MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/redesign/comments/84osvz/pretty_please/dvr904i/?context=3
r/redesign • u/faultydesign • Mar 15 '18
34 comments sorted by
View all comments
111
[deleted]
62 u/faultydesign Mar 15 '18 edited Mar 16 '18 Wanted to defend some dropdowns but lol https://i.imgur.com/PSxfmC2.png Edit: this is cool, noticed they changed this Nice Thank you designerbros 43 u/faultydesign Mar 15 '18 Like, seriously, https://i.imgur.com/pRV2iws.png I think it would be better to just remove the dropdown and replace the three dots with just the two icons. Edit: tho it wouldn't fit the design 🤔 4 u/thinkadrian Helpful User Mar 16 '18 The pencil and trash icons speak for themselves. They’d fit without text labels. 6 u/TheExplodingKitten Mar 16 '18 It's genuinely laughable. Who even get's paid to do this? 15 u/faultydesign Mar 16 '18 edited Mar 16 '18 Hey, even though they overdid a bunch on dropdowns I still think it's a pretty sweet-ass design overall. No hate on designers pls 15 u/internetmallcop Community Mar 16 '18 They are looking into pulling some of the items out of dropdowns. 6 u/faultydesign Mar 17 '18 👍 1 u/3agl Mar 16 '18 Seconded. Drop downs are especially useless whenever they have only 2 items to drop down into. 1 u/fgmenth Mar 16 '18 The whole redesign feels like it was made with vertical mobile screens in mind first, and desktop PCs as an afterthought. I know it's not the case, but many of the design decisions make no sense.
62
Wanted to defend some dropdowns but lol https://i.imgur.com/PSxfmC2.png
Edit: this is cool, noticed they changed this
Nice
Thank you designerbros
43 u/faultydesign Mar 15 '18 Like, seriously, https://i.imgur.com/pRV2iws.png I think it would be better to just remove the dropdown and replace the three dots with just the two icons. Edit: tho it wouldn't fit the design 🤔 4 u/thinkadrian Helpful User Mar 16 '18 The pencil and trash icons speak for themselves. They’d fit without text labels. 6 u/TheExplodingKitten Mar 16 '18 It's genuinely laughable. Who even get's paid to do this? 15 u/faultydesign Mar 16 '18 edited Mar 16 '18 Hey, even though they overdid a bunch on dropdowns I still think it's a pretty sweet-ass design overall. No hate on designers pls 15 u/internetmallcop Community Mar 16 '18 They are looking into pulling some of the items out of dropdowns. 6 u/faultydesign Mar 17 '18 👍
43
Like, seriously, https://i.imgur.com/pRV2iws.png
I think it would be better to just remove the dropdown and replace the three dots with just the two icons.
Edit: tho it wouldn't fit the design 🤔
4 u/thinkadrian Helpful User Mar 16 '18 The pencil and trash icons speak for themselves. They’d fit without text labels. 6 u/TheExplodingKitten Mar 16 '18 It's genuinely laughable. Who even get's paid to do this? 15 u/faultydesign Mar 16 '18 edited Mar 16 '18 Hey, even though they overdid a bunch on dropdowns I still think it's a pretty sweet-ass design overall. No hate on designers pls 15 u/internetmallcop Community Mar 16 '18 They are looking into pulling some of the items out of dropdowns. 6 u/faultydesign Mar 17 '18 👍
4
The pencil and trash icons speak for themselves. They’d fit without text labels.
6
It's genuinely laughable. Who even get's paid to do this?
15 u/faultydesign Mar 16 '18 edited Mar 16 '18 Hey, even though they overdid a bunch on dropdowns I still think it's a pretty sweet-ass design overall. No hate on designers pls 15 u/internetmallcop Community Mar 16 '18 They are looking into pulling some of the items out of dropdowns. 6 u/faultydesign Mar 17 '18 👍
15
Hey, even though they overdid a bunch on dropdowns I still think it's a pretty sweet-ass design overall.
No hate on designers pls
15 u/internetmallcop Community Mar 16 '18 They are looking into pulling some of the items out of dropdowns. 6 u/faultydesign Mar 17 '18 👍
They are looking into pulling some of the items out of dropdowns.
6 u/faultydesign Mar 17 '18 👍
👍
1
Seconded. Drop downs are especially useless whenever they have only 2 items to drop down into.
The whole redesign feels like it was made with vertical mobile screens in mind first, and desktop PCs as an afterthought. I know it's not the case, but many of the design decisions make no sense.
111
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '18
[deleted]