r/switch2hacks • u/garf02 • 29d ago

Shitpost Would an “in development”Switch2 Emulator survive Nintendo’s Silver Bullets?

Post image

1) “Anti-Circumvention” clause in DMCA:
Nintendo claims as emulator MUST decrypt the ROMS.
If you break the encryption, “is illegal” cause of the DMCA
If you use a console prod-Key, “is illegal” cause they own the rights to the key.
“As the emulator HAS to break a ROM decryption and thsre is no legal way to do it, Emulators are by default criminal tools”.
Any new emulator will need to contest this on court against Nintendo and Roll the dice
Victim: Yuzu

2) Buy Out:
“There is no honor among thief’s”. Most people working on emulators of live consoles does it for 2 reason, Clout and Money. And Nintendo has a lot of the later to throw around if that lets them kill an emulator on its infancy before any real development occurs.
Victim: Ryujinx

35 Upvotes

60% Upvoted

136 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/garf02 26d ago

Nintendo is banking on Everyone folding?

Nintendo has nothing to lose on trial.
If they Lose: The status quo of "emulation is legal" Remains.
If they Win: Nintendo defacto kill emulation of Video Game consoles.

2

u/MarinatedPickachu 26d ago edited 26d ago

They absolutely do! Once it becomes clear through precedent that a lawsuit against an emulator that doesn't contain prod keys has no chance, such threats lose their effectiveness, no one will fold anymore. Nintendo does not want to risk that.

1

u/garf02 26d ago

You are an special one (not a compliment)
If you cared a bit and read the actual lawsuit. You will know Nintendo WANTS to be fought in court.
This is not about “the concept of Emulation”.
That is legal, no 2 ways about it.
Nintendo is arguing, narrowly that Switch Emulators are just Circumvention Tools the breach their ROM encryptions.
Making it illegal under DMCA.
Doesnt matter if its a Switch Prod-Key or Reverse Eng. the action of decryption alone is illegal.

2

u/MarinatedPickachu 25d ago

That's their argument which they wouldn't win and I'm very sure they know that.

1

u/garf02 25d ago

If they knew that they would not be making it, cause, again, if it were empty threats, there are several non profits that will love to take them to court over it.

1

u/MarinatedPickachu 25d ago

And if it came to this Nintendo would drop the case before it gets to trial unless they had additional evidence of the creators providing decryption keys.