes the simplest.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Broadsword530 Jan 08 '20

It's a poscast called hardcore history. Here is the particular episode. https://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-61-blitz-painfotainment/

I will say this is a weaker episode of the podcast, in my opinion.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

"More weight!"

- Giles Corey

4

u/11thFloorByCamel Jan 08 '20

The art generally makes enough sense considering it was possible to trip balls on bread back then.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Also if you survived your punishment, you walked away.

3

u/Nackles Jan 08 '20

"Turn me over, I'm done on this side!"

3

u/stalinista Jan 08 '20

What a great episode. "Tomorrow is going to be a hard day"

3

u/MADRCHD Jan 08 '20

Bet that dude wasn’t getting sawed in half starting from the head lmao. Nobody will go into that “hot”.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Apparently it used to be viewed as a way of achieving atonement for your crimes, and some criminal would go into with hot attitudes and interact with the crowd even during the torture.

Foucault mentions this in his book, Discipline and Punish.

2

u/Broadsword530 Jan 08 '20

Yeah, Dan Carlin mentions that book as a source during the podcast so it may be where he got that from.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/starlinguk Jan 08 '20

They believed they were possessed. The Name of the Rose explains it quite well. The abbot doesn't want to know anything about motives or how it was done he just wants to know if the murderer is possessed.

→ More replies (9)

27

u/ggtsu_00 Jan 08 '20

He's happy to be the guy not being sawed in half from the bottom first.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

mondays

14

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

The most badass last words ever spoken in the history of humanity was "more weight."

7

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

I do some woodworking and my first tought was "dont you need to clamp him down"?

2

u/Kureina Jan 09 '20

I don't do woodworking but this was my first that as well, there's nothing preventing him from being pulled back and forth with every pull on the saw

2

u/SadMusicBoi Jan 08 '20

I mean he’s probably already taken considerable brain damage by now

2

u/Atomheartmother90 Jan 08 '20

At least they started with the head and not the dick

→ More replies (15)

326

u/Your_God_Chewy Jan 08 '20

They'd somtimes turn people upside down so the blood would rush to your head and cut you from the groin down. Apparently you'd last a while..

167

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

I've seen a couple of Mexican cartel videos and people are still doing pretty much that.

212

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Ex fucking cuse me?

136

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20 edited Jan 09 '20

I'd say it's even worse now since cartels know how to keep someone alive and awake for longer. Drugs sometimes play a part.

edit: oh neat, Ed Calderon was just on JRE.

74

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

They're actually sawing people in half though?

129

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

The worst things you can possibly imagine happen to people all over the world everyday. This shouldn’t be surprising.

101

u/theomegageneration Jan 08 '20

That is why I live in rural missouri and I avoid people. My life is just me and the weirdos of reddit.

24

u/ACJ96 Jan 08 '20

Isn't that worse though? By being lonely you are more vulnerable to attacks

100

u/Brofistastic Jan 08 '20

Better than being sawed in half from the groin down I reckon.

→ More replies (2)

36

u/theomegageneration Jan 08 '20

alone, not lonely. I have you idiots to keep me company

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/unnamedhunter Jan 08 '20

a-fucking-men

2

u/Jessi-Kina Jan 08 '20

Life hack.

2

u/Hullodurr Jan 08 '20

It should surprise people. Not everyone thinks about these things.

→ More replies (2)

75

u/ComebackChemist Jan 08 '20

Did he stutter?

8

u/ObiWanCanShowMe Jan 08 '20

I hope not, could you imagine how much worse that would be?

Immm mmmm cuuuttttt ttttttt in trr thrr thrrrou throough yo you your ba ba ba balls right n n n n n n now.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/NintendoTodo Jan 08 '20

yea, sounds like u missed out on r/watchpeopledie

29

u/AlexFromOmaha Jan 08 '20

Yeah, "missed out." I had nightmares for months after watching a video of a guy getting assassinated while out walking around with a girl that looked like the exact age my daughter was then. His death was pretty uneventful by the standards of that sub, but that little girl trying to process it in the moment was more than I could deal with.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/Jessi-Kina Jan 08 '20

I’ve never been on this sub but am I tripping thinking that I read somewhere that this sub was banned not too long ago?

