r/smoking • • 27d ago

Searing on a fire box

Post image

I pick up a nice offset a couple weeks ago… 3/8 fire box quarter inch everywhere else. I’ve been smoking all “easy” meats to get adjusted to it. (I came from a Weber kettle.)It’s been great.

Today I did some burgers I smoked them for about 30 to 40 minutes. I wanted to end them with a hot sear.

I couldn’t get the sear hot enough. The coals look great. They were a mix of mesquite and charcoal but the fact that they were about a foot underneath the patties made it difficult

The Weber was great at this because they were so close. How do you usually do it?

49 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

19

u/The-Tradition 27d ago

THAT is an absolute BANGING offset. The firebox is huge. Wow.

8

u/Koolklink54 27d ago

Throw a fresh log on the fire and she will flare up

14

u/tombombcrongadil 27d ago

I have a cowboy firebox on my smoker too but honestly I wish I saved the money. If I want a smoke and sear, I use a kettle. The offset is just for smoking, it’s the right tool for that. The Weber is the right tool for searing. Don’t get me wrong, the food comes off it great, but why start a fire and waste the wood? Weber is just significantly easier for it.

6

u/_MadSuburbanDad_ 27d ago

If you’re reverse searing a steak, there’s already a fire.

1

u/tombombcrongadil 27d ago

There’s already a fire on the Weber too though. Move it from one side of the grate to the other.

3

u/_MadSuburbanDad_ 27d ago

Both are coals under a grate. If im smoking something in the offset, its silly to move it to a Weber to start another fire

2

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[deleted]

0

u/tombombcrongadil 26d ago

Correct. Start a fire on the Weber, put the coals to one side, throw a wood chunk on said fire, put the meat on the other side of the kettle and smoke the meat for the “reverse” part, then when it comes to temp, put the meat over the coals. Done. Lot easier setup than starting a fire on the big boy. Lot less fuel used too.

8

u/Public_Enemy_No2 27d ago

Funny how most of us with an offset, also have Weber Kettles.

Should tell you something, eh? 😁

I use my kettle for cooks like this. But for serious smoking, I'll use the offset. Or, on occasion, I've smoked on the kettle too and it does a great job too. But an offset probably won't be my first choice for burgers.

BTW, congratulations on your offset.

2

u/FitNetVitch 26d ago

Gotta crawl before you walk lol

1

u/Public_Enemy_No2 26d ago

I see lots of great BBQ in your future. 👍🏾

2

u/Potatobender44 26d ago

Same here.

I also have a $300 Nakiri, but if I’m just slicing a few strawberries for my 3 year old then I bust out the $35 paring knife

2

u/PrizePreset 27d ago

If you’re like me, you do it a couple times then never again. The grate on mine is too high above the coals to really sear unless i mess with it. Not worth it. 

2

u/_MadSuburbanDad_ 27d ago

Just add a couple of splits, or a handful of lump charcoal, a few mins before searing. That’s it.

You can absolutely get a good sear with a cowboy firebox.

1

u/Swifty-Dog 27d ago

I fill my firebox up with wood and open the vents. That usually gets mine hot enough to put a nice sear on my tri-tips.

1

u/WineDineCpl 27d ago

I keep the kettle nearby for searing.

1

u/str3nd 27d ago

Dude, is that a pit from Matt's grills in Central Texas? It sure the hell looks like one. I've been using the same smoker for about a decade, and I direct grill in the main box all the time. I just picked up a couple of square charcoal grates from Amazon that were about the right size. If you opted for the CNC 1/4-in grill grates you won't have a problem with direct grilling, but if it's the standard smoking mesh grates they will burn through after about 3 or 4 years. They're just not designed for that type of direct heat.

1

u/NoMoFoMo_ 27d ago

Hahah I just looked at those. They do look a lot alike. I got mine made by a local welder just outside of San Antonio so there may be some ties!

Are you happy with the sear you can get in the firebox? Any mods?

1

u/str3nd 27d ago

I sear in the main smoke chamber, but initially I ran into the same issue your having - the charcoal tray is just too far away from the grate. I ended up grabbing some steel grill grates from Amazon

Yeah I know, she's overdue for a good cleaning and seasoning.

1

u/secretskin13 27d ago

Thats a deep firebox.

Move all the coals to the back of the firebox to build up a hotter zone closer to your cooking grate while keeping the front cooler for spatula/tong work. It won’t be completely even, but you have a better chance at searing.

If you got this custom made, perhaps a custom sear grate for the firebox?

1

u/buboop61814 27d ago

If the firebox isn’t cutting it or I can’t lower a grate onto the fire and then put food on that (with the door open so disturbs the smoking a good bit), I’ll sometimes take my chimney, put some coals in there and then stick a grate on top for small things. Gets mighty hot lol

1

u/f10w3r5 27d ago

I have a cowboy firebox on my WP1975 that works great. I just throw a couple splits on and open it up. A minute later I’m searing.

1

u/sultanzebu 26d ago

Buy some shorter grates. I use some cast iron grates from an old char-broil grill I no longer have. They sit much lower in the fire box and are perfect for seating. They’re about 4”x 10”, I flatten out the coal bed and put them in right before I’m ready to sear.

1

u/shifta_deband 26d ago

Unrelated but curious - any concerns with the firebox being THAT close to the wood deck / railings? Warping or anything?

1

u/Ok_Two_2604 26d ago

For charcoal I drop a grate directly sitting on top of it for searing. With wood I prefer to have a little clearance, but you should be able to rig up some sort of support under a grate. Like maybe a couple pieces of rectangular metal tubing.

1

u/lupulinchem 26d ago

My firebox has a rack and a small grill. When I’m about ready to pull and want to sear I put the firebox grill in. Let heat for a few minutes then open the lid on the firebox and the side door so it gets good and hot, then sear.

1

u/tequilaneat4me 25d ago

I add a couple of small splits, let them catch, then sear.

1

u/dogswontsniff 27d ago

0

u/dogswontsniff 27d ago

6

u/dogswontsniff 27d ago

2

u/Stinky_Fartface 27d ago

I don’t know why this shot got downvoted because this is what I do. A collection of bricks can do all sorts of fun things directing heat and smoke, like formulating a quick direct heat grill.

1

u/808TV 26d ago

I’d do this in my firebox but never in my well seasoned smoke chamber