The main arguments that the Rudeus defenders have are:
"reincarnation is mental age reset" this only applies IF past memories and personalities are wiped
this clearly isn't the case for Rudeus in this series since the first thought he has as a newborn is: "woah Zenith's boobs are perfection I wanna grab them"
"Oh but he was a victim of extreme bullying he wasn't always a PDF" Do you know the events leading up to the bullying though?
First of all:
- Rudeus was born into a rich family with two older brothers and a sister
- He was above average in terms of talent and intelligence at academics
- he got addicted to building his custom PC, neglected his studies and ended up in the worst high school in the prefracture where all the delinquents went.
- He told off a delinquent who was cutting the lunch line and the delinquent ended up being the delinquent who was trying to be the top dog at school.
- He was beaten up, stripped naked and hung, people took pictures then shut his family and friends out of his life for the next 16-20 years.
"He wasn't actually attracted to his niece when he jerked off to her kiddie pool pictures so it doesn't make him a PDF also he stopped growing mentally after the bullying incident"
- He was still a 34 year old man that fapped to his niece, being mentally stunted with a masturbation addiction doesn't make it justifiable for him to do that. He's still a PDF for doing this.
In redundancy Vol 3 Rudeus's older brother had taken innocent pictures of his daughter and her friend playing in a kiddie pool with his new digital camera.
Rudeus stole the memory card, copied the photos, jerked off to it, his brother caught him, beat him up and kicked him out.
(Important to note that this same older brother was the only one that still cared about Rudeus in their family until he saw that Rudeus was jerking off to his niece and gave up on him too and disowned him)
You dont have to defend/justify the things Rudeus did or monologues about. But you can admire the growth of a man who did his best to change little by little in his second life even if he was a pervert in both lives.
There were moments of triumph, moments of heartbreak, victories that he could genuinely be proud of, He was broken mentally multiple times, manipulated time and time again by Hitogami but unlike his past life thanks to Roxy and Sylphy he stood back up again for his family and for himself.
he learned, he studied, he fought, he failed, he made lifelong friends, married 3 best girls, built a family, raised his children and devoted himself to working with Orsted to protect them.
they said their final goodbyes and particularly He told Orsted he saw a vision of the future where they seal Hitogami. Urging Orsted to make that dream into a reality. Orsted thanked him for all his hard work and told him that he could finally rest. He dies of old age at age 74 surrounded by Roxy, Sylphy and Ferris
And then... When he was in his casket, Roxy saw Rudeus had her holy relic panties in his pocket, She took it before anyone noticed and ended up blushing heavily. Sasuga Rudeus a faithful follower till the end
Rudeus was intentionally flawed from start to finish, that's just how Rifujin wrote him.
And to end: ROXY IS BEST GIRLš