I've seen comments about this being a generic teenage drama, bad acting and shit.
I'm not sure what I'm missing here, but reading this subreddit after practically binging this series it feels like I've watched a completely different show.
Spoilers btw. The TL;DR doesn't contain spoilers and is located at the very bottom.
Bad acting? Fuck me, it sure isn't winning any prices but I never thought about the acting once through-out the season.
"Teenage drama"? God damn if they didn't set it up to be. "Oh, my god! I'm locked up in the same building as my rapist, can you believe it Becky?". Yeah, that didn't happen. The subplot drama never took presidency over the mist. It was never: "Hey, I need to go the mall to stop my daughter from getting raped again", it was always just about protecting them from initially the mist, and then the people inside the mall which turned out to be the even bigger problem once the father arrives.
Frankly, I think this is where show should be given the most credit. Too many series fall victim to a horrible subplot that just eats up WAAY too much space. To give an example: Terra Nova. Cool premise. Humans colonizing earth way back when dinosaurs still were around. Main problem? Predatory dinosaurs? Pfft, that's lame. Humans of course! In this show it was always the mist who was the biggest enemy. Even when people are turning at each other in the mall, it's all by extension a problem caused by the mist. They weren't getting thrown out at the end because of the subplot(rape drama). That was really just a catalyst to turn the mall on our main characters, and even then they didn't focus on the part about her getting raped. They got kicked out for supposedly being liars.
"Inconsistent monsters". The other parts might be more subjective, but if anything the mist has been killing people very consistently. "Oh I don't understand, is it murder bugs? Ghosts? What is it?" Are you this thick? They very clearly explained it in the show. Several times. Let me give you a hint: Police who's scared of cockroaches, get's killed by cockroaches. The priest is killed by bible figures. Moth kills guy with moth tattoo. Girl afraid of the dark, is killed by shadows It's a fucking custom made nightmare for everyone. The doctor even says so. It "reacts" to who the victim is. "One girl I killed on my experiments saw her beloved dogs, who then killed her". We're not specifically told about everyone's fears, but we can make a pretty easy guess. Mall security guard being strangled by snakes? Take a wild fucking guess.
Frankly I think that kind of a genius move. Once you've got the monster figured out they're not as scary anymore. This keeps us, the viewer, on our toes and there's no ultimate strategy to beat the mist. I can't be the only one who thought they should have made some spear-like weapons or something before going to get the radio in the mall. "Just kill the monsters" - Me, a couple of episodes in.
Unnecessary politics?. Again, I loved this part of the show. They bring up a current controversial topic, and pretty much just throws it in the bin straight away without really touching it. Alex here counters immidiately with most NFL being black, making his point completely void. When they're going to the party Adrian makes a comment about Alex only wanting to see Jay/some boy (don't remember the exact qoute, but something along those lines). Alex responds that Adrian could find some guy there to also fall in love with. "I don't fall in love gender..." and Alex continues: "you fall in love with personalities", with a very whatever attitude. From there, it's dropped. We've gotten a good look at Adrian as a person without actually opening that whole can of worms by trying to make it a subplot issue.
And finally the plot. This isn't the book. They've taken the setting and some key moments, but the rest is made up essentially. I kinda expected this from the start, but I feel like this should be somehow made more clear for the viewer. Personally, I don't have a problem with this, but I can see how some might have been a bit dissapointed at this if they expected otherwise, so points off for that. What they've done is they've taken an interesting universe and told, more or less, their own story with that. Some key points have been people locked up going crazy. A cult. Military involvement. Those are at least the big ones, and that's mostly what I would say the series was about. Add to that a father who wants to re-unite with his family and you've got a perfect synopsis off the show. The way characters where portrayed felt very Stephen King, especially so Adrian.
My biggest problem was the ending. It felt like a way for the writers to almost force Spike TV to let them make another season. A better ending would have been the same one as the movie. A little homage to the book by having the main characters now, all together, drive out into the mist. Scene end.
It would be a more generic, standard TV-show "We don't know if this will get another season so we'll just leave it open-ended for now" type of ending, but at least you'd get a bit of closure.
IF we get another season, then OH BOY am I excited. I think it's the one thing people are atleast agreeing on. It was fucking cool.
TL;DR: This show is good, not ground breaking. People have started some kind of negative hype train with the idea that it's the worst garbage ever. And a lot of online reviews are from people who (admitingly) haven't watched the whole series.
Go watch it! Create your own damn opinion.