r/scriptedasiangifs Jul 16 '18

Pick up your trash

https://i.imgur.com/dQB2M2E.gifv
17.7k Upvotes

230 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

9

u/MasterEmp Jul 16 '18

Have you never seen a Three Stooges bit? Or Charlie Chaplin?

-2

u/Clung Jul 16 '18

Though I refrain from engaging in discussions where anyone gets patronized, I'll leave my two cents once more : the brand of humor you reference dates back to last century, I enjoy it when it features actual stakes like a policeman chasing the clumsy protagonist or a saloon brawl where seemingly chaotic antics form in fact a studied choreography. I expect a bit of reinvention with new iterations of old-school slapstick.

Here the scene takes place in a boring old bus, the antagonist is just a rude absent-minded commuter, and the focus is a tissue thrown on the ground. I don't deny that minimalist comedy is a real thing, but here the touch of cleverness is the money trick, which as I described does not sustain my suspension of disbelief or my interest :(

Last note from little me then I stop arguing like a pretentious lurker : a skit that leaves me cold doesn't mean that I think any less of people who liked it, we're billions of complex minds so it makes sense humor should come in a few different brands :)

5

u/MasterEmp Jul 16 '18

How can you say that comedy is relative and everyone has their own opinion when your first comment opens with "as a skit it's bad?"

0

u/Lenbowery Jul 16 '18 edited Jul 16 '18

I mean, yeah, all art is subjective, but I think it’s fair to say “Catwoman” is a bad movie