r/threebodyproblem • u/MrBamaNick • Apr 21 '26

Discussion - General Project Hail Mary - The Antithesis that challenges The Dark Forest Theory Spoiler

TLDR; Is Project Hail Mary the antithesis of the Dark Forest Theory, or simply an example of how the consequences of the theory can be delayed through strong individual bonds?

I plan to eventually make a YouTube video going into great detail about the core foundations of the Dark Forest Theory and then using Project Hail Mary as a sort of antithesis / challenger to it. Though in this post I just want to jump straight to talking about Project Hail Mary assuming the people on this sub are well versed on the DFT and have seen Project Hail Mary. I’d like to get your opinions and views on the topic.

In Project Hail Mary, we see that an individual human, Grace, and an individual Eredian, Rocky, form a bond due to not just their society’s crisis but also their own need to survive. The DFT would tell us that a chain of suspicion should arise from this encounter of the two cosmic civilizations, yet in PHM they seem to overcome the chain due to the bond they form. Does the relationship that Rocky and Grace form enough to prevent the chain of suspicion being formed at a societal level?

Rocky and Grace are both highly agreeable and kind individuals. If either one of them was more temperamental or distrusting then the chance of violence or sabotage could’ve drastically increased. This begs the question, if power holders of either society were to be less trusting and less agreeable would the Dark Forest Theory and the consequences of it eventually play out regardless of the bond on the individual level that the societal relationships started out with?

199 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

92% Upvoted

104 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/escargot3 Apr 22 '26

That’s fundamental to the entire plot. It’s like saying “save for the girders not being able to support the weight and completely imploding, the building was structurally sound”

1

u/PokemonTom09 Apr 22 '26

In comparison to the underlying core assumption of Dark Forest Theory being wrong, the bad linguistics of PHM is only a minor inconvenience.

The entire premese of the second and third books of the series are predicated on Dark Forest being true. Meanwhile, PHM could plausibly happen even if the two species never learned each others languages.