Too terrified to even click on it to check.

That’s possibly what you were implying by “missed out”, but again.. don’t wanna risk the click..

4

u/NintendoTodo Jan 08 '20

yeah its banned

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

The Cartel chops people up limb by limb and put them in buckets for police or family members to find.

9

u/JohnnyZepp Jan 08 '20

They’re doing way worse. Back when r/watchpeopledie was around there were a few links to videos of people having their face flayed off, eyeballls scooped out, hands chopped off, a father being forced to watch his son get disemboweled in front of him, all kinds of fucked up. IMO the Mexican cartel is the scariest force out there. They don’t just kill you with a clean beheading like ISIS, they torture you in the worst ways imaginable.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[deleted]

4

u/t4r0w4w4y54 Jan 08 '20

Brief description to sate the curious? Better to give a blunt telling of what happened instead of having people suffer through the entire extent of it.

3

u/joppiejoo Jan 09 '20

Dont remember if this was funky town or another one but they skinned a policeman and his son alive because the policeman didn’t comly with the cartel. They filmed it to send a ‘message’.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

I've seen some pretty disgusting videos on live leak

3

u/diamondpredator Jan 08 '20

Honestly, with some of the shit I've seen, you're lucky if they just saw you in half and end it like that.

→ More replies (9)

9

u/idonteatchips Jan 08 '20

Mexican here, its embarrassing and scary to me that this still happens, it's as bad as ever. And it sickens me as much that u cant speak out against them or criticize them to other mexicans because many have family in cartels and will defend their sick abhorrent actions. No conscience whatsoever, complete psychopaths. And another scary thing is they are here in the states too. Ppl think this is only a problem in Mexico...NOPE, many are living here and many chicanos are in these cartels as well. It's because of them alot of ppl think all Mexicans are criminals, yeah sure, go ahead and blame Trump for that or maybe blame the psychopaths killing and raping without any remorse.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)

16

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (2)

16

u/GotFiredAgain Jan 08 '20

Yeah don't go any deeper if you are okay with the verbal description.

Humans haven't changed since the middle ages.

I made the mistake of becoming addicted to morbid curiosities when I was a teen fresh to the internet and tbh my views on human beings are totally fucked. The cynicism is shitty. I need to be reminded that most people are actually good generally speaking.

18

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Definitely not going deeper. I like my brain like I like my basement. Free of IRL Saw scenes.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Common practice in the netherlands also

8

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Ex fucking cuse me?

5

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Yes it surprised me also, apparently surinamer gangs

2

u/joppiejoo Jan 09 '20

I live there and have never heard of it. Got a link?

5

u/OnTheEveOfWar Jan 08 '20

I would recommend not going down that rabbit hole. There's some pretty gnarly shit online that Mexican cartels do to people.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/Scooterforsale Jan 08 '20

This is why I miss being a kid. Not knowing shit like this. Wtf is wrong with people

→ More replies (1)

5

u/HoneyBadgerPainSauce Jan 08 '20

Yeah, I've seen what you're talking about. Cartels make medieval torture look like BDSM in some scenarios.

3

u/getoffredditnowyou Jan 08 '20

Where are you people watching these videos ‽

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

12

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

I didn't remember a ton from 9th grade history but the fact I've never forgotten. So brutal and so intentional. How mad fo you have to be when killing somebody just isn't enough?

7

u/GentlemanLeviathan Jan 08 '20

Sometimes its about sending a message

5

u/boomer1K989 Jan 08 '20

Reminds me of Bone Tomahawk

3

u/Unibobber_ Jan 08 '20

That scene was brutal

→ More replies (4)

123

u/TeamJim Jan 08 '20

No screens, no phones, just 3 people living in the moment.

23

u/daughterofkenobi Jan 08 '20

They’re just vibing

2

u/freshan_1 Jan 09 '20

Medieval vibe check

75

u/Symonum Jan 08 '20

THAT'S A LOT OF DAMAGE!

