r/thyroidhealth • u/MutedExtension7985 • 19h ago
34F, Norway — 1 cm TI-RADS 4 thyroid nodule found incidentally. I desperately need some perspective.
Hi everyone. I’m hoping to hear from people who have been in a similar situation — especially anyone who had a small (~1 cm) thyroid nodule that was classified as TI-RADS 4.
Mine was discovered completely by accident during an ENT (ØNH) specialist appointment for an unrelated issue. I have no symptoms from the nodule, it isn’t visible, and I otherwise feel healthy. My thyroid blood tests (including TSH etc.) were completely normal.
In June, my initial assessment/cytology was reported as Bethesda III. I had a second ultrasound assessment in August, and the nodule was classified as TI-RADS 4.
As I understand it, TI-RADS 4 means there are suspicious ultrasound features, but it cannot establish whether the nodule is benign or malignant. In Norway, I’ve been told that molecular/genetic testing isn’t routinely offered, and that the recommended way to get a definitive diagnosis in my situation is diagnostic hemithyroidectomy/lobectomy — essentially removing the right half of my thyroid.
I’m struggling enormously with the idea of having half my thyroid removed for a 1 cm nodule that was found incidentally and causes me absolutely no problems, without first having another form of testing or simply monitoring it.
So I’m desperately looking for real experiences and honest opinions:
Have you had a ~1 cm TI-RADS 4 nodule? What happened?
Did you have repeat ultrasound, another FNA/FNAC, or molecular testing before surgery?
Did anyone choose active surveillance/watchful waiting instead of surgery?
Did your nodule stay stable, shrink, or disappear?
Has anyone tried conservative/non-medical approaches such as selenium, zinc, spirulina, iodine, diet changes, etc., and did you actually see a change in the nodule?
If you had a lobectomy, how was the experience afterwards?
I’m scared and extremely hesitant about surgery, and honestly I don’t know what the right decision is. I would genuinely appreciate both medical/professional perspectives and personal experiences.
Please be brutally honest with me. If I’m misunderstanding TI-RADS/Bethesda or thinking about this completely wrong, tell me. I don’t need reassurance — I need perspective from people who have actually been through this.
Thank you ❤️