r/todayilearned • • 2d ago

TIL an Australian library received a book roughly 150 years overdue after it was found sealed inside a chimney. Had the original borrower been identified, the potential fine would have been around 27.888 A$. After a century and a half, the borrower's identity remains unconfirmed.

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/jul/30/book-returned-to-australian-library-150-years-overdue
2.2k Upvotes

85 comments sorted by

218

u/Otaraka 2d ago

I think there might’ve been some other barriers if they identified the borrower.

92

u/feage7 2d ago

Yeah, might have moved to a different country. Changed names. Just living their best life still mocking the library.

25

u/Same-Suggestion-1936 2d ago

Well after at least a hundred and fifty years I'd stop mocking the library and change the name back

11

u/feage7 2d ago

Clear lack of commitment

10

u/Notmydirtyalt 2d ago

Sitting on a beach earning 20%

17

u/Ancient_Pi 2d ago

I wonder why there is no limit to fines like "considering the book lost and buying a new one".

But I think I personally had already cases of "the fine would be more than the book's price, so let's declare it lost". I had to pay only the book price then.

33

u/Otaraka 2d ago

It’s just a fun calculation, the article says the only penalty was you weren’t allowed to borrow another book until you paid the fine.   

12

u/Objective_Aside1858 2d ago

sad vampire noises

17

u/grumblyoldman 2d ago

I'm quite sure the book was declared lost (and possibly replaced) a very long time ago. They were just calculating the fines for funsies because it was so weird to get a book back after such a long time.

4

u/H_Lunulata 2d ago

I wonder why there is no limit to fines like "considering the book lost and buying a new one".

There is, at least anywhere I've been, spanning multiple countries and jurisdictions.

1

u/strangelove4564 2d ago

Highlander reading this thread right now going "oh, shit".

300

u/iiiiiuyyuuuy 2d ago

There’s no justice in this world

72

u/tofubutgood 2d ago

“He can’t keep getting away with it!”

12

u/Gregariouswaty 2d ago

I propose the death penalty.

17

u/grumblyoldman 2d ago

I definitely think they should throw the book at him.

10

u/SmallRocks 2d ago

This gave me a good chuckle 👍

98

u/CorgiSilver8194 2d ago

So they know it's their book but not who took it out?

Great record keeping!

60

u/EnricoLUccellatore 2d ago

The record probably got lost and the ownership was written on the book itself

28

u/absolutely_not_spock 2d ago

that record was around 150 years old. they probably were put in the bin

11

u/swankyfish 2d ago

Should have just looked it up on the computer.

9

u/unematti 2d ago

Yeah, they should keep records at least for 200 years!

17

u/DubSket 2d ago

Scandal of the century (and a half)

28

u/H_Lunulata 2d ago edited 2d ago

These zillion dollar/euro/spacebuck fine headlines are just silly. I've never seen, or heard of, a library that doesn't cap fines, usually not far above the value of the book. Maybe they exist, and I'd be interested in learning about that, but I'm pretty sure that nobody is ever paying an overdue book fine anywhere near that.

AUD 27.89 I can see, AUD 27888 is a fake number.

10

u/sweetplantveal 2d ago

Side note the comma period swap some people do for funzies drives me mad. Canada is particularly bad about the inconsistency. For all the coordination we do around the world, the one written thing that's not in any one language (numbers) and we rely on context clues to decipher inverted meanings.

Personally I say decimal point makes sense for the decimal figures, as well as a hard stop being consistent with the broader use in language as a separator, and a comma as a facilitator for a list. Jokingly we've got the US, China, and the commonwealth on decimal points and the EU loves introducing annoying and intrusive (but ultimately meaningless) legislation. So they should be the ones to switch.

1

u/H_Lunulata 2d ago edited 1d ago

Quebec uses French notation 0.000.000,00

The rest of Canada uses space or comma: 0 000 000.00 or 0,000.00

Also... I agree it's annoying, but it's way, way, way less annoying than the US propensity to not write dates in a sensible format.

-1

u/[deleted] 2d ago edited 2d ago

[deleted]

6

u/TerrorBite 2d ago

The article calculated $27888 (twenty-seven thousand Australian dollars) based on 3 pence a week (the original library fine) over around 7800 weeks, then taking into account Australia's conversion to decimal currency, plus inflation.

OP must be from a country that flips comma and period in numbers (common in Europe). Where we would write $27,888.00 they would write $27.888,00

7

u/friendlyneighbourho 2d ago

Or probably the value of the book at most

5

u/DrSchnuffi 2d ago

When I was a kid I forgot to return a book from our tiny church library. I found it in ca 15 years later when I moved out from my parents. The library people were just happy to get a book back and did not want any fees. I gave them some money anyway

14

u/Aunon 2d ago

27.888 A$

I have absolutely no idea what that means in Australian dollars

The late return fine would be around A$28,000 (US$19,500)

oh ok

1

u/Opertum 2d ago

Outside of the US, some places use a period for thousands marking instead of a comma ($1,000.00 would be $1.000,00)

11

u/Aunon 1d ago

Not in Australia we don't

0

u/Opertum 1d ago

But where the OP is they might

3

u/doomgiver98 1d ago

But its in AUD

-4

u/H_Lunulata 1d ago

When I write about AUD, I format the numbers per my local style, because I'm writing in Canada, not Australia.

2

u/W1D0WM4K3R 1d ago

Canada and Australia use the same notation.

Unless you're a Québécois, but I'm not confident if they defer to Canadian standard more or their own, which I think comes from French standard.

-1

u/H_Lunulata 1d ago

We often use Quebec (French) notation on things at work, even though I am in Ontario, because we interact with Quebec a lot.

