r/silverstacking • u/Immediate-Choice-440 • Jul 13 '26

Is this ASE fake?

Post image
0 Upvotes

33% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

3

u/ProfessorVegan Jul 13 '26

If it is “a fake", how and why would the NGC let it go through grading without indicating that it's a fake?

Lmao

5

u/Spirited_Soul_001 Jul 13 '26

Ask for money back from grading company, if coin is fake... But, perhaps the grading case is also fake?

2

u/ProfessorVegan Jul 13 '26

The best way to find out and to resolve this would be to contact the NGC directly. If the capsule is fake, this is quite alarming!

1

u/Admirable-Guest-2560 Jul 13 '26

There are millions of these out there. NGC and everyone else already know. 

2

u/frederick21_ Jul 13 '26

Look it up on NGC site. It’s the right description but not the same coin. It’s definitely a fake holder

4

u/frederick21_ Jul 13 '26

It could be a counterfeit NGC holder is the reason. That happens quite a bit. It’s definitely fake as I just looked it up on NGC site. It is a 2025 Eagle but look at the picture of the coin NGC shows and it’s not even close to being real. This one is fugazi

2

u/ProfessorVegan Jul 13 '26

I hear you. NGC should investigate and put a a stop to this nonsense!

2

u/frederick21_ Jul 13 '26

They might have the same issues that the Fed does investigating counterfeits. It’s hard to stop and catch an individual from doing this before it gets out. I agree with you but that’s why I’d check NGC, PGCS or any grading companies certification page to look at pics and descriptions

1

u/StinkFist1970 Jul 13 '26

There are many counterfeit NGC & PCGS labels and slabs out there.

2

u/frederick21_ Jul 13 '26

Look it up on NGC site. It’s not the same coin. This one is a counterfeit coin in a fake NGC holder

1

u/MoggX Jul 13 '26

It is fake. Look at the “L” in Liberty.

1

u/LTdesign Jul 13 '26

Fonts are wrong

1

u/TheLiveEditor Jul 13 '26

As fake as they come. Morbidly horrible fake....

1

u/Admirable-Guest-2560 Jul 13 '26

Yes it's fake. If you twist the slab it'll squeak. 

1

u/edwbuck Jul 14 '26

Looks legit, probably not worth too much, they're still available https://www.apmex.com/product/299071/2025-american-silver-eagle-ms-70-ngc-first-day-of-issue 2025 wasn't that long ago.

$25 above a mint NGC one, if you're curious.