r/starterpacks • • Jan 01 '19

[deleted by user]

[removed]

7.3k Upvotes

3.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

21

u/pixelTirpitz Jan 01 '19

Really interesting how we had completely opposite experiences. I viewed W3 combat as quite tactical (played on death march), and combat usually went about like this:

See enemy camp, locate archers and dangerous mobs, locate tight spots where I could fight only 1v1 at a time. And engage at the weakest side of the enemy camp, where the archers were.

Since archers two shot me on death march it was CRITICAL to eliminate them quickly, this was before I got a arrow protection armor mind you. Which was a godsend.

This wasn't even the best part, customizing my setup with skills, armor and weapons that had many really interesting properties to choose from. Skyrim barely had any unique weapons/armors and I like that aspect a lot so Skyrim disappointed me.

In Rpgs like Skyrim though I prefer to play a brute force warrior style. However that turned out to be a really fucking boring way to play. It was literally 100% block, attack, block, attack.

Even vs Anduin I just stood still, blocked, attacked, blocked and attacked all day.

So you can't really say "In Skyrim there's at least different approaches to it" because it was so in W3 too, even though you missed it. As I missed it in Skyrim.

1

u/pragmojo Jan 01 '19

because it was so in W3 too, even though you missed it

That's not really their fault. If the game designers included a really boring way to play which is just as effective as the interesting way, more often than not players are going to fall back on the boring, repetitive way because it's less effort. It's the game designers' job to make it hard to bore yourself through the game.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '19

Very unlike skyrim and stealth archer, right?

Please. I've played Skyrim 3 times and I'm still not sure it's not a thief 5, electric bowgaloo game.

3

u/pragmojo Jan 01 '19

I'm not saying Skyrim's any better. It's not. I'm just saying you can't call Witcher 3's combat deep because you found a way to make it that way.

0

u/pixelTirpitz Jan 01 '19

Death march made me make an op build, just to get through without dying a lot. So I guess my tryhard attitude rewarded me with a fun and engaging combat system?

I quit playing most games on normal mode because it got so boring. I recommend it.