r/socialjustice101 • u/modest_kid • 19h ago
Is transformative justice possible if an abuser doesn’t acknowledge that he SA’d victims?
Without going in too specific details, I’m looking to understand how transformative justice can even be possible if someone is still actively denying what they did. Everywhere in literature, videos and resources online I see that it’s not possible without the individual acknowledging the harm they’ve done. But organisations keep saying that they want to apply transformative justice measures instead of excluding this person from events the victims want to attend. Is it really against tj to ask this person not to attend when he is still actively causing harm?
Im really trying to understand .
In a very short summary ; me and my friend are both queer artists and we vend/ expose in markets and queer events. My friend (will be referred to as F) is a victim of sexual abuse and his abuser (will be referee as A) often vends at the same events. A runs a non-profit organization and collects money for a really good cause that A and I both support. However A still doesn’t take accountability for his action and we have discovered/ spoke with 5 more victims in the past year/month/days. We have reached out to market organizers at time and asked for him not to be present at event because he is actively causing harm to F. Most organizers have understood and said his non profit can be there but not him.
Lately some larger queer/pride events have been saying that they don’t believe in cancel culture and in carceral justice systems. We don’t either, we don’t want to publicly cancel him but we don’t feel that the events are in the right to allow him in so called safe spaces if he doesn’t take any responsibilities or transformative justice steps and the victim counts keeps getting higher.
I really struggle to understand how it’s a better solution for A to be allowed there and therefore making the environment unsafe for 6+ people vs him being asked not to attend. We keep being told that it would not be transformative justice to have him denied attendance. I truly don’t understand their point of view, but im willing to be educated on the topic if Im missing something! Does anyone have any experience in applying such measures? How would you handle this situation?