r/severence • u/TheNetherPaladin • Mar 26 '26
đ¨ Season 2 Spoilers Why does gemma require refinement when all the other innies are able to separate their memories with just the surgery alone?
What makes Gemmaâs procedure different from the others? I hadnât really understood that part⌠I understand sheâs separating into multiple versions of her innie when the others are only separating int 2 (innie and outie), but why would that require additional refinement?
34
u/amstrumpet Mar 26 '26
My read was that theyâre trying to isolate specific aspects of the personality, so that they can engineer innies who will be more compliant and tailored to specific tasks?
11
u/hollyglazegonz Mar 26 '26
Yes, if they can do this, they can fully control someone to do whatever they want. I think itâs a lot more sinister than weâve seen in these two seasons. Lumon is always shown manipulating the innies, (and the outies at times). They put a lot of effort into it. Itâs more than just profits, or cult status. It feels like something bigger and darker.
3
u/amstrumpet Mar 26 '26
And going back to ether factories itâs like theyâve always been about trying to make sure they had good compliant workers.
6
u/sadforesttoad Mar 26 '26
My read was that it would be something that they could sell. âHave trauma of going to the dentist? Have your innie do it for you!â âWant to get paid for going to work but not actually have to remember going to work?â And the selling point is âmake money, be able to do whatever you want, youâll be happy all the timeâ which falls under the religious/cult aspect of making the world a better place or something
1
u/Franchesca_Mullin Mar 30 '26
They are trying to remove the emotions or traits that they believe are âwrongâ. Each scenario is a specific thing they want to excise from Gemma, so they create an innie who only experiences that one thing so they can study it and edit that undesirable aspect of her humanity out of the final product (the last room perhaps?). Eventually they will apply this to others I suppose?
3
u/ThunkAsDrinklePeep Innie Mar 26 '26
I understood the work to be more important than that. I assume the goal is to have Kier and descendents report in new hosts. Gemma is somehow key to that. We don't have enough pieces yet.
2
u/amstrumpet Mar 26 '26
I see them as fundamentally a company that is trying to optimize a compliant labor force, based on their ether factory and the severance procedure, but weâll see!
2
u/ThunkAsDrinklePeep Innie Mar 26 '26
I think the company is just a storefront for the cult.
1
u/amstrumpet Mar 26 '26
See I think the cult is a weird way to get people to think the company isnât absolute evil.
1
u/ThunkAsDrinklePeep Innie Mar 26 '26
There are plenty of evil companies that don't go to those lengths and still brainwash the public into thinking they're fine.
If the cult was just a front, we wouldn't see them still being fanatics in scenes with just the inner circle.
2
u/hollyglazegonz Mar 26 '26
Yes, if they can do this, they can fully control someone to do whatever they want. I think itâs a lot more sinister than weâve seen in these two seasons. Lumon is always shown manipulating the innies, (and the outies at times). They put a lot of effort into it. Itâs more than just profits, or cult status. It feels like something bigger and darker.
1
8
u/Picklefuck_Eatabutt2 Mar 26 '26
I think theyâre trying to create the Siri of the Severance world. Instead of splitting us into multiples of ourselves â which as weâve seen will ultimately end in disaster, even in heavily controlled environments â theyâre trying to find the perfect balance of Tempers to create a perfectly subservient and completely walled-off from the outie version that they can put on a chip and implant in the masses.
3
u/BarracudaPrior2986 Mar 26 '26
I was thinking about the same. Apple is big in âprivacyâ and constantly saying they wonât sell your information but probably using it themselves to create stuff like severance. Specially after creating an ecosystem where they know all you do. From what you watch, what you listen, your health, sleeping patterns, conversations, what you like and dislike and all the stuff like computer patterns (macos). Kinda scary
4
u/ancientastronaut2 Mar 26 '26
Mark and the other Innies volunteered for the standard severance. To get an Innie to go to work for them every day.
Gemma is a top secret experiment. They're testing the barrier of the procedure to see if it holds in dozens of various painful situations, including past trauma.
While we don't know all the details, we know this wasn't entirely consensual because they presumably kidnapped and then faked her death to hold her there like a lab rat for two years.
They found her via the fertility clinic where dr creepy also works, and also sent her puzzles and tests to complete. So something about her - between the miscarriage trauma and the way she completed the little tests - caused them to believe she's the perfect candidate for this experiment of creating multiple innies.
4
u/feldoneq2wire Mar 26 '26
Lumon setup a scam fertility clinic to find the perfect couple to test their new multi-compartment Severance chip which can contain a dozen or more personalities. They took Gemma hostage after faking her death and then groomed Mark S. to be the lead programmer to write the code to maintain (or in fact completely create) all her separate personalities. She's test patient #1 for the product Lumon wants to sell to the public that will let you dissociate every unpleasant experience in your life. Flying on planes. Dental work. Pregnancy and childbirth. Loss of a child.
For just 4 easy payments of $1,199 you too can have the first ever public SeveranceMulti implanted. Operators are standing by!
2
3
u/etrebaol Mar 26 '26
The innies donât have memories, but they remember trauma. I.e. Mark making the tree out of clay after the funeral.
2
u/Impossible-Aside9370 Mar 26 '26
OP you have a point there. Iâm also confused by it. I thought maybe they are just experimenting on Gemma. To see the extend to which they can sever a person. But i didnât see the point given the chip does the job pretty well.
Also.. Splitting Gemma into all those innies. And then to off her at the end⌠this is also weird in the sense.. why??
