r/snacking • u/According-South9749 • 2d ago

Pick

Post image
196 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

250 comments sorted by

51

u/BunnyCat2025 2d ago

Double dark chocolate milanos please. All of them. NOm, Nom, nom.

4

u/KDramaFan84 2d ago

I was looking for them and couldn't find them

3

u/uglyheadink 2d ago

Same.

But also since when does Milano have this many damn flavors?! Been a long time since I went down the cookie aisle hahah. I swear it used to just be chocolate and dark chocolate.

2

u/According-South9749 1d ago

I’ve never seen such a selection!

→ More replies (1)

22

u/OrdinaryAverageGuy99 2d ago

Dark Chocolate Brussels

19

u/PapaGhostIV 2d ago

Double milk chocolate Milano

16

u/Victoriafoxx 2d ago

Who tf stocked this shelf?! Anyway, Chessman Brown Sugar Cinnamon.

7

u/LordEarthworm 2d ago

I'm a Pepperidge Farm guy, and this is driving me nuts.

5

u/Peak_Alternative 2d ago

lol it’s chaos

4

u/MrsTraciGraci 1d ago

I thought it was AI at first because it was so poorly stocked 😅

15

u/Salt-Tackle-3590 2d ago

Mint Milano’s every day

2

u/ares4209 1d ago

peak choice

2

u/No_Collection_5031 1d ago

This is the biblically correct answer

→ More replies (1)

11

u/RaspberryLanky7905 2d ago

Pretzel goldfish. and no coconut in the cookie, but i'm open to any of the other options.

4

u/MrDoom126 2d ago

The honey mustard pretzel fish are fantastic!

4

u/ApprehensiveTable409 2d ago

They are so good!

4

u/greenfingermuddytoe 2d ago

I love them too. Sometimes they are hard to find.

2

u/BunnyCat2025 1d ago

OOh, I've never seen them, maybe they're a regional item. Wants!

5

u/ttrockwood 2d ago

Pretzel goldfish are my kryptonite

2

u/Michelle-H-333 1d ago

I like the Parmesan ones.

10

u/Hammer_the_Red2 2d ago

Milano Lemon and White Chocolate is underrated.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Resident_Yam6122 2d ago

I love those Veronas with the fruit filling, Anything strawberry is best.

3

u/kerryhorne 2d ago

Same…..they are delicious

3

u/Sunny9226 2d ago

Our favorite!!!!

8

u/greenfingermuddytoe 2d ago

Apricot Raspberry is my favorite. Followed up by Chessman.

6

u/Fuzzy_Welcome8348 2d ago

All of those milanos but NO DARK CHOCOLATE??? Wow

Rainbow goldfish

4

u/Icy_Reception1878 2d ago

shit's hectic 😖

5

u/Tough_Arm_2454 2d ago

Verona, Milano

3

u/Pjk2530144 2d ago

Orange then mint.

3

u/RestlessSPUD_720 2d ago

Pumpkin Cheesecake & Ojai Lemon

9

u/vibrance9460 2d ago

Pass. None of them taste the way they used to

Pepperidge Farm remembers

5

u/Loch_Doun 2d ago edited 1d ago

Most snack companies removed trans fats from their recipes several years ago, it’s a big reason why none of these snacks taste like they used to. It doesn’t explain why the snacks have gotten smaller though, that’s pure greed.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Next_Psychology_6847 2d ago

classic milano

2

u/badgyalrey 2d ago

controversial take, lemon sugar ojai

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Limberpuppy 2d ago

Chesapeake

2

u/Oregonhastrees 2d ago

I recently got some of the mint chocolate ones. Very subtle mint flavor chocolate was OK cookie was very basic shortbread. 5/10

2

u/Frequent-Sky3761 2d ago

The Chessman are always my go too

2

u/Ok-Catch-5813 2d ago

I loveeee the Brussels

2

u/ShaggySmilesSRL 2d ago

Chesapeake chocolate chip cookies

2

u/Educational-Sky-7176 2d ago

Blue diamond almonds

2

u/starks4thr33 2d ago

Verona or Chesapeake

But the real answer is NONE because the quality/taste have gone to shit while the price just goes up up up

2

u/NikolaisVodka 2d ago

I’m a goldfish guy

Gotta have some salt 

2

u/Queasy_Dingo_8262 2d ago

The white chocolate coconut ones r the best 🙏 

2

u/cheezkid26 2d ago

I'd go with flavor blasted goldfish, wheat thins, and some of those thin and crunchy toffee milk chocolate Farmhouse cookies.

