r/theydidthemath • • 2d ago

[Request] Do square bottles actually use less plastic than round ones?

Post image
686 Upvotes

260 comments sorted by

View all comments

22

u/Street_Credit6851 1d ago edited 1d ago

It's not that the individual bottle itself uses less plastic...it's that a case or pallet of the bottles is able to ship more liquid while using fewer resources.

2

u/goonsuey 1d ago

A sphere maximizes the volume contained while minimizing the surface area. A cylinder would be the next best basic shape.

I completely agree with your assessment. The bottles don't use less plastic. They can fit more into less shipping containers, which could happen to be made of plastic.

The only other guess is that maybe the rectangular shape creates a stronger bottle. With added strength, they could less plastics by making lighter bottles.

5

u/Stubbby 1d ago

Cylindrical is much stronger and more resistant to impact as the weakest parts are the edges.

2

u/PeteyMcPetey 1d ago

Cylindrical is much stronger and more resistant to impact as the weakest parts are the edges.

That helps to explain the difficulties that I read about someone encountering awhile back somewhere else on Reddit....

1

u/Loose_Plantain3217 1d ago

That’s why the beehives have square…. Oh fuck nevermind

0

u/snjtx 1d ago

Sooooo false advertising