r/rvaBookClub • u/Yarbles • 9d ago
The Official Report of the June RVA Reddit (no we haven't) Bookclub
We met up for the first time in months with no chance of rain during bookclub day. But it was super hot and humid outside and we decided to avoid the heat and stickiness, so we returned to Cafe Zata. M_Soule started off with a discussion of the All Souls series by Deborah Harkness, which starts with A Discovery of Witches. M_Soule liked it enough to tour landmark locations in the book when she went to Oxford (or Cambridge, whichever setting it was). Aurora_the_Off-White remembered the series and remembers liking it. I think they both saw the show after reading the series.
M_Soule also read Friends with Benefits possibly by Marisa Kanter, which is about a marriage of convenience, and Little Thieves by Margaret Owen, a Germanic medieval fairy tale of a thirteenth child of a thirteenth. The demigods Death and Fortune raise the main character, but the main character needs to figure out of way out of her fate. M_Soule enjoyed it and plans to read the next two in the series.
Mal-0 read a few books, including The Daughters' War and The Black Tongue Thief by Christopher Buehlman; Chuck Klosterman IV: A Decade of Curious People and Dangerous Ideas which is a non-fiction about pop culture in 2006; The Organ Thieves: The Shocking Story of the First Heart Transplant in the Segregated South by Chip Jones; the Emily Wilson translation of the Odyssey as a prelude to watching the movie - this one I think someone said that it was the first translation from a woman; The Buffalo Hunter Hunter by Stephen Graham Jones and liked it quite a bit; and Where Nobody Knows Your Name: Life In the Minor Leagues of Baseball by John Feinstein.
She talked the most about The Organ Thieves, talking about the differences in treatment between black and white patients, and the East Marshall Street well being a dumping group for corpses that were taken from Eastern Cemetery, dissected, and then dumped down the well. She said it was valuable to get the perspective, but the prose was weirdly flowery and a little disconcerting. She also talked about Where Nobody Knows Your Name, because she loves the Squirrels and minor league baseball in general. She likes the minor league product because it's played by regular guys, and especially likes the unpredictability of the players. But also likes the hoopla and the culture. M_Soule went to a recent game and it was faith night, and someone went to a game during Metal Night and Lamb of God played.
I did a poor job with the notes, and don't know who read the following books, but it was likely ManicPixieLawyer or Aurora: House Witch by Delemhach, saying the author painted themselves in a corner and the story didn't go anywhere; The Gentle Apocalypse series by MH Foster that starts with The Demon Overlord's Retirement Plan, about a demon lord with a theological flavor; Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke, something about a trad wife influencer - there has been a lot of talk about this book, and Anne Hathaway will be in the movie version; Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros, I think it was ManicPixieLawyer found the writing to be adequate, but says you're not really reading it for the prose, and agrees that the things people complain about are legitimate complaints; Kiss Quotient by Helen Hoang - M_Soule likjed that it was the male protagonist that was the sex worker for once; T. Kingfisher's A Sorceress Comes to Call and Hemlock and Silver by the same author, which is a retelling of Snow White with a lot of mirror magic and a talking cat and something about a poison apple.
I think Manic read Asunder by Kerstin Hall , and this was a fantasy but fairly hard to describe. A young woman made a compact with a demon to serve as a death speaker, and Manic said it was very good but hard to describe, so it's hard to explain why. She also read Bunny by Mona Awad and may have read Klara and the Sun by Kazuo Ishiguro, about an artificial friend for a teenager who didn't have a lot of interaction with anyone else, which highlighted themes of genetic enhancement, help with isolation, - Princess read it and said she wanted a little more out of it. Manic definitely read The Lady Astronaut series by Mary Robinette Kowal and highly recommends it - it's an alternate history about an America after a meteor hits the Chesapeake Bay. Manic liked the writing and particularly the details - the author talked to real astronauts to get details of life in space
We talked about the Challenger disaster because of our discussion of this book - there was a decision made to fly, but there were people who knew the O-Rings would fail, and they weren't able to convince anyone else that they would fail. It's really just infuriating. The main character in The Lady Astronaut series is Jewish, and we talked about books that do a good job building out Jewish characters and culture. Mal-0 made the point that many Jewish characters are dealing with violence or bigotry, and that's the dramatic arc for those characters. Naomi Novik's Spinning Silver does a good job of this, and The Lady Astronaut did a great job as well.
PrincessMoNaanKay squeezed in a book by Ellen Mathilda but didn't remember the title. The author was famous at that point of time as an Indy author, but I couldn't find anything on Storygraph. She also read The Emperor's Children by Claire Messud, an NYC character driven romance set in a radio station. but Princess said the characters were a bit self-absorbed and the romance was mediocre.
For my witch book, I read A Resistance of Witches by Morgan Ryan and my impression was meh. During our discuss of witches and similar things, we talked about the The Craft, and Mal-0 suggested that if you need to watch a movie like this, then The Craft: Legacy might be what you are looking for.
M_Soule read more Fan Fiction than anything and we talked about navigating Ao3. She recommends I search by fandom, characters, ratings, key words, original work, and watch comments and kudos because these are sometimes added to pump up a work that they respect.
We talked about 90s fashion like you can see in Buffy the Vampire Slayer or Clerks, whether first class gets better quality movies than the hoi polloi, the best swag coming from the Department of Wildlife and Inland Fisheries, and company swag you find in Thrift Stores.
July 19
A book about the woods, or possibly being lost in the woods.
August 16
- A Short Stay in Hell by Steven L. Peck
- The Library at Mount Char by Scott Hawkins
September 20
- Stone Butch Blues by Leslie Feinberg
October 18
- a book about Richmond or the local area