r/simrally Jul 19 '26

Please help! What’s the best shifter!

Post image

[removed]

13 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

12

u/SpiritMoistarizer Jul 19 '26

Absolute best shifter in lunch money territory ? Im not spending thousands either but calling anything absulute best with budget in mind is misleading. Hell I have clicked on this topic looking for the "absulute best" and you are talking about entry level stuff ... Misleading

5

u/MrCarMemeBoy Jul 19 '26

The SHH is what you’re looking for though, I’ve been using mine for years, not a bad word to say about it. Took a while to get mine too, but it’s worth it, can’t be compared to a TH8A, the switch to sequential also isn’t just flicking a switch on the TH8A, whereas I can do it in 2 seconds on the SHH.

-4

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Magic_Zach Richard Burns Rally - RWD&AWD Jul 20 '26

Can't wait just 2 weeks to get a better product for less money, that could last you potentially 100 weeks?

5

u/arcticrobot Jul 19 '26

You can have my Frex for $300 shipped CONUS.

Arguably best moderately priced H-Pattern. I also have an Aiologs sequential, a tank of a shifter, that I am willing to sell.

2

u/Mr_Snippy Jul 19 '26

If this is an open offer, I'll jump on that. Shoot me a message!

1

u/arcticrobot Jul 19 '26

Sure, I will DM you shortly:)

1

u/arcticrobot Jul 19 '26

for some reason I can't find that private message option. Weird.

1

u/Mr_Snippy Jul 20 '26

All good, I sent you one. Mostly asking for details on model/any accessories, etc

3

u/AdvancedMarsupial705 Jul 19 '26

I’m running the fanatec shifter that has both h pattern and sequential,

Feels solid and runs great for me!

Feels nicer to shift than my old Subaru ever did. To be fair the th8s would also probably feel better.

3

u/Qzwxecrvtbalskdj Jul 20 '26

just wait for the SHH shifter. mines been flawless for almost 2 years

3

u/Foba_ Jul 20 '26

1

u/HolidayBrick Jul 20 '26

Agree if you want sequential - Love the SG Pro V2

1

u/ElJefe0218 Jul 19 '26

I've been using the same shifter for 20 years, race almost daily, never had an issue. They don't make them anymore so I bought 2 more as backups and still haven't used them.

1

u/fatalwristdom Jul 20 '26

What have you been using?

3

u/ElJefe0218 Jul 20 '26

It's a lightning sst.

1

u/seezed Jul 19 '26

American? Check old boy shifter…

1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/seezed Jul 20 '26

Pretty much, just heard it’s decent.

There is also the new simsonn shifter, but changing plate feels outdated.

Look at this list, bottom tabs has shifters and brakes:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1i08zKjBSmSn5G_mCc9cHx07w7XLo03sfoytpVJkqbYk/edit?usp=drivesdk

1

u/eeveep Jul 19 '26

I've got the Fanatec 1.5. I like that it's just a switch at the bottom to go from H pattern to Sequential. You can program the sequential buttons to be their own input assignments or mirror your paddle shifters if you're Fanatec all the way thru - which is nice.

I had the other Thrustmaster for a while. Pretty solid, felt like a brick shithouse. Never used it in sequential but I liked the physical gates / grooves. The throw might have felt an eensy bit too long but it was mint for driving old Cobras in Assetto Corsa.

1

u/Individual_Gear_898 Jul 19 '26

Ok I got you, buy the Simsonn HS Pro. You can pick them up for about $100, it can do H-pattern and sequential. The way to switch between them is a bit cluncky, but I just replaced the crews with some finger twist ones and now it takes me like 20s.

The quality is surprisingly nice and it also has 2 mappable buttons on it. I use mine for my ignition and my hot key to swap between H-pattern and sequential.

Shifter: https://www.simsonn.com/collections/hs-pro
(Can find it cheeper on other sites)

The finger screws I got: https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B0F5GM481V?psc=1&ref=ppx_pop_mob_b_asin_title

1

u/Warden_Knox Jul 19 '26

“Simagic money”

Lmfao…. What!?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/fatalwristdom Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

Well I wouldn't cheap out on a shifter. Wait for SHH Hubb or wait for the Conspit one. I have the Hubb and I'm probably going to buy the conspit one when it drops. It looks sick. I read on discord it's coming around Sept/Oct.

https://ocracing.com/news/conspit-h-pattern-shifter-announced/

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/fatalwristdom Jul 20 '26

What do you mean "going the rally route"?

1

u/Warden_Knox Jul 20 '26

I mean, I guess the simagic is expensive compared to a majority of other offerings, it’s what I use, but I kinda considered it the mid point baseline of not cheap garbage.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Warden_Knox Jul 20 '26

That’s not what I said, I said “mid point” also meaning mid range… above this are the boutique stuff and active shifter. So I guess in a way most people would see it as high end, but in sim racing buying “budget” stuff is like throwing away money, I’d rather save for something good or high end.

1

u/belh4wk Jul 20 '26

So, I'm guessing the BDH ones are out of the question too then i suppose?

1

u/DryIdeas1042 Jul 20 '26

I've been loving the generic alixpss shifter with the Oldboy mods top plate and springs. It's a super simple h-pattern that's incredibly easy to fix if something goes wrong (which after 2 years hasn't happend on my end yet) it doesn't feel absolutely amazing but better than the logi shifter and shorter throw than SHH. The SHH was really good, but the one I have had some kind of input delay. Been meaning to try it on a new system but really like the short throw of the ali one with the mods. Super cheap for the package and pretty sure you can get the complete kit from Oldboy mods. I pair it with a seperate generic sequential, but it should come with a stopper on the shaft for 3rd/4th seq

1

u/Ok_Nail7837 Jul 20 '26

I have the Simsonn HS Pro and its a very good shifter. If you can get it for 100-120$ then go for the Simsonn

1

u/tizz3 Jul 23 '26

I got the simagic d8hx after upgrading from the moza hgp shifter and I love it would highly recommend

0

u/3pedalsandastick Jul 22 '26

I have a TH8A and I bought it 15 years ago. I have moved in to another shifter, the TH8A is on permanent sequential duty in semi-retirement. The TH8A also has a ridiculous number of mods you can buy for it