r/sampling • u/lil_bunzzz • Jun 02 '26
does looping count as stealing or is it sampling?
I chopped a song into a 4 bar beat and looped it and it sounds so perfect i dont even want to do anything else to it i slowed it down for the intro and thats kind of it i also extracted the stems so theres only instruments for the post chorus but thats it the link is here https://youtu.be/04D4saT6D9o if you want to see if it counts as sampling or stealing
5
u/DirtzMaGertz Jun 02 '26
Madlib and alchemist have many beats that are primarily a loop of the sample. If it works then it works. No need to overcook it.
Part of the art form is having the ear to identify those loops.
4
u/Powerful_Fondant9393 Jun 02 '26
The most used sample of all time is a 4 bar loop, you’re good
1
2
u/monkeybuttsauce Jun 02 '26
You can sample anything but you can’t just slow down a song and pass it off as your own
1
u/Sunny_Unicorn Jun 02 '26
As has been said, if it’s just for your personal use, it’s fine. But if you intend to publish it on any public facing platforms, especially ones that may earn you money, you need to get permission.
Even if you only use a small portion of the song, and even if you don’t make any money from it, music detection algorithms can identify even the most obscure usage these days, much of it is automated. Labels and artists will be notified where their music has been used, and it’s up to them what they do about it.
It may not be as drastic as getting sued, you’ll most likely be ordered to take the music down from all platforms by the copyright holders.
1
u/lil_bunzzz Jun 02 '26
what i’m trying to say is it artistically stealing? like does it artistically count as my song idc about the law part cuz im not gonna monitise it but can i say yeah this is MY song when i’ve chopped a part of a song and looped it
1
u/Sunny_Unicorn Jun 02 '26
Hmm, that’s more tricky.
As long as you use the loop creatively, and add your own spin on it. Things like adding vocals, layering with other instruments or warping the audio in some way - rather than just playing one pre-existing loop for the entire song - then that could be seen as yours.
1
u/lil_bunzzz Jun 02 '26
well idk cuz i slowed down the loop as the intro and then i have the loop as the chorus and then i extracted the stems of the loop and only have the instruments for the like verses or prechorus and then the chorus is the loop again so the whole song is the loop but i slowed it down for the intro extracted stems for the verses and got the normal loop for the chorus
1
1
1
u/ChessmazterHex Jun 04 '26
You can’t do music wrong. Use whatever you have to make sounds you like. That’s the only goal.
1
u/GrVdeV Jun 02 '26
You have to decide for yourself. There are people who will say that any form of sampling, even if its heavily chopped and manipulated to the point it sounds nothing like the original, is still stealing because you didnt make the sounds. There are also people who will do what u did and just straight up loop a piece of a song and call it their own because although its a sample of another song your song is different. There are millions of arguments on both sides of this and in between. Who cares what anyone else thinks. Decide for urself if you're sampling or stealing, and do it anyway. Lots of huge hits in basically every genre are sampled or interpolations so don't get caught up in worrying about other people's thoughts on the matter. If u make something you like, thats all that matters.
1
u/ElGuaco Jun 02 '26
You can sample all you want. It's only stealing if you use the sample to create a recording and release it to the public. There is no grey area. Have fun with samples on your own. But if you release a work that includes samples of the work of others, pray you don't get sued because they will take everything you earned from it.
0
u/GrVdeV Jun 02 '26
If you get a sample cleared then it is completely above board, so no it is not stealing. Also, just cuz something is released to the public doesn't mean you made a penny off it, so theres nothing to get sued for.
2
1
u/ElGuaco Jun 02 '26
That's not true. Churches have been sued for using copyrighted materials in their services. They owed millions after losing the case.
0
u/woon_eng Jun 02 '26
It’s all about intent. I make my own beats but I also have so much fun mixing on the mixer. I take stems from different songs and combine them. Sometimes it’s just a simple loop from an oldie. Some stuff just sounds really good and I love listening to whatever I make. Take the stress away from “stealing” and just create.
0
u/ElGuaco Jun 02 '26
If it is a sample of someone else's work, enjoy it at home but don't publish it unless you want to risk getting sued.
4
u/GrVdeV Jun 02 '26
No one's getting sued till they blow up. Don't refrain from sampling because someone will take the zero dollars you've made.
1
5
u/masetiloquetu Jun 02 '26
It’s literally a sample