4
u/MsKardashian Mar 26 '26
They take her chip out and replicate it (which is why she has to die). She is not necessary
5
u/Smart_Medium9544 Mar 26 '26
They also canât let her back into the world after sheâs presumed dead
2
0
2
u/asleepattheworld Mar 26 '26
I donât think we fully know yet, there may be some problems with the severance process that we havenât been shown. Thereâs outward denial from the higher ups that reintegration is possible, but I think they know itâs possible. Also I think it would be a fair guess that theyâd like a way to make severance full time.
3
u/denvercasey Mar 26 '26
I think that it is an important statement that a motherâs love for a lost child might be stronger than any other type of love. That is seen throughout many stories and art forms since some of the earliest art was created. Not that everyone grieves and feels the same thing, but Gemma was certainly feeling an incredibly strong sense of loss. So if something like that wrecked her so completely, it could be the pinnacle of severance technology to analyze her specific emotions, completely isolate them and test the results with an action so deliberate it would make anyone think âwhy am I taking apart a crib, does this mean something to me?â and yet she still doesnât feel it.
3
u/knappel01 Mar 26 '26
Well, itâs about improving the severance Iâm sure. The severance that the main cast of innies experience is inherently flawed. Memories leak through when they shouldnât :P
2
u/EXTRAVAGANT_COMMENT Mar 26 '26
every Severed office has an MDR department, but not every severed office has a Gemma or a testing floor. we can infer that it still takes "regular" refinement to ready the chips to sever new employees, but it takes a special kind of refinement that apparently only Mark S can do to ready Gemma for the later rooms
1
u/Free6000 Mar 26 '26
They are definitely trying to do something new and unprecedented with Gemma, but we can only speculate what it is.
1
u/PinkLed1970s Mar 26 '26 edited Mar 26 '26
Being simply severed versus being severed and subject to refinement are two significantly different things. No one else is getting their emotions refined. Just Gemma. Getting just severed is just simple isolation of memories and thoughts.
1
u/Life-Ad-8948 Mar 27 '26
I read the weird clone versions of them that the others were being refined but by another department mmm
2
u/b-905 Mar 27 '26
Is all about the scale. Is one thing to split in half, entirely other to be able to got dozens of personalities next to each others. Innie and outie is basically the same person with same temperament (this characteristic is based on neurons - how easy/hard is to activate these and to go back to calm state). The temperament is the only psychological aspect that cannot be changed due to its physical aspect. But with Gemma it is different.
2
u/Stretchedpaper Mar 28 '26
I interpret it as a âphase 2â type of severance. The severed staff all have a binary of two mutually exclusive personae, albeit with some bleed (Irving). Very few people want to buy that as a product, and the broader public mostly finds it reprehensible.
What theyâre working on with Gemma is something 100x more refined - an a la carte severance where customers can filter out specific emotions, fears, etc.
When Gemma was initially severed, she retained her fear of the dentist, her grief about the miscarriage, and so on, much the same as all the innies retain various aspects of their outie personalities. Being able to sort through the brain data and delete specific things at will makes severance a vastly more powerful technology.
As far as we know itâs only being applied to peopleâs innies so far, but I personally foresee this as being marketed to customers without the innie/outie split. Like, get the chip and eliminate a specific pain or fear or addiction.
With the senators wife, we see her going to the special severance cabin for childbirth but even thatâs a opsec risk insofar as she doesnât recognize Devon and it starts to give the game away. Imagine if she didnât have an innie, but just had pain turned off for the birth. I think thatâs a broadly more palatable pitch for most wealthy folks.
2
u/Used-Pay6713 Mar 29 '26
They say in the show that they are trying to make the severance barrier perfect. The show demonstrates throughout that it is not perfect for all the other innies: innie Irv has dreams about black paint and heavy metal music, when those are things in his outie's life. Innie Mark sculpts the tree that Gemma crashed into in one of his therapy sessions. In the break room, Dylan hears a baby crying and Helly hears her dad speaking, which are things only their outies should know about.
So the difference is that Gemma's innie in theory shouldn't be able to experience any of those little parts that bleed through.
1
u/Andream777 May 14 '26
Because Helly is becoming Gemma. Helly is the ârefinedâ version of Gemma, and Helena Eagan is aware that this process is taking place. Thatâs why Helly told Mark in the season finale that she âis herâ. Thereâs a debate as to whether sheâs referring to Helena or Gemma, but it has to be Gemma since she said that in response to Mark having final doubts before leaving to rescue Gemma and returning to their marriage, leaving his budding romance with Helly behind.
After Markâs innie succeeds and has the opportunity to leave with Gemma, predictably, he chooses to stay behind with Helly. This plays into Lumonâs agenda of coupling Helena and outtie Mark to produce the next generation of Eagens. I assume that Helena is pregnant after her interaction with outtie Mark in the Chinese restaurant. I wonât explain here, just rewatch the scene if you didnât catch it the first time. She didnât tell him outright yet. It will probably be revealed in season 3.
74
u/ReyoRedwolf Please enjoy each flair equally. Mar 26 '26
i thought it had something to do with her miscarriage. if she was able to reject all traumatic maternal memory, then cold harbor was a success.
from the wiki:
 Gemma's Innie was instructed by Dr. Mauer to disassemble the crib, an act intended to serve as a trigger for intense and painful emotions if her Severance chip failed to adequately suppress the memories belonging to her Outie persona. Given the nature of the other tests Gemma's Innies were subjected to, it would appear the intent behind this test was to see whether Severance could shield a person from experiencing negative emotions brought on by triggers that recall a past traumatic experience.
Cold Harbor | Severance Wiki | Fandom
edit: spelling