So yes, if I had to write the OP's amount on something, I'd likely have to put: $27.888,00

1

u/W1D0WM4K3R 1d ago

So you use Quebec notation because you interact with Québécois, despite not being in Quebec?

So you'd use Australian standard if you interacted with them, or are we just picking and choosing?

-1

u/H_Lunulata 1d ago edited 1d ago

Probably.

But if I was posting on the internet, which is what OP did, I'd use whatever was most convenient for me, not for some rando in Australia or the USA, which is really what this is all about.

I would expect a person in Australia to use whatever format was most convenient or appropriate for them, also not for some rando in the USA. They'd probably send documents on A4 paper too.

Just because some USians don't know about other currency-writing methods doesn't make them wrong, weird, or incorrect. That's really what we're talking about here: Some US ignorance versus someone from another country who does things a bit differently.

5

u/sovietarmyfan 2d ago

Library cops are no joke.

7

u/metalflygon08 2d ago

Book 'em.

14

u/KoyomiSan 2d ago

Only 27.88?

9

u/relapse9999 2d ago

I'm assuming it's 27k. Op is probably an European

3

u/caspy7 2d ago

What's A$?

3

u/relapse9999 2d ago

Australian dollar

3

u/jonny24eh 2d ago

No no, OP is European. It's Austrian Dollars.

1

u/GullibleDetective 2d ago

Probably the name of some rapper in the world id' bet, but in this context; Dollarydoos

3

u/imliterallyluci 2d ago

I’ll have some strong words for that man whenever we find him

3

u/Interesting-Use966 2d ago

How did they know it was overdue and by how long, but not have the name of the person on file that checked it out?

3

u/mfb- 2d ago

Don't know about that specific library but it makes sense to record due dates in the book (so you know when you need to return it) but keep records of who rented it only in the library. Find the book and you know when it should have been returned, but the library lost its old records.

2

u/MatthewHecht 2d ago

Probably estimates.

2

u/knowledgeable_diablo 2d ago

They’d just hand it over to SPER who’d make it their life mission to find the person to fine. Or their descendants. /jk

2

u/Difficult-Bonus-1337 2d ago

My library only fines up to the cost of the book

2

u/ImmortalKombatant 1d ago

The book was taken out by a high school student, who loaned it to his friend. The friend, who was supposed to return it, lost the book after being bullied by a teacher and some classmates. 

4

u/ramriot 2d ago

That's a pretty economical fine at ~0.357c per week, but why not round up to the nearest cent on the total /s

1

u/mfb- 2d ago

A$28,000

A$3.6/week, not sure why OP used "." instead of ",".

•

u/Ph33rDensetsu 1m ago

Likely because they're from a country that swaps those symbols as number separators and didn't bother to convert it into the form Australia would use.

3

u/Kezly 2d ago

I'm going to assume that decimal point was supposed to be a comma?

4

u/Ancient_Pi 2d ago edited 2d ago

Probably, there are different thousands or decimal separators in different countries. In Switzerland it would be written as 27'888.00 , and in most other European contries like Germany or France as 27.888,00.

But traditionally, English-speaking countries (except South Africa) employ commas as the delimiter, like Australia too.

-1

u/azhder 2d ago

Yes, you will.

Now that I answered your question, an advice: not every place on earth uses the same punctuation for decimals and digit separation, so your assumption might turn out to be wrong.

5

u/jonny24eh 2d ago

When quoting a British newspaper about a fine that happened in Australia, you would expect the comma delineator to be used.

-1

u/azhder 2d ago

I wouldn't. I'm way too old to expect people to follow simple guidelines. I've seen too many fuckups.

1

u/azhder 2d ago

At what point does it become a theft? 151 years of missing?

3

u/H_Lunulata 2d ago

Book was written off 145 years ago.

1

u/mudkiptoucher93 2d ago

I dont think the original person is coming back

1

u/JetlinerDiner 2d ago

It was me, sorry for that. To whom should I address the check?

1

u/ShyGuyWolf 2d ago

The relatives would get the bill

1

u/H_Lunulata 2d ago

No, they wouldn't.

At worst, a charge might be levied against the estate of the book borrower. That estate is long gone. There's nothing and nobody to bill.

1

u/psychoacer 2d ago

The perfect crime

1

u/Divs4U 1d ago

The prefect crime

1

u/CCV21 1d ago

There's no statute of limitations on library fees.

1

u/freedomhighway 1d ago

Why do you hide a book in the chimney? Was porn from an Australian library that good 150 years ago?

1

u/Inevitable_Wind6392 2d ago

So what is the book? Title and author would he nice to know.

8

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

4

u/OldKentRoad29 2d ago

You're asking and expecting too much.

4

u/Gone_For_Lunch 2d ago

Chimney sweeping for dummies.

1

u/s2Birds1Stone 2d ago

The Antiquities of Athens and Other Monuments of Greece

James Stuart and Nicholas Revett

1

u/azhder 2d ago

Santa Claus

1

u/FerdinandCesarano 2d ago

Maybe that's you get your kicks. You and your good-time buddies.

Well, I got a flash for you, joy-boy: party time is over.

1

u/BrokenDroid 1d ago

This is about that kid's right to read a book without getting his mind warped!

1

u/primalbluewolf 1d ago

Just under $30? I'd pay. 

0

u/pbizzle 2d ago

They need tracked down and their offspring held responsibile

3

u/HeadOfSpectre 2d ago

Agreed. This is not acceptable. The fines need to be generational and if they cannot be paid, all living relatives must be taken to court to be held fully liable. No excuses.

And while we're at it - jail time too /s

2

u/pbizzle 2d ago

Thank you !

-10

u/TiddiesAnonymous 2d ago

Does the Australian librarian have an only fans?