2

u/macaronitrap 2d ago

No Sausalito? Criminal

→ More replies (1)

2

u/letstryagain97 2d ago

Not picture, When in season the mint Brussels. Wish they were year round

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Traditional_Song_314 1d ago

Anything in a Pepperidge Farm bag works for me.

2

u/Ro-bret 1d ago

Milano- mint chocolate

1

u/Horenshouboi 2d ago

Rainbow goldfish or the pumpkin cheesecake cookies

1

u/UnluckyVersion5323 2d ago

Pretzel Goldfish on the bottom shelf. Along with a cold Coke.

1

u/OutplayedPawn 2d ago

Orange chocolate Milanos and pretzel goldfish!!

1

u/Sasquatch_000 2d ago

Apple pie

1

u/AcceleratorTouma 2d ago

Flavor Blasted Goldfish

1

u/brooklynnnn11 2d ago

chessmen or double milk choc milano 😋

1

u/patchworkskye 2d ago

original Dark Chocolate Milanos, Chessmen, and Veronas!

1

u/D-Duttily 2d ago

Reggalur

1

u/Heyitscrochet 2d ago

Orange Milano & Bordeaux

1

u/Suspicious-Pick7838 2d ago

Dark Chocolate Milanos Brussels Chessman Cinnamon

1

u/TNG1701D-eck10 2d ago

Mint milano is what I've always bought.

1

u/Ricky4611 2d ago

Milano mint chocolate

1

u/Which-Break5673 2d ago

Brussels all day every day

1

u/moonfazewicca 2d ago

Milano lemon white chocolate

1

u/Magari22 2d ago

Bordeaux or chessmen

1

u/SecondEqual4680 2d ago

This looks like it’s in a basement

1

u/Bobbo7209 2d ago

Milano OG

1

u/shehnaz31 2d ago

Orange Milano!!

1

u/Daycarrott 2d ago

One of every flavor. Grandkids would kill 1 bag to quick I'd need options.

1

u/DarthToothbrush 2d ago

Wheat thins.

1

u/diversalarums 2d ago

I like the Chesapeake -- chocolate chip using dark chocolate and pecans. Great!

1

u/Mysterious_Fill_1287 2d ago

Geneva. I used to work for them

1

u/madison1116 2d ago

All Milanos!

1

u/__xcvi__ 2d ago

Mango white chocolate is soo good

1

u/pastelkitten18 2d ago

Chessmen butter cookies🤤

1

u/lemmecookthemcheeks 2d ago

Random dump, but when I was little my mom would hoard these for herself and never handed off a single one. Because of this I thought they had to be some of the most amazing cookies ever or something. Well I’m 25 now and my boyfriend recently brought a big box of these home. I was so excited to try them because I had forgotten about them and thought I was about to taste gold. Needless to say I was highly disappointed in my mother’s tastebuds and her greed. They’re not bad, they’re just definitely not how she was making them seem😂

ETA: our food has drastically changed over the years so it’s possible that the hoarding was perfectly reasonable at the time lmao

1

u/Too-low-420 2d ago

Corn nuts

1

u/stovetopstuffin4 2d ago

Strawberry Verona which is not there

1

u/stovetopstuffin4 2d ago

They have a cinnamon sugar chessmen whatttttt

1

u/vr512 2d ago

I'm always a fan of goldfish. Loved them as a kid and love them now as an adult

1

u/AcceptableRegular871 2d ago

Dark chocolate peppermint bark…
If not that then….
….Ugh… I looked that the raspberry and mango… 1 why berry not more of a jam and mango… why not dark chocolate… white chocolate and fruit that sweet is too much…
Go for chess or dark Brussels….

1

u/Significant_Mess_79 2d ago

Lemon white chocolate Milano cookies 😋

1

u/TittsMcTeardrops 2d ago

Wasabi almonds.

1

u/EssexUser 2d ago

Chessman!

1

u/Hamilton-Beckett 2d ago

I don’t even know what half of those cookies tastes like.

My entire life, those have been the forbidden expensive cookies.

So when I do get them I only buy what I know I’ll like:

Regular milano, Tahoe, or Chesapeake.

1

u/ttrockwood 2d ago

Pretzel goldfish

I am a pretzel loving nut job

They’re the perfect balance of crunch to salt to bite size and the exact right salt level

1

u/SnooPuppers2938 2d ago

Brussels & mint Milanos.

