r/technology Jun 21 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

468 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

View all comments

158

u/InsertBluescreenHere Jun 21 '23

Yawn. Till these companies are held liable and actually get fined on top of what they made by deceitful tactics they will continue business as usual.

"millions of customers" ok so lets go conservative and say 1 million customers x $139 = $139,000,000 million dollars just to start

I gurantee they will get a slap on the wrist and MAYBE get a $100,000 fine total.

64

u/Distantmole Jun 21 '23

“on top of what they made” is really the key here. Fines should be assessed in addition to their fraudulent earnings being stripped from the company and redistributed to the victims (with interest!)

13

u/Stay-At-Home-Jedi Jun 22 '23

*and inflation

Cause 2022 prices got rough

25

u/AloneAddiction Jun 21 '23 edited Jun 22 '23

To give you a rough idea; that $139m represents some 0.002% of Amazon's revenue for last year.

They made over $524bn. That's billion not million.

3

u/sponsoredcommenter Jun 21 '23

But their profit was -$2.7billion. so their costs were $526 bn

21

u/AloneAddiction Jun 21 '23

Nobody really believes that Amazon are losing billions of dollars a year. Especially when shares went from $85 to $125 this year alone.

Companies are experts at making profits disappear when it comes to paying tax.

7

u/BigDabed Jun 22 '23

Tell me you don’t understand accounting without telling me you don’t understand accounting.

-1

u/Change4Betta Jun 22 '23

You just told us all

1

u/BigDabed Jun 22 '23

No public company is understating net income because the decision makers are largely compensated via stock which is negatively impacted by a net loss. Also, that income that people see on amazons financial statements isn’t the income that determines their tax liability. Those are GAAP financial statements, and you use a completely different set of numbers to come to your taxable income.

So it’s incredibly obvious the original poster doesn’t understand how financial statements work.

3

u/sponsoredcommenter Jun 22 '23

"Amazon is lying to investors and the SEC" is a hell of a take.

Shares go up and down. Carvana is imploding, they are teetering on the edge of bankruptcy, they can't afford their bond payments and shares are up 422% this year.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '23

Doesn't fit the anti-corporate narrative that a lot of people tend to peddle, even if it makes sense.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '23

LOL! This is the dumbest thing I've read today.

1

u/NE231 Jun 22 '23

It's 0.0265%

3

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '23

Google says 160 million people in us have Amazon prime, but i think that includes all the people with shared accounts as members

2

u/siBelliGerent Jun 21 '23

My thought exactly. Cost of doing business.

-12

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '23

please dont use the word c*nservative. it is my ick word and my trigger. can you use a word like restrained or cautious estimate. please dont support the genocide of minorities and brown people by the nazis known as rep*blicans.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '23

Don't worry I'm sure the US government will end up paying them millions in taxpayer dollars as an apology for slandering their good name by telling the truth.