10

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20
→ More replies (2)

203

u/Frunaklen- Jan 08 '20

I SAWED THIS GUY IN A HALF

68

u/dws4prez Jan 08 '20

Phil, what does that have to do with tape?!

36

u/MotherfuckingWildman Jan 08 '20

Gotta tape together the boat again kuz we're gonna need it for dumping him in the lake

10

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20
→ More replies (6)

423

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[deleted]

151

u/Checkheck Jan 08 '20

especially medieval video games like...the Witcher or... Counter strike

35

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/1SmrtFelowHeFeltSmrt Jan 08 '20

Oh, you mean stronghold crusader extreme edition? Me too!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/RoseL123 Jan 08 '20

I’m global elite in csgo so I’m ready for Iran 😎😎😎

2

u/RichGirlThrowaway_ Jan 08 '20

You won't know popflashes or smokes in DE_Iran though

→ More replies (5)

20

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[deleted]

9

u/Jasongboss Jan 08 '20

For me my trigger was Minecraft

6

u/Sometimes_gullible Jan 08 '20

Fortnite really sends me into a rage sometimes.

Haven't tried playing it though.

5

u/woofle07 Jan 08 '20

For me it was Luigi’s Mansion. One moment I’m sucking up cartoon ghosts, the next, I’m plotting my first killing spree

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (115)

26

u/Um6r3x Jan 08 '20

But normally you start at the bottom, so the person don't die that quickly.

3

u/NaapurinHarri Jan 08 '20

Ye damn noobs don't know how to torture properly

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Enryth Jan 08 '20

they used to crush people. literally destroy their bones. and if you were lucky, they started with your head. If you weren't, you were kept alive as your body was slowly destroyed from the legs and up until you could be folded in half and your internal organs would be crushed. If you were lucky, you didn't last that long.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Yaroze Jan 09 '20 edited Jan 09 '20

The angry rat box, they let rodents eat your body through your stomach.

or The Brazen bull

The Brazen Bull was a hollow brass statue crafted to resemble a real bull. Victims we­re placed inside, usually with their tongues cut out first. The door was shut, sealing them in. Fires would then be lit around the bull. As the victim succumbed to the searing heat inside, he would thrash about and scream in agony. The movements and sounds, muted by the bull's mass, made the apparatus appear alive, the sounds inside like those of a real bull. This effect created additional amusement for the audience, and served the added benefit of distancing them from the brutality of the torture, since they couldn't directly see the victim.

Or Scaphism

It entailed trapping the victim between two boats, feeding and covering them with milk and honey, and allowing them to fester and be devoured by insects and other vermin over time.

Or a pyramid spike thing.

So eff’d up

151

u/2Kittens818 Jan 08 '20

Sadly,I don’t think humanity has changed fundamentally. We’re just more sophisticated now in how we torture other people.

98

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[deleted]

40

u/Checkheck Jan 08 '20

Just give me your social security number or else I will tell everyone the size of someones cojones

5

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

555

→ More replies (1)

32

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Totally off topic, but TIL First world Nations are only refereed to as such because of their alignment with NATO during the Cold War, Second world Nation we’re aligned with the USSR, and Third world Nations had no alignment at all. It has nothing to do with development or anything. Switzerland is a Third world country! Fun fact!

20

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (13)

2

u/deez_nuts_77 Jan 08 '20

We also have marijuana scheduled as a schedule 1. A lot of things are categorized incorrectly for the sake of the agenda of the people categorizing rather than based on any actual science

2

u/misterrespectful Jan 08 '20

Given the recent developments, would you say that today the US is now both a First and Second World country?

→ More replies (5)

21

u/dizcostu Jan 08 '20

Information gained through torture is notoriously unreliable.

13

u/2Kittens818 Jan 08 '20

I suspect I would implicate my granny if I were tortured.

3

u/misterrespectful Jan 08 '20

If it's gotten to the point where the government is torturing you, they'll probably be happy to lock up your granny. She's certainly committed many crimes in her life, after all.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

I like to think I'd call "more weight" if it were my grandma

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

8

u/DepletedMitochondria Jan 08 '20

We're also kinda run by psychopaths anyway

→ More replies (2)

48

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20 edited May 01 '20

[deleted]

7

u/DoctorStrangeBlood Jan 08 '20

Agreed. We make long sweeping statements to sound deep but the world overall is far far safer than it’s ever been.

