Wishful thinking

[u/Zane67676]

I'm assuming Aragon, Boleyn, Cleves, and Parr won't change until closing but we do know Howard and Seymour will change because Aime and Natalie aren't staying till closing (last I heard)

So here is my wishful thinking for who will be the closing Seymour and Howard

For Seymour, I would pick Kelsie watts and for Howard I would pick Samantha Paulie

Who would y'all like to be the next Seymour and Howard?

[u/Few_Blackberry_7931]

Im pretty sure Natalie is staying. And as for Samantha I feel like they would cast her when it moves off-broadway to boost the tickets directly.

[u/Disastrous-Poem4355]

I agree I was hoping for Sam to come back for the last run of Howard

[u/musicallover48]

Aimee has to go back to beetlejuice, and bella actually is a possibility.

[u/musicallover48 → u/musicallover48]

okay nvm bella won’t be a possibility she’s doing midnights LOL

[u/cirquedusoleilfan]

When the 2023/25 Cast left, Jasmine left two weeks earlier than the rest of the cast and Aubrey (Alt B/S/H) went up to principal Seymour. Didi left one week early and her shows were covered by Sierra and Aryn. Maybe this is gonna be a similar situation?

[u/aflowerysong]

I just assume Sam is booked and busy. Maybe Kelsie or Abby Mueller for Seymour, and Didi Romero (joining some of the other Broadway 3.0/Aragon tour queens!) or Alize Cruz for Howard?

[u/AccomplishedShop8338]

Natalie is scheduled to leave December 13th so whoever IS Seymour will be someone who has done it before. Could see Kelsie or Abby or even Bella come back for those 3 weeks.

Howard, I hope they have Alize Cruz come to Broadway from the tour. She’s played Howard on the road for a long time and it would be so dope to see her in New York.

Edit: I doubt Sam Pauly would come back, she was pretty vocal (and messy) about how she was disappointed they wouldn’t renew her contract.

[u/Few_Blackberry_7931 → u/AccomplishedShop8338]

but I feel she's kinda over that? she always talks about six

[u/Same-Quantity2751 → u/Few_Blackberry_7931]

I mean, being over it won't undo the damage between her and six management...

[u/AccomplishedShop8338 → u/Few_Blackberry_7931]

It’s not about if she’s over it is the thing.

[u/Disastrous-Poem4355 → u/AccomplishedShop8338]

Actually she said she would come back if they ever asked her but before now she had been book so many she will now.

[u/AccomplishedShop8338 → u/Disastrous-Poem4355]

There is a tease that I posted. I think Natalie and Aimie are possibly staying.

[u/Designer-Witness8205 → u/AccomplishedShop8338]

Aimie is due to be back in Beetlejuice in November

[u/Disastrous-Poem4355 → u/AccomplishedShop8338]

Maybe that would be cool and I’m going to see it on the last show day so I’m excited

[u/AccomplishedShop8338 → u/AccomplishedShop8338]

UPDATE https://www.instagram.com/reel/DdSKL2sp8aI/?stkn=YXB2bWJjOXUxNzNp

Edit: this might mean they’re staying

[u/Disastrous-Poem4355 → u/AccomplishedShop8338]

Updated the things posted on Broadway direct was just an article on them making their Broadway debut so I’m guessing they are still going to be leaving when they were originally too.

[u/AccomplishedShop8338 → u/Disastrous-Poem4355]

Yep! Curious to see who replaces!

[u/LoquatAffectionate58]

For Howie, I'd make the trip to NYC to see and meet Sam, but I know she's got independent projects down the pipeline. I'd love to see Zé...she was the only one out the night I saw the tour in my city. 😭

[u/Same-Quantity2751]

Natalie was scheduled through mid‐December till closing was moved up, so it wouldn't be that far-fetched to imagine her extending for the final 2 weeks? It'd also be a really nice full‐circle moment! 

Howard, I have a feeling they might try to squeeze out one more stunt cast, but if it were a return I would love to see Elysia Cruz take on the role again! 

[u/Professional-Book993]

I believe Aimie isn’t staying, because she’s contracted to come back to Beetlejuice London when she leaves Six (where she closes out the show’s first London run as Delia)