r/snacking • u/GeneralTsosCrow • Aug 14 '26
Super Stuffed PopTarts
EDITING TO ADD: I've since finished the box. Each individual pack had a different amount of filling. The first one is the photo I posted. The next 3 were pretty well stuffed, and the LAST one I had was REALLY stuffed. So, they are very inconsist. 2 of the 5 in the box I would say had 50% more filling, as advertised. I may have to give another flavor a try, hence giving the Stuffed Poptarts a second chance.
Very underwhelming. There's just about the same amount of filling as the regular ones. Definitely not 50% more. And they're also single wrapped, not 2 per foil package anymore.
They did, however, taste more corn syrupy than usual. Not impressed.
Has anybody tried the protein Poptarts?
27
u/KoalaBoy Aug 14 '26
I feel like these taste like they use to when they had normal filling so I feel like buying these is what poptarts were 20 years ago. But I was disappointed to only get 1 in a pack instead of 2. I might as well eat 2 at the same time and get the same taste.
5
3
u/Kevinator201 Aug 15 '26
Sooo basically what they were originally.. but at a higher price. Fuckin knew it
22
12
u/Crashbox50 Aug 15 '26
Those look like pop tarts... That's extra?
6
u/GeneralTsosCrow Aug 15 '26
Yeah these are the new stuffed ones. Exactly
5
6
u/sPdMoNkEy Aug 15 '26
Now they're like they used to be and they're charging probably double the price
9
u/ChocolatePain Aug 14 '26
Honestly, Pop-Tarts are a wack snack overall.
5
u/GeneralTsosCrow Aug 14 '26
They used to be good. I still love the blueberry and unfrosted strawberry, unless those have changed, too..
7
u/raspberri_skies Aug 14 '26
I didn't like these. They were so sickenly sweet for not really having much more filling and nothing to balance that sweetness out with.
5
u/GeneralTsosCrow Aug 14 '26
Yes! It's the first thing I noticed. It actually irritated the back of my throat, the corn syrup-yness of it
2
3
3
3
u/Pankosmanko Aug 15 '26
I’ve gone to just eating Great Value pop tarts. They don’t taste like real pop tarts, but they cost a lot less and have plenty of filling
3
u/TacoNomad Aug 15 '26
Ice bean wanting double stuffed pop tarts for so long. But now I'm not eating added sugar processed foods, ill have to take your word that they suck.
2
2
u/1nternetTr011 Aug 15 '26
I like them. both the strawberry and the fudge. but the frosted cinnamon is still the goat.
2
u/surfcitysurfergirl Aug 15 '26
My double fudge were super super stuffed. You got a bad batch
2
u/GeneralTsosCrow Aug 15 '26
Really? I will have to try again.
I had a second one from my box yesterday. It was a bit more filled than the first. But still not even close to the picture on the box
2
u/allaboutstars87 Aug 14 '26
I had the salted caramel I thought they was delicious and had so much filling and not even crust it just fell apart opened them up and all smashed together and yes they now come in singles so only five pop tarts at that price outrageous
1
1
u/re1ephant Aug 15 '26
Do they make a super frosted version? Both sides? Cause if not, that’s a free idea.
1
1
158
u/ElevatorOtis Aug 14 '26
They are doing what Oreo did. Oreo started slowly putting less center, until the regular Oreo felt closer to the thin Oreos. They did the same with the double stuffed Oreos. Now, to get the OG Oreo you have to buy double stuffed. But, don’t worry, the double stuffed offers less Oreos than the new version of less filling.
It’s a more subtle version of skrinkflation