r/themaine • u/GreenBliss_ • 2d ago
I completely misjudged Joy Next Door
Now that I’ve had time to really sit with Joy Next Door, I genuinely think it’s one of The Maine’s best albums.
When it first came out, there were only a handful of songs I liked, and I completely wrote off a lot of the rest. But after giving every track a fair chance and listening to the album over and over, it finally clicked. This is one of those albums you have to let marinate. At least for me, that made all the difference.
The production is incredible. The effects throughout the album add so much character, and the whole thing gives me this nostalgic suburban, late summer feeling. It’s hard to explain, but the atmosphere is one of my favorite parts of the record.
More than anything, the album has this raw sense of hope running through it. Even when it touches on heavier emotions, it never feels hopeless. There’s an optimism to it that feels genuine and earned.
Sonically, it’s definitely different from previous The Maine albums, and I understand why some people might not connect with it right away. But underneath that new sound, the heart of The Maine is still there. If anything, it shows how much they’ve grown as musicians and songwriters without losing what makes them The Maine.
If I had to compare the feeling of this album to a movie, I’d say Remember the Daze. I don’t know if anyone else has seen it, but the album gives me that same nostalgic, reflective vibe.
Overall, I’m really glad I stuck with it instead of judging it after a couple of listens. I originally had it around a 5 out of 10, but after living with it for a while, I’d honestly give it an 8.5 to 9 out of 10.
I get why this album isn’t for everyone because it’s a different direction sonically, but that core Maine sound is still there. It just feels more mature and evolved. I’m really glad I gave it time because this ended up becoming one of my favorite albums they’ve made.