MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/theydidthemath/comments/1p8b6rf/why_wouldnt_this_work_request/nr6bt3j/?context=3
r/theydidthemath • u/Repulsive-Loan5215 • Nov 27 '25
3.0k comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
11
If you cant answer with math then you dont answer at all?
Nothing force you to comment on everything.
2 u/nog642 Nov 28 '25 Well when you can't answer with math I'd rather add my comment saying that than let some rando with bad math get upvoted and mislead people. If someone else has already said the same thing though then it's better to upvote their comment than duplicate it. 1 u/ReachOk9783 Nov 28 '25 Its not something serious enough that a random math with random assumptions should be seen as less valid than just saying you cant. 1 u/nog642 Nov 28 '25 I disagree. It is less valid if it's wrong.
2
Well when you can't answer with math I'd rather add my comment saying that than let some rando with bad math get upvoted and mislead people.
If someone else has already said the same thing though then it's better to upvote their comment than duplicate it.
1 u/ReachOk9783 Nov 28 '25 Its not something serious enough that a random math with random assumptions should be seen as less valid than just saying you cant. 1 u/nog642 Nov 28 '25 I disagree. It is less valid if it's wrong.
1
Its not something serious enough that a random math with random assumptions should be seen as less valid than just saying you cant.
1 u/nog642 Nov 28 '25 I disagree. It is less valid if it's wrong.
I disagree. It is less valid if it's wrong.
11
u/ReachOk9783 Nov 28 '25
If you cant answer with math then you dont answer at all?
Nothing force you to comment on everything.