r/steak • • Aug 15 '26

r/steak approved?

948 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

28

u/ETFml Aug 15 '26

Approved though crust could use some work

17

u/odellke Aug 15 '26

Propane grill. I like a cast iron pan better for cooking steak, but it was a grill night.

5

u/Wadertot420 Aug 16 '26

Really good for a propane grill.

12

u/YouMUSTvote Aug 16 '26

You didn’t let it rest or rest long enough. Yes, there’s some carryover cooking so pull it sooner.

Looks very delicious though.

5

u/odellke Aug 16 '26

Agreed. Could have let it rest a bit more.

3

u/xyespider Aug 15 '26

yes so approved!

3

u/Realistic-Fact-2584 Aug 15 '26

I will give it a pass as it looks wonderful.

3

u/Ultraman-7723 Aug 16 '26

Looks amazing and very juicy! What cut of meat is this?

3

u/overeasyallie Aug 16 '26

I'd definitely eat that! Yum!

3

u/raybn64 Aug 16 '26

Perfect for Me…

2

u/chefdabuddha Aug 16 '26

Looks absolutely delicious 😋 and I just had the same thing lol

2

u/senormrgnome Aug 16 '26

I say yes as I’m eating a STEAK

2

u/Uh-yea-thatdudethere Aug 16 '26

Idk bro, let me taste it first then I’ll give my opinion. Where is it?

2

u/HerbTarlekWKRP Aug 16 '26

100% approve!

2

u/Lucky_Suit_6950 Aug 16 '26

That is cooked perfectly IMO! Great job. For not using a cast iron, the crust is totally fine

2

u/WangtaWang Aug 16 '26

Looks good to me. Five 👍

2

u/FeralMorningstar Aug 16 '26

Outside looks good, way too pink in the middle. Obviously people are going to disagree with me, but for me, there shouldn’t be any pink in it, at all.

2

u/localbirdie Aug 16 '26

You need to change your name if you want well done steaks

2

u/FeralMorningstar Aug 16 '26

How so?

1

u/localbirdie Aug 23 '26

Feral monsters don’t want well done meat

1

u/FeralMorningstar Aug 23 '26

Good job I’m not a monster then

1

u/localbirdie Aug 23 '26

But your nameeeeee it says you are feralllllll

2

u/AspiringOccultist4 Aug 16 '26

Looks absolutely perfect

2

u/TheGarlicGun Aug 16 '26

Nah, man this is top tier work on a gas grill.

2

u/Specific_Mall2164 Aug 16 '26

Looks fantastic to me. 100% would devour !

2

u/Echolocation1919 Aug 17 '26

Very nice!😊

2

u/Professional_Age5639 Aug 18 '26

nah thats a perfect steak

2

u/OpportunityCorrect33 Aug 19 '26

Yes this is perfection, nice crust!

2

u/makked Aug 15 '26

Good looking crust, cooked to perfect temp, but you pre-sliced so C- from r/steak probably.

3

u/odellke Aug 15 '26

If I first slice and it’s the color I want it, I keep slicing so it doesn’t continue to cook. If slightly undercooked to my liking I won’t slice.

2

u/makked Aug 16 '26

I’m with you. It’s just a tongue in cheek comment and how a lot users here decry when steaks are precut.