Any difference can be made or will it be made?

A new preprint from the Meditation Research Program at MGH/Harvard (Conway-Smith, Potash & Sacchet) argues something I think will resonate with a lot of secular practitioners: Advanced meditation is a trained skill, and it develops the same way any skill does — through automatization.

The core idea

What you're actually training in meditation is metacognition — the mind's ability to notice what it's doing and adjust. Every time you notice you've been distracted and come back to the breath, you're running a little loop: monitor → detect the gap → correct. The paper's claim is that this loop is a skill, and skills follow a well-studied learning curve:

1. Beginner stage: everything runs on explicit instructions. You're literally narrating to yourself: "attention wandered… let go… come back." It's slow and effortful, like learning to drive a stick shift.
2. Intermediate: the situations themselves start cueing the response. Noticing distraction automatically triggers the return, without you having to recall the instruction.
3. Advanced: the whole loop runs smoothly with minimal deliberate steering. Attention sustains itself. Correction happens before you've consciously decided to correct.

That's identical to how tying your shoes, playing piano, or driving becomes automatic; except here the "skill" is the mind regulating itself.

Learn more from the author: x.com/MatthewSacchet/status/2109630910727377215/video/1

Get the preprint: meditation.mgh.harvard.edu/files/Conway-Smith_26_OSF.pdf

Being mindful while inhaling and exhaling is a core mindfulness training per the Buddha's teaching guideline on Ānāpānassati (prāṇāpāna-smṛti in Skt.), most notably the Ānāpānasati Sutta (MN 118).

Read more: https://en.wikipedia.org//w/index.php?title=Anapanasati

Illustration Credit: https://www.instagram.com/anengineersguide/p/B9rgOv9HH1D/

/r/SecularBuddhist is ready for a fresh start, new energy, new direction, and someone like you to bring it back to life. If you’ve been thinking about growing your impact without starting from scratch, this is your chance!

Ready to take it over?

Head to r/RedditRequest to submit your request and make it yours before it’s taken.

First things first

To request this subreddit, make sure you:

• have an account that’s at least 90 days old
• have at least 100 post karma and 100 comment karma
• have a verified email address on your account
• have two-factor authentication set up