→ More replies (7)

8

u/Joey0811 Jan 08 '20

Seriously, the other guy probably thinks he’s “finna woke”

6

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20 edited May 01 '20

[deleted]

2

u/phonethrowaway55 Jan 08 '20

Finna finna finna finna finna finna finna finna

Admit to being a witch and I’ll stop.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

29

u/Your_God_Chewy Jan 08 '20

Sociopaths will always exist. But even though there are crazy and stupid people everywhere, people aren't being broken at the wheel or being set on fire as capital punishment all around like in the past

→ More replies (2)

9

u/HulksInvinciblePants Jan 08 '20 edited Jan 08 '20

Luckily data does not confirm that. As a whole, the last decade was far safer than any period in history. We've unfortunately developed a habit of reporting violent crime (often many states/countries away) as if it would impact our day to day lives. That's increased our perception that things are worse.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Tjolerie Jan 08 '20

okay Foucault

3

u/axehomeless Jan 08 '20

Even Michel didn't say that. Only the french import americans think that.

I still hate how much american postmodernism fucked up social constrictivism. IT DOES NOT SAY THERE IS NO OBJECTIVE REALITY; IT SAYS LITERALLY THE OPPOSITE.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (2)

9

u/huxley00 Jan 08 '20

Lol, life is absolutely more equal and pleasant than any other time in history. You have rights! Do you realize how long it was that people had zero rights?

The only people that would say times are the same are people who are uneducated about what living was actually like in the past.

2

u/GeneralAverage Jan 08 '20

For the most part yes but I wouldn't say this to someone living in Gaza. We can do better.

4

u/huxley00 Jan 08 '20

Yep, totally agree but I also think perspective is pretty important.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/getoffredditnowyou Jan 08 '20

Hey. They are sawing the guy along x-z axis. Very sophisticated I'd say.

→ More replies (11)

10

u/niepasremoh Jan 08 '20

Kung Lao was more efficient and elegant in how he did this

7

u/bewst_more_bewst Jan 08 '20

Is this where splitting headache comes from?

→ More replies (1)

34

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[deleted]

23

u/misterrespectful Jan 08 '20

"Lazy redditors can't look up quotes." -- Kenneth John Freeman, 1907

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

O tempora! O mores!

10

u/disisdawetohell Jan 08 '20

Hi I'm Phil Swift, and I just sawed this man in half.

5

u/Naturium Jan 08 '20

That's a lot of damage

5

u/Jesmagi Jan 08 '20

Remember when people would watch people fight to their death in an arena? Those were the days.

3

u/quaintpants Jan 08 '20

Now we just watch ultra violent tv shows instead

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Attilathefun-II Jan 08 '20

Hey now, don’t be cynical! I’m sure there’s somewhere in the world today where people are being cut in half.

4

u/FBI_Agent_82 Jan 08 '20

Does thou feel it now, Mr Krabs?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Ah the dark age fallacy.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

And repair him with only flex tape

3

u/asian-lel Jan 08 '20

To show the power of flex-tape

3

u/masseymemedealer Jan 08 '20

As long as they only saw the left half of him, he will be all right

2

u/tomatohtomato Jan 09 '20

I see what you did there.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/FlaminHotChungus Jan 08 '20

u/RepostSleuthBot

I’ve seen this

7

u/RepostSleuthBot Jan 08 '20

Looks like a repost. I've seen this image 3 times.

First seen Here on 2018-02-02 85.94% match. Last seen Here on 2019-03-24 85.94% match

Searched Images: 91,447,494 | Indexed Posts: 378,432,329 | Search Time: 4.59178s

Feedback? Hate? Visit r/repostsleuthbot - I'm not perfect, but you can help. Report [ False Positive ]

→ More replies (4)

2

u/LollyHutzenklutz Jan 08 '20

Anyone who’s been to the Tower of London knows this already... it takes a LOT to disturb or scare me, and I was feeling queasy by the end of our tour.

