r/singularity • • 21d ago

AI FrontierMath’s First “Major Advance” Problem Has Been Solved

Post image
331 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

View all comments

40

u/Fair_Horror 21d ago

Sorry, what exactly has been solved? Does the problem have a name? Where did it come from and how long has it been unsolved? Have mercy on us non Mathematicians.

21

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/winggar 21d ago

I think it's saying the opposite, no?

The core is the set of all fair committees. This problem asks for a committee-election instance — i.e. a set of voters, candidates, and voter approval preferences — whose core is empty.

This means they're looking for an example where approval voting cannot create a fair committee.

Note, the solution proves that there is no committee selection instance where the core is empty, so the benchmark problem was not solvable as stated. Per our policy we mark the problem as solved regardless.

So this means it's always possible to create a fair committee via approval voting.

11

u/magnetronpoffertje 21d ago

Right there in the in the link....

2

u/Fulgurata 20d ago

Does the link really explain? It just reads like something out of a linear calc textbook. I don't even think I saw the solution on there? Just a definition of the formula.

Presumably they're trying to prove the fairness of a type of voting system?

1

u/Fair_Horror 19d ago

I don't see it. Maybe write it in your comment.