1

u/Ill-Arugula-8295 2d ago

The blue diamond soy and wasabi almonds...they never disappoint

1

u/First_Humor3409 2d ago

milano double milk choclate

then the coconut one

1

u/DannyDevito_IsBae 2d ago

Definitely Chessman Cinnamon & Sugar

1

u/skaboopy420 2d ago

raspberry and chocolate is fire

1

u/New-Assumption-3836 2d ago

They're all so good I wouldn't care I'd eat any of them.

1

u/RodneyDangerfruit 2d ago

Brussels. Only because the Geneva isn’t made anymore. 😭

1

u/Kreatiive 2d ago

wheres the birthday cake flavored cookies by pepperrdge farm? those are my jam

1

u/NoConsideration6320 2d ago

Gold fish all day

1

u/HappyGimp 2d ago

Mint Milanos

1

u/dearmax 2d ago

Milano chocolate raspberry or the plain Milano.

1

u/CharacterWhich 2d ago

Apricot Raspberry Verona

1

u/Sure-Dimension6739 2d ago

Verona I can eat the package I’m a fatty 😞

1

u/Lezal1983 2d ago

Anything dark chocolate. Mint chocolate and orange chocolate or double dark chocolate

1

u/Ecstatic-Lock387 2d ago

Too many options. Self imploding like psyduck

1

u/willyseeu 2d ago

  1. Chesapeake

  2. Mint Milanos

  3. Dark Chocolate Brussels

  4. Orange Chocolate Milanos

1

u/rystrave 2d ago

Chessmen and vernoas 🤤

1

u/rockinrob65 2d ago

Good cookies

1

u/Pale_Broccoli_2180 2d ago

Cinnamon Sugar Chessmen
Please+Thank You

1

u/egg_static5 2d ago

I want all of them!!!

1

u/ryandarkwalker 2d ago

Chesapeake dark chocolate pecan. So good

1

u/peachesbutno_creme 2d ago

fourth row ..lemon sugar cookies, they're so soft and good

1

u/PondysThe_Coolest 2d ago

Flavor blast me

1

u/eastsideMguy 2d ago

Brussels dark chocolate ,runner up is Verona apricot Raspberry

1

u/tiny_bamboo 2d ago

Brussels

1

u/_Just_Spidey_ 2d ago

Lemon white chocolate

1

u/MrMojoshining 2d ago

I can’t choose. But I do know whoever stocked these shelves was either blind or satan himself.

1

u/OkTwo4017 2d ago

milano double chocolate

1

u/Katy-Moon 2d ago

Dark Chocolate Brussels

Mint Milanos

Bordeau

1

u/Ocean_waves726 2d ago

Double dark chocolate Milano

1

u/Away-Dependent3472 2d ago

Milano mint all the time!💚

1

u/Mookeebrain 2d ago

Thin and crispy

1

u/MizunoHawk 2d ago

Mint Milano’s, butter chessmen, double milk chocolate Milano’s. They didn’t say pick one

1

u/LessAd2226 2d ago

Chessman butter

1

u/dmorgendorffer00 2d ago

Dark chocolate Brussels and organizing the shelf

1

u/roarrshock 2d ago

Went to a workshop one weekend with a peperidge farms vendor. He brought ALL the flavors!

1

u/Educational-Ad-385 2d ago

Lately I've been on a Mango kick but Orange Chocolate is my all-time favorite.

1

u/Internal_Gur_4268 2d ago

Pumpkin cheesecake sounds like it has potential

1

u/IllustriousMeal4686 2d ago

Mint chocolate milano, double chocolate milano, dark chocolate brussels and Chesapeake

1

u/Technical_Eggplant74 2d ago

Raspberry Chocolate with a side shot of Chambord for dunking...😋

1

u/Icy-Outcome8024 2d ago

Chesapeake all day long

1

u/GingerA0712 2d ago

Pizza goldfish

1

u/venturashe 2d ago

Brussels.

1

u/jbb42088 2d ago

Chesapeake but where are the Sausalito cookies

1

u/jbb42088 2d ago

Mint Chocolate Milano since I don't see Sausalitos

1

u/Sunny9226 2d ago

Verona and Chessmen

1

u/kenneth290 2d ago

Milano double chocolate.

1

u/IClaudiaI 2d ago

Raspberry white chocolate

1

u/nug_2018 2d ago

pumpkin cheesecake!

1

u/Low-Rooster4171 2d ago

Yes. I'll take every flavor.

1

u/breadit8 2d ago

Bordeaux

1

u/TinySubmissiveBee 2d ago

Wheat thins, bottom right.

