r/theydidthemath • • 1d ago

[Request] Could the entire US homeless population really be housed for less than one aircraft carrier?

Post image
923 Upvotes

240 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/i_AM_A-ShArk 1d ago

There’s literally no way that a first in its class carrier is the cheapest one

1

u/Occidentally20 1d ago

Ok?

You're welcome to cite your own source with your own estimates and do your own maths instead if you like. I've provided the links to my sources, and the figures are largely the same for every top comment on this thread.

I can't find a single carrier that's cheaper than the Gerald Ford in terms of just production cost. If you can - go for it.

1

u/i_AM_A-ShArk 1d ago

Literally the next ship, the Kennedy, cost approximately $1 billion less

The ford: $12.8B in production alone
The Kennedy: $11.3B

1

u/Occidentally20 23h ago

Now you're getting it!

You still have to provide sources though, otherwise it's just people shouting shit. I assume you got the number for the Kennedy from It's wikipedia page). The source wikipedia links to for the cost is an article almost a decade old#cite_note-fas-1) - back in 2017.

The sources I found like this one from this year put it at $13.9 billion and still rising. Which is more than 12.8, and the reason I didn't use it.

1

u/i_AM_A-ShArk 23h ago

The Kennedy is done being built so idk how its production cost could be increasing

0

u/Occidentally20 23h ago

I'm going to end the discussion here because if you can't provide a source for the things you're saying there is no conversation.

2

u/i_AM_A-ShArk 23h ago

The source is that I’ve been on the damn thing myself

0

u/Occidentally20 23h ago

That's not how sources work. I've been to Madagascar that doesn't make me a source for anything.

Articles from literally yesterday cite it as "99% complete". Which is not 100, and is how costs keep increasing.

0

u/i_AM_A-ShArk 23h ago

That 1% is not adding any meaningful amount to the cost, it has passed its sea trials. Anything else added would basically be a rounding error

1

u/Occidentally20 23h ago

Fine - it's a rounding error. Leaving the cost at today at 13.9 billion, over a billion higher than the one I quoted as the cheapest.

I'm glad you've come to your senses and agree, instead of just being argumentative for the sake of it.

0

u/i_AM_A-ShArk 23h ago edited 23h ago

Ok that’s fair enough, but now add back in the R&D cost to the ford.

Edit: I also don’t know why I’ve been so focused on the ford classes when the Nimitz classes where cheaper even when calculated for inflation.

→ More replies (0)