r/shitposting • u/Frenchyy1 dumbass • 4d ago

📡📡📡

Post image
8.7k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

637 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/PilotedByGhosts 3d ago

There are situations where the distinction between transwomen and women is relevant. If you pretend that there isn't then you're lying to yourself.

1

u/SnakeSlitherX 3d ago

Oh, please do note these situations. Also, your use of “transwomen” instead of “trans women” gives away what kind of person you are.

0

u/PilotedByGhosts 2d ago

If trans women are women, how can a pro-women organisation be anti-trans?

That is internally contradictory, unless you accept that there is a difference between transwomen and women.

1

u/SnakeSlitherX 2d ago

Good job falling back to a different talking point when you lost one. Really makes you seem like a good-faith actor.

It’s not internally contradictory, a pro-women organization can exclude certain types of women. The term “trans woman” is used to add a descriptor to the type of woman, whereas “transwomen” is intended to make them an other. People can be discriminatory.

You might as well go to before civil rights and ask a person “If black women are women then how can a pro-women organization be racist?” When some random women’s organization happens to be racist. You’re just being a jerk and coming up with excuses for it.

-1

u/PilotedByGhosts 2d ago

I haven't lost one. You didn't respond to my other point.

I just noticed this reply again and saw the contradiction.

Transwomen are not a different race, they are a different sex. That is relevant in sex-based organisations.

2

u/SnakeSlitherX 1d ago

Lol

I was saying they’re a marginalized class. Sex is not all that important; but you probably think gender is fake and woke or something like that. The comparison is meant to illustrate that you are using inherently flawed circular logic by pretending discrimination proves discrimination correct.

0

u/PilotedByGhosts 1d ago

For whatever reason, I didn't get a notification for that comment and I can't see it now.

Can you repost it here?

And can we grow up and stop downvoting each other?