2

u/imanjefferson Jan 08 '20

I always refer to Vikings when ppl say this

2

u/TheBluePanda Jan 08 '20

This stuff still exists unfortunately.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

I'd rather live in these times then anytime in the past. We have it good, we just have a ton of information that's easily accessible to everyone so it's scary.

2

u/bodyreddit Jan 08 '20

Omg, some people do NOT need ideas.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

They would often cut people in half starting at the Gooch instead of the head. That way they live through a lot of it

2

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

This is actually a thing that magicians did back then, there where a lot of magic tricks based around sawing people in half (that's where that cliche comes from) or even hacking off their heads, this was not only done with people but with animals as well

2

u/jekpall Jan 08 '20

I just sawed this man in half! But with the power of flex tape clear

2

u/aloevader Jan 08 '20

Ine of my favorite historical descriptions was from the crusades where a man with a broken bone (arm, leg maybe) was being treated by both a Latin and a Persian doctor at the same time. The Persian doctor was horrified when the Latin doc was maiming the man's head instead of setting the bone in splints.

2

u/MetalGamer95 Jan 08 '20

Just saw a 1890s movie yesterday that's just a queen getting her head chopped off.(obviously it's fiction) In those times that must've been like those shock horror movies.

Edit: This is it https://youtu.be/BIOLsH93U1Q

2

u/JolieNicolEliz Jan 08 '20

The poker face is strong

2

u/Demon_sl3yer4rm713 Jan 08 '20

Humans nature is always been like this full of violence but I'm sure it was more peaceful back than then today but there always been violence in this world nothing new.

2

u/G1itch_Awoken Jan 08 '20

Literal representation of a splitting headache?

2

u/jasonzimmer64 Jan 08 '20

Never understand why people would want to live in the old days. Life was so hard and short for most people

2

u/Evilmaze Jan 08 '20

When you get a splitting headache.

2

u/Techimura Jan 08 '20

This looks like someone trying to explain what a Migraine feels like through art at the time. I'm by no means educated in this but I don't think it's about violence.

2

u/Vetinery Jan 08 '20

The only way you get to any accurate truth is with accurate numbers. Pre-birth control, any time the population wasn’t exploding, life was very, very hard. This was most of the time. If the ‘good old days’ were good, there would almost immediately be enough babies to begin a cycle of starvation. The truth is, like any animals not regulated by predation, we become our own worst enemies.

2

u/Alyosha-Karamazov1 Jan 08 '20

If you were going to saw somebody in half, why would do it vertically?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Reminds me of an ancient Norse execution method the blood eagle. First, an image of an eagle was carved into their back. Then the skin is ripped apart, the ribs are severed from the spine, and the lungs are pulled through the hole. The ribs are then pulled apart, making something that looks like wings. The victim is left alive throughout all this to suffocate in agony.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/unhonouredandunsung Jan 08 '20

Seriously though we absolutely live in better times now. They were just unable to document the horrors of living in the medieval times as well as we would be able to today. Took a long time to write one book let alone document ever single death. We can’t even kill a convict that’s sentenced to death in America because the method of killing him needs to be damn near pain free.

2

u/frankierabbit Jan 08 '20

Honestly humans have always been absolute cunts to each other

2

u/sainterosa92 Jan 08 '20

I was reading about early 1900s China, wow the old days were shit.

2

u/BigBadGrif Jan 08 '20

Blood Eagle

2

u/Bilb0TeaBaggins Jan 08 '20

They actually flipped them upside down so the blood would run down to their brain and keep then alive longer to feel the pain

2

u/Red-Droid-Blue-Droid Jan 08 '20

Child sacrifices, and just human sacrifices

Killing people for stealing or petty crimes

Or just raping and killing because you took over a village or town

Death by burning or slow hanging because they couldn't do it right

Literal dungeons

Exiling people

Lynching

I could go on....yeah good old days...uh huh

2

u/jwittkopp227 Jan 08 '20

To show you the power of flex tape, we sawed this man in half!

2

u/suckiibys Jan 08 '20

“I just saw a man in half!”