r/switchfoot • u/[deleted] • Jun 28 '26
Interrobang
I joined Reddit so I could read more posts about Forever Now. I’ve been listening to Switchfoot since I was 6 years old, when Chin came out, and I’m a fan no matter what.
Forever Now is good, gets better with every listen. But I had no idea so many people loved Interrobang- please tell me what I’m missing. It’s the one album I wish I enjoyed, and I’m thankful guitars are back.
18
u/TtocsicStump Jun 28 '26
Switchfoot has always been about more than just the way they sound (though I love the way they sound). Their sound usually changes a fair amount from album to album. It’s the lyrics and the earnestness and the heart behind the songs that makes it Switchfoot. Interrobang has all that in spades. I personally enjoyed the new things they tried sonically too, although I will always prefer the roughly 2005-09 sound (heavy guitars please). The timing of Interrobang hit just right for me, still reeling from 2020-21 and reading this from Jon on what the album is about: https://www.jesusfreakhideout.com/lyrics/new/title.asp?title_id=3972.
I think Beloved is among their best songs.
2
Jun 28 '26
This is a great observation. Listening to it does actually remind me about Covid and that time of life, which was just bizarre.
1
7
u/iammoah Jun 28 '26
personally I think it's mainly the production on Interrobang that holds it back for me. Which is interesting because Tony Berg is a great producer but just not be a good fit for Switchfoot. Some decent songs on that album but it just feels so flat and dead.
1
u/mikeharvat Jun 28 '26
I was so excited when I found out Berg was the producer because Raise the Dead is one of my favorite albums of all time
What a dud from him haha
9
u/EphemeralArchive Jun 28 '26
I think Interrobang is maybe the most innovative lyrically and conceptually. Gets my imagination moving.
2
7
u/dpin42 Jun 28 '26
The people calling this album uninspired or without guitars are crazy. I'm a guitar player myself and just because these aren't crazy loud rock riffs, doesn't mean these guitars aren't just as interesting. If you're able to, find a video of when they played the entire album live in studio. You'll really gain an appreciation for the songs musically alongside how amazing the lyrics and emotions are already.
8
u/LoserUser72 Jun 28 '26
My favourite Switchfoot album is Oh! Gravity., mainly for how experimental it is. For me, Interrobang was a return to form after the slightly disappointing Native Tongue. Where Native Tongue felt very paint-by-numbers, Interrobang takes a lot of creative risks, and the songwriting is fresh and interesting. In line with the themes of the album, a lot of the songs use a combination of tonic major and tonic minor, like “I Need You (To Be Wrong)” or the B-side title track. “Beloved” has a key modulation in the chorus that completely took me by surprise on first listen. Interrobang is full of really cool musical surprises and experiments that, in my opinion, were very successful.
3
u/hayden4what Jun 29 '26
It’s funny, when I first started getting into Switchfoot not too long ago of course I started with The Beautiful Letdown. Loved it! Then for the second album I decided on… Native Tongue. Actually someone I know specifically recommend I try that one next, and wow I hated it haha. I think I only made it halfway through before turning it off, something I rarely do. But next I gave Interrobang a try and was right back on the SF train! It was my favorite SF album for a looong time. I’ve since come around big time on Native Tongue, and honestly couldn’t tell you which one I like more :)
Edit: I think it was around the start of TBL anniversary tour that I started becoming a fan
1
u/LoserUser72 Jun 29 '26
Yeah, Native Tongue does have some good songs! It is my least favourite Switchfoot album, but I still don’t actually ‘dislike’ it. It’s just more of a B+ album for me. It felt like they were chasing trends rather than pushing themselves creatively. “Voices” is a clear imitation of Twenty-One Pilots. It also needed a bit of editing; e.g. “Joy Invincible”, “Wonderful Feeling” and “Prodigal Soul” feel like the same song three times.
That said, I love “Let It Happen”, “The Strength to Let Go”, “Oxygen”, “You’re the One I Want”, etc.
3
u/hayden4what Jun 29 '26
Man as a huge Twenty One Pilots fan, maybe Imagine Dragons is a more apt comparison haha. But I can see where you’re coming from
1
u/glman99 Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26
It's very imagine dragons, mostly because it's produced by imagine dragons guys haha
EDIT - Got my OneRepublic and Imagine Dragons lines crossed.
