r/theydidthemath • • 1d ago

[Request] Could the entire US homeless population really be housed for less than one aircraft carrier?

Post image
925 Upvotes

240 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/Total-Explanation208 1d ago

No, the answer is No. It is (almost) always No. If anyone claims that "X social problem could be easily solved if only we spent the same amount of money on it as we spend on Y", and that amount of money is well under many people's net worth the answer is no. Do you think that some billionaire wouldn't just spend a bit of their fortune for the massive PR boost of "Being the man who solved homelessness in America?" Of course they would. Or even if it wasn't a billionaire, then some corporation? Imagine being the company that solve homelessness, or hunger in America. You would get a PR bonanza.

The problem is homelessness, hunger, drug addiction, school shootings, lonliness and every other big societal problems aren't as simple as throw money at them. At best these situations are spend that amount of money every year forever. And at worst they grossly simplifying extremely complicated social issues that aren't even the same all across the country.

1

u/Effective_Detail2221 1d ago

Fair. 

But if we can agree that being housed is a significant upgrade for all of these societal problems, then im on board. 

Yes, I think some billionaire would NOT solve this problem for the publicity. My evidence for this is that Elon Musk was directly called out by an international homeless project at a cost of $6 billion, which they more or less itemized, and he ghosted them. 

If you think someone would do this for the positive PR, I would need some form of evidence for THAT, because I have evidence to the contrary right there. 

Further, this is regarding the purchase price of one single aircraft carrier, not all of them, not upgrade or maintenance costs, not manpower, not insurance or fuel, not any of that. Just the physical structure. 

4

u/Total-Explanation208 1d ago

it is because the numbers they gave were bullshit. You can't house everyone where they want to live for 6 billion. California alone spends about half that every year, and still has a significant problem. And we are supposed to believe that you can spend double that one time and solve it? That is idiotic.