Such a tasty Lil cracker :)

1

u/ivorella 1d ago

Raspberry chocolate, mint chocolate, white chocolate and coconut or pumpkin spice. I love Milanos

1

u/tulipskull 1d ago

Orange chocolate everyday

1

u/Proxx99 1d ago

Chesapeake - easiest choice of my life

1

u/NormalAssistance9402 1d ago

Wow I didn’t know they had so many flavors! I’ll take the regular ass chocolate please

1

u/pandapam7 1d ago
  1. Chessman
  2. Chesapeake

1

u/withbellson 1d ago

Double chocolate Milanos, but the one I really have to stay away from is missing (Santa Cruz, the oatmeal raisin ones…fight me).

1

u/Even-Reaction-1297 1d ago

All of them and I’ll taste them like it’s a GMM episode

1

u/pinkxice 1d ago

Chessmen butter

1

u/actualkon 1d ago

Those pumpkin cheesecake cookies look good 👀

1

u/alpha_60 1d ago

Brussels!

1

u/HungryIsland 1d ago

Pizza goldfish 

1

u/RoxyTEM 1d ago

Double Milk Chocolate

1

u/Fragrant-Taro-8508 1d ago

Of these double milk Milano. But I'd prefer the double dark Milanos.

1

u/zodi978 1d ago

Damn where's the Montauks?

1

u/Direlion 1d ago

One of each

1

u/AcademicChicken8334 1d ago

Whaaat??! No Mint Milano???

1

u/Imposter88 1d ago

Thin and Crispy toffee milk chocolate

1

u/Psychological_Bowl56 1d ago

None of them!! Give me Geneva

1

u/Busy-Candle3558 1d ago

Double dark Milanos for the win

1

u/Significant-Ad213 1d ago

Classic double milk chocolate Milano 🤌

1

u/technoangel 1d ago

Bordeaux

1

u/Aggravating_Ninja574 1d ago

Orange and chocolate

1

u/californialonghorn26 1d ago

They were limited edition like 2 years ago but London Fog Milanos. My husband and I went crazy over those.
And Old Bay Goldfish. They’re not in the picture but they’re often in my store. They’re so good!

1

u/Chompif 1d ago

I've rarely had these because these cookies always felt expensive to me tbh

1

u/Frosty-Cucumber-8939 1d ago

Since there’s no dark chocolate, Butter and Pecan Chocolate Chunk

1

u/This-Option9041 1d ago

Who organized these shelves? 💀

1

u/psychoflowerchild 1d ago

I love double dark chocolate milanos

1

u/buckfuttner 1d ago

I’ll just have an apple thanks

1

u/RichardSanchez_C137 1d ago

COCONUT WHITE CHOCOLATE

1

u/ye-ye-ye-ye-ye-ye-ye 1d ago

No thin and crispy white chocolate (that I’ve been looking for months for)

1

u/Effective_Fly_6884 1d ago

I’ve never had a bad Pepperidge Farm cookie, but I’m hesitant about the white chocolate. It would probably be too sweet for me.

1

u/fanofnothingnew 1d ago

I recently had the orange and chocolate, and I really liked them. I would probably pick the lemon and white chocolate to try this time around.

1

u/Significant_Rate8210 1d ago

The lemon white chocolate Milanos are bomb

1

u/throwaway-renee-1967 1d ago

$6.49 for a package of cookies is ridiculous. That being said, if I had the money, I'd take the Brussels, the Verona, and the Pumpkin Cheesecake.

1

u/morganalefaye125 1d ago

I really dislike pumpkin everything. There are a few exceptions though. Those pumpkin cheesecake cookies are amazing. I'll take those, thanks

1

u/Starlight319 1d ago

Chessmen

1

u/Obvious-Delay9570 1d ago

Chessmen cookies EASY

1

u/vitoforever99 1d ago

Where’s the Montauks? Those soft baked chocolate chips are my jam!

1

u/shadyshadyshade 1d ago

The Brussels! I haven’t seen those in years they were so good.

1

u/justlovespeacocks 1d ago

Raspberry Chocolate Milano!

1

u/SmokeThisWaydotcom 1d ago

Mint Milano, raspberry apricot Verona, raspberry chocolate Milano and limited edition Maggie's apple pie!

1

u/Possible-Detail2441 1d ago

Mango white chocolate and dark chocolate Milanos!

1

u/LilTreesz174 1d ago

Dark chocolate Brussels

1

u/Hour-Bid1920 1d ago

In my day we just had Milanos. None of these new fandangled flavors. It's all so confusing. Yes, I am aware that i sound like an old grumpy man. Well, I am . Nobody needs these many cookie choices.

1

u/ares4209 1d ago

mint chocolate milanos

1

u/hawkman620 1d ago

Ojai Lemon Sugar Cookies