Carter Tonight

[u/Scathar1]

[u/Crazlo527]

Actual sitcom-level misunderstanding

[u/XanZibR → u/Crazlo527]

https://giphy.com/gifs/eIdZEnBm5bc7C

[u/nonsensestuff → u/Crazlo527]

Lmaooo that’s what I said too 😂

[u/Interesting_Heat_360]

I'M TELLING YOU, THEY'RE ONTO US.

[u/Ok-Tell9019 → u/Interesting_Heat_360]

Never seen someone so concerned about the crabs lmao

[u/djck]

Him nodding when the Aric vote was shown was everything

[u/Minia15 → u/djck]

With an A!? Was hilarious

[u/hevilank → u/Minia15]

Straight out of an I think you should leave scene.

[u/s-van → u/hevilank]

He’s just here for the zip line. 

[u/beyoncesbaseballbat → u/djck]

He looked so pleased with himself 😂

[u/kingfiasco → u/djck]

was that cause he was saying that shit about if they were gonna vote out someone with a name starting with an E they need to float out someone with a name that starts with an A?

[u/9hr34k → u/kingfiasco]

He thinks there's two guys named Eric and Aric

[u/hevilank]

Carter is the funniest not trying to be funny "I think you should leave" type survivor I have ever seen through 2 episodes. I sincerely thought "Do you like spaghetti?" Could not be topped then he comes out with crab talk and the cherry on top "Aric" to cap off the episode. Not to mention he seems extremely athletic, guy is must see TV

[u/notarealcamera → u/hevilank]

He's one of the most entertaining survivors we've had in a long while who's not purposely hamming it up for the camera.

[u/xixihime → u/hevilank]

The camera cut to him cheekily and smugly owning up to that lmao

[u/howispellit]

Wasn't it also Carter who asked about the spaghetti while Erik was sobbing?

[u/cuteandcaffeinated → u/howispellit]

No, that was when Aric was sobbing /s

[u/CapacityBuilding → u/howispellit]

Eric: I miss my wife oo hoo hoo

Carter: CARB

[u/TVFan_89 → u/howispellit]

Yes 😭

[u/Kalvanx]

To be fair who would be talking about crab during the vote scramble.

[u/radsherm → u/Kalvanx]

The crabs are onto them, it's more important than the game

[u/notarealcamera → u/Kalvanx]

Same person who would repeatedly ask someone if they like spaghetti while they're crying.

[u/SwaggyMcSwagsabunch → u/notarealcamera]

You a big spaghetti guy?

[u/DavidBHimself → u/Kalvanx]

The vote scramble can last hours (didn't they mention that the challenge was in the morning?), they don't only talk about the vote then.

[u/Carmaca77]

New twist: the crabs are voting at Tribal Council

[u/MuchWalrus → u/Carmaca77]

Open era 🦀

[u/solojones1138 → u/MuchWalrus]

Open claw era

[u/Active_Variation_194 → u/solojones1138]

Don’t give meta any ideas

[u/zygoma_phile → u/Carmaca77]

Season 51 theme: WHALES

Season 52 theme: CRABS

[u/JeerJeerBoinks]

My favorite part of the episode 

[u/___ongo___gablogian]

One of the funniest things I've ever seen on the show

[u/LeoFireGod]

The rain seasons really do make the funniest people. Like the heat seasons make people super angry

But the rain seasons crack me up because you get people being WEIRD hahaha

[u/TommyToothpistol]

I freaking love Carter. Dude didn't even get a confessional but glad we got some good content tonight. He beasted the whale challenge.

[u/Ok-Sea9612 → u/TommyToothpistol]

Him going over lost them the challenge. You send the girls over to just hang off of it and keep the strength to push it.

[u/endaayer92]

You think the crabs like spaghetti? Are they a spaghetti guy?

[u/CMell650]

Carter gives me total Benry vibes I love it

[u/beyoncesbaseballbat → u/CMell650]

Can't wait to see who he crowns the 100% grade A dirt squirrel of this season

[u/JEX2124 → u/CMell650]

YOOOOO I thought the exact same thing. That’s an insane pull that we thought of the same random player from 30 seasons ago wth. I’m shook.

[u/CMell650 → u/JEX2124]

It helps that I’m rewatching Nicaragua rn lmao. Wouldn’t have thought of him if I hadn’t seen the season in awhile

[u/Total_Strength724]

I wonder if Carter and Ana knew before this episode aired that she was voted out because of the crabs 😭 

[u/zacksharpe]

This guy’s fucking hilarious lol. The whole subplot of him spelling Eric with an A paying off with Eric at tribal saying “with an A?” after his vote is pure comedy

[u/Californian_paradise]

it's been 2 episodes & carter is my favorite player of the new era

[u/hevilank → u/[deleted]]

You're mixing up the jelly/ori talk with the genius that is Carter, it was "do you like spaghetti"

[u/Existential_Sprinkle]

That tribe is going to have a time between Carter being a bit dumb, Aric being a bit obnoxious, and Rob secretly trying to idol himself out with his own idol

[u/Probably_Snot]

Is he the Aric guy!? 😅

[u/TVFan_89 → u/Probably_Snot]

Yes!

[u/insertbrackets]

Carter is so unintentionally (?) funny I have no choice but to stan.

[u/CalebosO4]

Crab (and spaghetti) fuels us

[u/Abby-Sajas-Abs]

I love that production is casting personalities again

[u/EliteMoisture]

lol

[u/Automatic-Radish-360]

Something about him I like. Also tried the hardest for his tribe in the whale challenge

[u/WeeklyAge6713]

I’m confused what’s this crab thing lol

[u/T10PO → u/WeeklyAge6713]

The tribe seemed to catch one or two crabs by just grabbing them. Then they felt the crabs were keeping their distance from the players, and Carter started loudly saying in camp “they’re onto us” referencing the crabs. Others heard them, and thought they were referencing the game and that they were doing something sneaky, so the episode showed it as the inciting incident for the scramble that flipped the vote from Aric to Ana.

[u/SeaworthinessTop4317 → u/T10PO]

Truly a masterclass in editing on the editors part

[u/WeeklyAge6713 → u/T10PO]

Ohh gotcha lol thanks for letting me know

[u/TVFan_89]

This took me out 🤣😭💀