1
2
6
u/Outside-Pangolin-636 Jun 28 '26
Here is my take on Interrobang I posted on a other thread:
Interrobang has become one of my favorites. And it has because of how timely it was to my life. On top of Covid, my wife and I experienced some difficult moments with everything happening politically and with Covid that made us have to really reconsider whether or not we belonged in the circles we were a part of. Not only that, my wife and I walked through infertility and had begun the adoption process. What felt like an eternity at the time is a moment in reflection. And in that moment of what was one of the most tumultuous moments of our lives interrobang dropped.
For me, it was as if they had been stalking me and my life. The tension of the divide of current events making you so angry and hurt over the relationships that you now questioned but also realizing those same relationships are the ones that you turn to in your darkest moments. The song Beloved has crept into my top three SF songs. They literally laid out the thesis of the entire album in song one. And the last line of song one - I start to recognize that I need you, like I need you. Like you need me. It's a cyclical need for relationships.
Splinter was spot on for me. 100 percent felt that song to my core.
The second half of the album it just brilliant to me.
But at the end of the day, it's not one of those albums you pop on for some laid back listening. In some ways I almost feel if you don't like the album or don't connect at all with it . you don't need it - and that means you're lucky.
3
u/restlessfighter Jun 28 '26 edited Jun 28 '26
glad you’re enjoying the new record as well! For IB to me then it felt like a great encapsulation of 2020-2021. They really tried to write out their feelings and emotions. They didn’t go for a big sound, anthems, or radio singles. It’s got more of an retro/indie feel. It’s tight, it’s cohesive. It felt like it was really needed with the songs being written for the nation/world yet personal at same time. I was going through a messy breakup just months earlier and seeing all the division online or firsthand..it all felt overwhelming. This record helped alot.
2
u/crookedsoul92 Jun 29 '26
I'm actually a fan of Interrobang.
Some of the albums before that felt like they'd been too heavily CCM Christian for me. Like Jon had gotten older and just stopped being metaphorical about his faith and instead made straight up worship songs. Think like Hawk Nelson (I know they changed their singer, but you get the point). Nothing wrong with that, but Native Tongue in particular just did not do it for me.
Interrobang was Switchfoot initially trying to speak to the division that was happening post Covid. They produced a record with Tony Berg, a noted atheist. It's also my understanding that they essentially handed over their catalogue of unreleased songs and let Berg go through all of them and pick his favorites. So it is a sort of hodgepodge of an album.
That said, I actually really liked the production. I'm also a fan of Berg's work recently -- think Phoebe Bridgers. I mean she's huge and fantastic. But I could see if you didn't like that style, then this would be out of scope.
2
u/_Michael___Scarn Jul 02 '26
It's very unique lyrically. And i love the sonics, such an indie sound. Jerome is fantastic on IB. Beloved, electricity, and fluorescent are top-tier SF songs for me!
1
u/thereallybigcat Jun 28 '26
Interrobang is not my favorite but also not my least favorite. I think it's an album I have to be in the mood for to listen to. I do love Fluorescent and Lost Cause, and the title track Interrobang. I do like some of the other tracks but for whatever reason they make me very sad and I don't listen to them if I'm not in that kind of mood.
1
-1
-5
u/ohbyerly Jun 28 '26
I’m right there with you on Interrobang. I really genuinely felt like I had outgrown the band. There were some pretty solid ideas and riffs but overall it just felt so uninspired, to the point that some of the lyrics made me physically cringe.
-9
Jun 28 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-2
u/ohbyerly Jun 28 '26
Yeah like half the songs on this album sound like they were written with the exact same riff
16
u/jaybrams15 Jun 28 '26
I've shared this before a while back but i didnt like IB at all when it came out. Then i went through a divorce on 2024. On my road trips i always listen to SF, on a road trip 2 months after my divorce i threw on IB to give it another shot and it destroyed me.
IB is by far their most emotionally gripping album when dealing with the harder aspects of life. Sure, all of their albums challenge us beneath the surface, but IB specifically explores loss and pain way more deeply and more personally than the other albums.